President Donald Trump began his second term in office by weaponizing European worries about being abandoned by the United States, attacking NATO, and threatening to annex or buy Greenland, the semi-autonomous territory of the Kingdom of Denmark.
asserted
Trump → begin → Denmark
On Sept. 22, Trump got much of what he wanted, short of sovereignty.
asserted
he → get → sovereignty
He signed an agreement with Denmark and Greenland on the future of U.S. presence on the island.
asserted
He → sign → island
In a speech at the United Nations, Trump described the deal as offering the U.S. “permanent control over security and all other needs on that territory,” and forbidding American adversaries from establishing a “military presence” or making “sensitive investments” there.
asserted
Trump → describe → investments
The deal aims to address the limitations of the 1951 agreement that governed the U.S. security relationship with Greenland and counter the growing threat posed by Russian and Chinese activity in the Arctic.
asserted
that → aim → Arctic
The new agreement increases American presence on the island through the expansion of two military installations.
asserted
agreement → increase → installations
Whether it adequately addresses U.S. national security concerns remains to be seen.
asserted
addresses → address → concerns
But it does resolve one of the disputes that have strained relations within NATO since President Trump’s return to office.
asserted
that → resolve → office
And it reflects America’s short-term approach to coercing allies in the Trump Era.
asserted
it → reflect → Era
For now, the acute phase of the Greenland crisis appears to be over.
asserted
phase → appear → crisis
Denmark’s ambassador to the U.N. described the deal as “good” for all parties, as well as for “international peace and security.”
asserted
ambassador → describe → peace
Some observers, irrespective of their views on the methods used to secure the agreement, have emphasized that the deal does advance U.S. national security interests.
asserted
deal → use → interests
As Americans voted in midterm elections that gave Democrats control of both houses of Congress, Greenland’s legislature approved the September agreement.
asserted
legislature → vote → agreement
Trump hailed the Greenland deal as Europe giving the U.S. the “greatest gift we were ever given.”
asserted
we → hail → gift
Seventy years earlier, another American election coincided with a crisis between Washington and two of its closest allies, Britain and France, over their invasion of Egypt and seizure of the Suez Canal.
asserted
election → coincide → Canal
Washington coerced its allies to withdraw their forces.
asserted
Washington → coerce → forces
Judged by its immediate aims, the coercion succeeded.
asserted
coercion → judge → aims
But the longer-term costs of American coercion of allies offer a warning.
asserted
costs → offer → warning
Even if the Greenland crisis remains resolved, a big if, the consequences of Washington’s coercion, like those of its intervention in the Suez crisis, are likely to reverberate throughout the alliance for years to come.
asserted
consequences → remain → years
The historical parallels are imperfect, but earlier episodes of U.S. coercion against allies offer clues to what might follow.
uncertain
what → offer → clues
The U.S. has occasionally used coercion to resolve disagreements with allies.
asserted
U.S. → use → allies
When it has, Washington has typically made its demands and their limits clear: it specified the policy outcome it sought, confined its pressure to the issue at hand, and promised a return to normal relations once the allies complied.
asserted
allies → make → relations
In short, Washington offered a path back.
asserted
Washington → offer → path
The American nuclear non-proliferation policy illustrates this approach.
asserted
policy → illustrate → approach
In the 1970s, the U.S. used threats of abandonment, among other forms of pressure, to prevent South Korea from developing a nuclear weapons program.
asserted
U.S. → use → program
The Trump Administration’s coercion has typically lacked those limits.
asserted
coercion → lack → limits
Its pressure spills across policy areas, from trade relationships to state sovereignty.
asserted
pressure → spill → sovereignty
What's more, it often lacks a clear, stated objective and offers no obvious path back.
asserted
it → lack → path
The administration has yet to articulate a positive vision for America’s alliances.
asserted
administration → have → alliances
In these ways, coercion under Trump differs in kind from that wielded by his predecessors.
asserted
coercion → differ → predecessors
The resulting damage to America’s alliances is likely to endure long after the immediate disputes are settled.
asserted
disputes → result → alliances
Ghosts of the past
Even cases of conditional American coercion show how alliance cohesion can shift in ways the U.S. did not anticipate.
asserted
U.S. → show → ways
In July 1956, President Gamal Abdel Nasser of Egypt proclaimed, “The Suez Canal belongs to us! And it will be run by Egyptians!
asserted
it → proclaim → Egyptians
Nasser nationalized the Suez Canal Company, the international enterprise that had operated the canal since 1869.
asserted
that → nationalize → 1869
In the fall of 1956, as President Dwight Eisenhower campaigned for a second term, Britain partnered with France and Israel, invaded Egypt, and seized the northern end of the Suez Canal, a lucrative and vital waterway for international trade.
asserted
Britain → campaign → trade
The invasion of Egypt by American allies came at the height of the Cold War.
asserted
invasion → come → War
The Eisenhower Administration worried about Soviet intervention in the Mediterranean should the conflict become prolonged, and Eisenhower wrote in his memoirs about the potential damage to the “interests of the entire Free World.”
asserted
Eisenhower → worry → World
President Eisenhower launched a coercive campaign against Britain and France with the aims of establishing a ceasefire and then the withdrawal from Egypt.
asserted
Eisenhower → launch → Egypt
In the aftermath of World War II, Britain was heavily indebted, and the pound’s role as an international reserve currency made it vulnerable to a run.
asserted
it → make → run
The British pound came under pressure.
asserted
pound → come → pressure
…and 62 more, not listed.