- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
A homeowner whose sea views have been obstructed by an illegal brick wall has lashed out at the developer for applying to replace it with frosted glass.
asserted
views → see → glass
The 16ft by 6ft brick wall was added to a block of luxury flats built in front of Liz Bates' home without permission - and has knocked an estimated £50,000 off the value of her seaside flat, she said.
asserted
she → add → flat
His appeal also failed, with a government planning inspector delivering a damning verdict on the structure.
But instead of demolishing the wall, Mr Fitzsimmons has submitted another application to replace the brick wall with an opaque glass screen.
asserted
Fitzsimmons → fail → screen
To prevent 'mutual overlooking' between the properties, the glass would need to be frosted, therefore keeping Mrs Bates' sea view hidden.
asserted
view → prevent → properties
The application states this would 'not create any harmful impact...on the living conditions of the occupiers of any neighbouring properties'.
asserted
this → state → properties
But Mrs Bates has slammed the developers and said any kind of wall or terrace was illegal and will harm her living conditions.
asserted
kind → slam → conditions
Homeowner Liz Bates, whose sea views were obstructed by an illegal brick wall, has lashed out at the developer after he applied to replace it with frosted glass
Mrs Bates' previous sea view before a block of luxury flats was built in front of her home
The brick 'privacy' wall built illegally at the development (left) and Mrs Bates' balcony (right)
She called on Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole (BCP) Council to carry out enforcement action to make sure the wall is swiftly knocked down and not rebuilt in another form.
asserted
knocked → obstruct → form
She is one of about 100 residents who have claimed their lives have been 'ruined' by the development of four cliff-top apartment blocks of 27 flats in front of their homes in the affluent Southbourne area of Bournemouth, Dorset.
asserted
lives → claim → Bournemouth
Mrs Bates, 42, a property inspector, said: 'It's like hitting your head against a brick wall dealing with this developer.
'
asserted
It → say → developer
They obviously seem to think that two metres will make all the difference to sound and smells travelling.'
asserted
metres → seem → sound
She added: 'I am extremely frustrated that we are once again having to respond to a retrospective planning application for something the developer was explicitly told by the council to stop building when the wall was first started - yet he chose to ignore that advice and continued regardless.
asserted
he → add → advice
For me, the most important issue now is that the council must properly take into account the planning inspector's findings, particularly the very serious concerns raised about the effect of the terrace in this location on noise and nuisance to my property.
asserted
council → take → property
The report provides independent scrutiny of the impact this development has on our home.
asserted
development → provide → home
Those findings cannot simply be brushed aside because the developer has already constructed the terrace and wall.
asserted
developer → brush → terrace
The fact that something has been built does not make its planning impact any less significant.
'
asserted
impact → build → ?
We have already endured a huge amount of stress and disruption as a result of what has happened at this site.
asserted
what → endure → site
What residents need now is for the council to stand firm, apply the planning rules properly and consider the actual harm being caused to existing residents - not simply find a way to retrospectively make unacceptable development acceptable.
asserted
development → need → way
I want the council to look at the full history of this matter, including the developer being told to stop, his decision to carry on regardless, and the planning inspector's findings.
asserted
developer → want → matter
'If the development is unacceptable in planning terms, then I believe the council needs to have the resolve to act accordingly.
asserted
council → believe → resolve
'After everything residents have been through, we are simply asking for the planning system to be respected and for the protection of existing residents to be taken seriously.'
asserted
protection → ask → residents
In February, BCP Council refused retrospective planning permission for the wall, with the developers soon thereafter lodging an appeal to the Planning Inspectorate.
asserted
developers → refuse → Inspectorate
The developers claimed the wall was necessary to prevent 'mutual overlooking' between the new apartment and Mrs Bates' balcony.
asserted
wall → claim → apartment
The proximity between Mrs Bates' home and the new development means her views have been completely obscured by the brick wall
The council previously ordered the developer to demolish the 16ft long, 6ft high wall which was added without permission
But
asserted
which → mean → permission
Inspector David Kay said that the wall had a 'harmful overbearing impact' on Mrs Bates' home and the size of the roof terrace 'far exceeded what could be reasonably described as modest'.
uncertain
what → say → terrace
He added that the terrace could be used for large parties which would cause 'significant levels of noise and disturbance' to Mrs Bates.
uncertain
which → add → Bates
He highlighted the risk of 'overheard conversations' and said that while the apartment's new occupiers would be aware of the 'privacy' issues before moving in, Mrs Bates could not have known as she already lived there.
uncertain
she → highlight → issues
In their latest application, Mr Fitzsimmons' Vivir Estate company said they will shorten the terrace so it is no longer large enough to host parties.
asserted
it → say → parties
They said the glass screen would 'not result in an overbearing impact' upon Mrs Bates.
asserted
screen → say → Bates
The new application states: 'Following the Inspector's decision, the applicant instructed their architect to prepare amended plans for a substantially reduced roof terrace which would feature a glazed balustrading and a 1.8m high obscure glass privacy screen facing [Mrs Bates' home].
asserted
which → state → home
The privacy wall is no longer proposed and the existing wall will be removed as part of the revised proposal.
asserted
wall → propose → proposal
'Given its limited height and the separation distance, the proposed glass privacy screen would not result in an overbearing impact upon [Mrs Bates].
asserted
screen → give → Bates
It is recognised that the outlook from the neighbouring terrace would change, but change does not equate to material harm in planning terms.
asserted
change → recognise → terms
Given the minor nature of the proposed changes, the amendments to the approved scheme would not create any harmful impact on the character and appearance of the area nor the living conditions of the occupiers of any neighbouring properties.'
asserted
amendments → give → properties
The two and four-storey blocks in the main development are being built on a former council car park in front of 24 existing properties.
asserted
blocks → build → properties
BCP Council put the Southbourne Crossroads Car Park site up for sale in 2017 when it was underused, but changed their minds and denied two planning applications for the site.
asserted
it → put → site
They were overruled after Vivir Estates launched an appeal and a planning inspector sided with them despite 1,500 locals objecting to the plans.
Daily Mail has contacted Vivir Estates for comment.
asserted
Mail → overrule → comment
The Aporia
