Guaranteed income programs do not work and amount to mere "redistributions of wealth," according to Michigan Republican state Rep. Jay DeBoyer, who joined other Republicans in the state Legislature in criticizing the programs, which have gained prominence in recent years.
uncertain
which → guarantee → years
When does that stop?"
asserted
that → stop → ?
Michigan State Rep. Jay DeBoyer, R-Clay Township, told Fox News Digital.
asserted
DeBoyer → tell → Digital
"When you think about the role of government, the role of government is not to fund people's lives.
asserted
role → think → lives
The role of the government is to provide a conducive environment where you have opportunities for success."
asserted
you → provide → success
DeBoyer, who chairs the state House Oversight Committee, is leading a contingent of Michigan House Republicans demanding rigorous inspection of Rx Kids — a taxpayer-funded initiative billed as the nation's largest prenatal and infant cash assistance program.
asserted
who → chair → program
Lawmakers are raising alarms over how hundreds of millions of public dollars are being spent.
asserted
millions → raise → dollars
The scrutiny boiled over during a June 2 House Oversight Committee hearing, where GOP lawmakers targeted the program’s lack of spending restrictions or income limits.
asserted
lawmakers → boil → restrictions
Republican leaders argue the state-funded initiative has evolved into something far different than what was originally presented to the Legislature, accusing Democrats of using hundreds of millions of dollars in public funding to advance a broader guaranteed-income agenda.
asserted
what → argue → agenda
Michigan House Speaker Matt Hall told Fox News Digital that lawmakers were led to believe they were funding a targeted maternal and prenatal health initiative — not what he characterized as an open-ended social experiment.
asserted
he → tell → experiment
Under the current design, Rx Kids provides expectant mothers with a lump-sum payment of $1,500 during pregnancy, followed by $500 per month for six or 12 months after birth, depending on the participating community, regardless of household income.
asserted
Kids → provide → income
GOP lawmakers across the country have raised similar legal, budgetary, and ideological objections to guaranteed basic income (GBI) and direct cash transfer programs.
asserted
lawmakers → raise → income
In Texas, Attorney General Ken Paxton sued Harris County over its Uplift Harris direct-cash pilot, prompting the Texas Supreme Court to block the payments in 2024.
asserted
Paxton → sue → 2024
Harris County later terminated Uplift Harris and a successor program in June 2025 and moved to reallocate the funds.
asserted
County → terminate → funds
In Arizona, Democratic Gov. Katie Hobbs vetoed Republican-backed legislation that would have prohibited local municipalities and counties from enacting GBI initiatives.
asserted
that → veto → initiatives
Meanwhile, Iowa Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds signed House File 2319 into law on May 1, 2024, banning local guaranteed income programs statewide.
uncertain
Reynolds → sign → programs
The director of Michigan's Rx Kids, Dr. Mona Hanna, told Fox News Digital that the initiative is neither a traditional guaranteed income program nor a universal basic income (UBI) model, pointing to its strict focus on the critical first year of a child's life.
asserted
initiative → tell → life
DeBoyer directly challenged that distinction, pointing to the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) plan.
asserted
DeBoyer → challenge → plan
The state document explicitly defines a "guaranteed income program" as a "cash payment provided on a regular basis to members of a community with no strings attached and no work requirement," citing Rx Kids as a primary example.
asserted
document → define → example
"The truth is this is just about redistribution of wealth," DeBoyer said.
asserted
DeBoyer → say → wealth
"It's a distribution tactic that I would argue is not going to help moms and babies, when that's actually what we should be trying to do.
asserted
we → argue → what
Progressive advocates have pushed back against the Republican offensive.
asserted
advocates → push → offensive
Adriane Brown, senior communications director for the Economic Security Project (ESP) — an advocacy group founded in 2016 to promote direct cash transfers — argued that direct assistance enjoys bipartisan support.
asserted
assistance → found → support
"Cash is widely supported across ideological lines, and there’s long been growing momentum and political appetite for guaranteed income," Brown told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Brown → support → Digital
"The majority of the Michigan Legislature supports this pilot," Brown added.
asserted
Brown → support → pilot
"Republican Senator John DaMoose wrote an op-ed in the Detroit Free Press about how Rx Kids is a pro-life policy and ‘fiscally responsible,’ and the program has been expanded in both urban and rural communities throughout Michigan by both Democrat and Republican leaders.
asserted
program → write → leaders
Brown emphasized that economic pressures on young families necessitate immediate, flexible relief.
asserted
pressures → emphasize → relief
"The bottom line is, people are struggling in our economy," Brown said.
asserted
Brown → struggle → economy
"It’s more expensive than ever to have a child.
asserted
It → ’ → child
In acute moments of vulnerability, people need all the support they can get.
asserted
they → need → support
It doesn’t make sense to malign cash assistance as a partisan idea when so many communities would benefit from the stability it offers."
Meanwhile, the ESP has been pushing for guaranteed income long before affordability became a salient issue.
asserted
affordability → make → income
Founded in 2016, ESP launched with more than "100 entrepreneurs, activists, researchers, and philanthropists" advocating for direct cash payments.
asserted
ESP → found → payments
The ESP helped create over 100 guaranteed income pilots across the U.S.
asserted
ESP → create → U.S.
The broader campaign for direct payments includes Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, led by former Stockton, California, Mayor Michael Tubbs.
asserted
campaign → include → Tubbs
Tubbs, who launched one of the nation's early municipal cash experiments, has long argued that federal tax dollars should fund income supplements to help lower-income Americans keep up with rising inflation, rent and groceries, claiming it's a viable policy to tackle affordability.
asserted
it → launch → affordability
As many guaranteed income advocates would like to make the policy permanent and even pushed at the federal level, only Cook County, Illinois has approved such a measure so far.
asserted
County → like → measure
DeBoyer countered that established social safety nets already exist to support low-income families, but said those programs carry strict eligibility standards and oversight mechanisms that Rx Kids lacks.
asserted
Kids → counter → that
"We have a safety net.
asserted
We → have → net
We spend literally billions of dollars on social welfare," DeBoyer said.
asserted
DeBoyer → spend → welfare
"The difference is, in this particular spending, there are no parameters.
asserted
difference → be → spending
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
