The Guardian
· collected 2026-09-17 · by Anna Bawden Health and social affairs corresponent
Proposals to limit the number of patients being formally diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder have been atacked as “rationing” healthcare and pushing children and adults to self-diagnosis via social media.
asserted
Proposals → limit → media
The comments came before a government review due next week, which is expected to say that patients with ADHD symptoms should not automatically be formally diagnosed, but should be “triaged” and offered support without the need for a formal diagnosis.
asserted
patients → come → diagnosis
Details of this “needs-based” system, first revealed in the Times, would mean NHS services target those most acutely affected by ADHD, such as those at risk of self-harm or unable to work.
asserted
services → base → harm
Less severely affected people may not be referred for a formal diagnosis to NHS clinics but would be offered help according to a “holistic” assessment of their needs, the report will say.
uncertain
report → affect → needs
The government’s independent review of mental health conditions, autism and ADHD was commissioned in December by the then health secretary, Wes Streeting, amid concerns over the sharp rise of people making sickness benefit claims due to mental health, autism and ADHD diagnoses.
uncertain
review → commission → diagnoses
Led by Prof Peter Fonagy, a clinical psychologist and psychoanalyst at University College London, the interim review concluded that the system forces children and adults to obtain a formal diagnosis in order to get support.
asserted
system → lead → support
Official figures show that patients are waiting years to be assessed, with 800,000 on NHS waiting lists.
asserted
patients → show → lists
Meanwhile, complaints about autism and ADHD services in England have more than tripled in five years.
asserted
complaints → triple → years
As a result, growing numbers of adults and young people with ADHD are not in education, training or work, of whom about 100,000 are on health-related benefits due to their condition.
asserted
100,000 → grow → condition
The ADHD taskforce calculated that the cost of undiagnosed, untreated ADHD was £17bn.
asserted
cost → calculate → ADHD
Fonagy’s review will recommend that only patients who would benefit from a formal diagnosis, such as those needing medication, would be referred to ADHD clinics.
asserted
who → recommend → clinics
Under the proposed holistic needs-based assessment, patients would be triaged according to their difficulties and ability to cope at school, college, work or other settings.
uncertain
patients → propose → school
They would be offered targeted early support, regardless of whether they had a diagnosis or not.
asserted
they → offer → diagnosis
Such support could include one-to-one help for children to cope with lessons, quiet rooms in schools, classes to help parents support children with ADHD symptoms, and encouraging employers to offer staff with ADHD flexible hours.
uncertain
parents → include → hours
The final report is expected to propose a similarly holistic approach to supporting people with autism, and to mental health more widely.
asserted
report → expect → health
But experts said the proposals would in effect introduce rationing of health services and that schools and workplaces are already able to offer early support without a formal diagnosis.
asserted
schools → say → diagnosis
Henry Shelford, the chief executive of ADHD UK, said: “This [review] proposes rationing.
asserted
review → say → rationing
Diagnosis requires evidence of a debilitating impact on your life.
asserted
Diagnosis → require → life
We already have a clinically drawn line of need.
asserted
We → have → need
“Without a formal diagnosis, it appears we will be left to self-diagnose via social media.
asserted
we → appear → media
Schools and businesses shouldn’t be forced to rely on TikTok to know when to put in adjustments and support.”
asserted
Schools → force → adjustments
“On average, a woman with ADHD will die nine years younger than her peers.
asserted
woman → die → peers
A man with ADHD will die seven years younger than his peers.
asserted
man → die → peers
In almost any other area, those numbers would have this treated as a health emergency, but the stigma and misunderstanding around ADHD means instead we’re treated as an inconvenience and proposed to be ‘disappeared’, untreated, from the waiting lists.
asserted
we → have → lists
“Diagnosis means people turning their lives around, more people in employment and succeeding in careers.
asserted
people → mean → careers
Investing in ADHD services has a high return on investment to the country.
asserted
Investing → invest → country
Last year, the NHS spent £574m on a single weight-loss drug because treating people gets them back to work.
asserted
treating → spend → work
Mel Merritt, the head of policy and influencing at the National Autistic Society, said: “Denying people a diagnosis will only worsen inequalities experienced.”
asserted
Denying → say → inequalities
A government spokesperson would not comment on the forthcoming report, but said: “Last December, we asked clinical psychologist Prof Peter Fonagy to lead an independent review, examining the prevalence of – and support for – ADHD, autism, and mental health conditions.
asserted
we → comment → prevalence
Prof Fonagy’s final report will be published shortly and will inform our new national approach in this area.”
asserted
report → publish → area
The Aporia
