Photo via The Sydney Morning Herald

The new face, the student and the veteran: The battle to succeed Reynolds

Read the original at The Sydney Morning Herald ↗
Cite

Wright, N. (2026, November 17). The new face, the student and the veteran: The battle to succeed Reynolds. The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/the-new-face-the-student-and-the-veteran-the-battle-to-succeed-reynolds-20261117-p61euh.html?ref=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_source=rss_feed

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

The Sydney Morning Herald · collected 2026-11-17 · by Nick Wright

Quick Summary

The Brisbane Broncos face a leadership void following Adam Reynolds' retirement, as they search for a new captain and halfback to lift the team from its worst season in NRL history. Pat Carrigan, a current Broncos player, is a frontrunner for the captaincy role, while the halfback position remains uncertain. Jonah Pezet, who joined the Broncos in 2025, is seen as a potential successor to Reynolds at halfback despite injury setbacks, with assistant coach Trent Barrett's influence playing a key role in Pezet's decision to join the Broncos.
Written by AI on 2026-11-17, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

The Brisbane Broncos face significant challenges after Adam Reynolds' retirement, leaving two key positions vacant: captain and halfback. Reynolds, who will remain with the club in a coaching role, was the team's captain and halfback, and his departure comes at a crucial time as the Broncos struggle to recover from their worst season since becoming defending premiers. In 2026, the team won only three of their last 16 games, suffering from injuries and internal discord. To stabilize the team, coach Michael Maguire needs to find a suitable replacement, particularly for the halfback position. Pat Carrigan, who will be free from his contract in 2028, is seen as a frontrunner for the captaincy. Carrigan expressed his readiness to take on the leadership role if offered. The decision on who succeeds Reynolds could significantly impact Maguire's tenure beyond 2027.

Written for “The Battle to Succeed Reynolds” on 2026-11-18, grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

Nothing to compare against. No article is close enough to this one for the pipeline to have linked or judged the pair.

Story

The Battle to Succeed Reynolds
Sports · 1 article(s) covering the same event.
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
41
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
2%
1 of 41 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Sports
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-17 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Sydney Morning Herald · 7597 article(s) · 15 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 15 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Nick Wright
34 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Whoever is named to succeed the retired captain and halfback could make or break coach Michael Maguire’s future at the club beyond 2027.
The NRL has forbidden club coaches in Australia from taking the national reins due to perceived conflicts of interest, but the fact Walters will be continuing his career in England is a different story.
But while Labuschagne rarely looked troubled before lunch – aside from surviving a caught behind appeal that had Gabe Bell adamant he had his man – it was once again a lack of judgment, this time attacking a delivery he easily could have left, which proved his downfall.
Lynn was served a suspension from July 31 to August 30, making him eligible to line up in this summer’s Big Bash League, in which he is expected to play for the Melbourne Renegades, having previously represented the Adelaide Strikers and Brisbane Heat.
2026-11-06 · assertive framing · T20 star serves ban after positive cocaine test
Jack Clayton played a lone hand in wrestling Queensland back into their Sheffield Shield clash with Victoria at the Gabba, bringing up his seventh first-class century early on Monday morning to thwart a bowling attack boasting fringe international prospect Fergus O’Neill, seven-Test spinner Todd Murphy and one-day international representative Will Sutherland.
Plying her trade for the Brisbane Barracudas while juggling her job at STARS hospital, nursing studies and fundraising initiatives, a typical Fasala day will begin at 5am and not end until at least 9.30pm. “You just get used to it and learn to push through how tired you are, and I think my body is so used to functioning on such little sleep,” she says.
The soon-to-be Test debutant, who will make his maiden appearance for Australia on Sunday night at Suncorp Stadium against Fiji, is expected to command lucrative interest from rival clubs should he not ink an extension before November 1.
His comeback will be complete when he runs out onto Suncorp Stadium on Sunday to face Fiji.
Renshaw had been viewed as a top order specialist who could soak up time and grind together an innings, but the now 30-year-old needed to redefine himself.
Smith surprised even himself, with Lyon quipping “there is probably no one more impressed than what Steve is”. “As soon as he saw that batter start to adopt a posture to suggest it was going to be a reverse sweep, it looked like he predicted that, anticipated that and started to move – he’s learned that,” Queensland University of Technology skill acquisition expert Adam Gorman told this masthead.
Also by Nick Wright
T20 star serves ban after positive cocaine test
2026-11-06 · The Sydney Morning Herald
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 34 articles by Nick Wright →

Topics

Australia Brisbane Broncos NRL the Brisbane Broncos

Subjects

Pezet PERSON · 6× Brisbane GPE · 3× Broncos ORG · 3× Duffy PERSON · 3× NRL ORG · 3× Reynolds PERSON · 3× Maguire PERSON · 2× Adam Reynolds’ PERSON · 1× Michael Maguire PERSON · 1× the Brisbane Broncos ORG · 1×

Narrative

“To come back in November and really get some good running under my belt, put some weight back on and be comfortable in my body – I’m 23 now, so I’m finding that keeping weight on is a little bit easier, and I’m starting to fill out in my body a bit better.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-17
Whoever is named to succeed the retired captain and halfback could make or break coach Michael Maguire’s future at the club beyond 2027.
2026-11-17 · The Sydney Morning Herald
The new face, the student and the veteran: The battle to succeed Reynolds · assertive framing

Claims (41 extracted, 1 hedged)

Adam Reynolds’ departure has left two gaping holes as the Brisbane Broncos prepare to lift themselves off the canvas. asserted
Broncos → leave → canvas
Whoever is named to succeed the retired captain and halfback could make or break coach Michael Maguire’s future at the club beyond 2027. uncertain
named → name → 2027
Brisbane suffered a freefall from grace in 2026, as they endured the worst season by a defending premier in the NRL era. asserted
they → suffer → era
Injuries and murmurs of discontent in the change room coincided with wins in just three of their last 16 games. asserted
Injuries → coincide → games
Finding a skipper to replace Reynolds, who will remain with the club in a coaching role, appears to be a simpler task for Maguire. asserted
who → find → Maguire
While there is a wealth of contenders – Mitch Barnett, Kotoni Staggs, Billy Walters and Ben Hunt – Pat Carrigan looms as a favourite before he comes off contract in 2028. asserted
he → be → 2028
“It’s a privilege to be captain of the Broncos, and if that opportunity was to come, I’d take it with both hands and lead the club forward,” Carrigan said during Australia’s World Cup camp. asserted
Carrigan → ’ → camp
“I’ve always prided myself on not changing and being true to who I am. asserted
I → pride → myself
Success is what you chase, but the hiccups and bumps are what make you a better person.” asserted
you → chase → what
The halfback challenge, however, will remain a summer-long headache. asserted
challenge → remain → ?
We break down the options to address Maguire’s dilemma. asserted
We → break → dilemma
For the first time in nearly five years, Pezet began an NRL pre-season in November, having been derailed by injuries throughout his career – headlined by a ruptured ACL in Melbourne. asserted
Pezet → begin → Melbourne
Heralded as Reynolds’ successor upon his signing in 2025, his lay-over season with Parramatta was one to forget, despite showing such promising signs with the Storm, where he won 13 of his 18 caps. asserted
he → herald → caps
Hamstring and shoulder issues limited him to just seven first-grade appearances. asserted
issues → limit → appearances
But he insisted his 2026 troubles were behind him. asserted
troubles → insist → him
“It’s been tough, the injury stuff that I’ve been through, but I’m in a good spot now,” Pezet said. asserted
Pezet → ’m → spot
“To come back in November and really get some good running under my belt, put some weight back on and be comfortable in my body – I’m 23 now, so I’m finding that keeping weight on is a little bit easier, and I’m starting to fill out in my body a bit better. asserted
I → come → weight
“I haven’t had any issues since round 12, I’ve seen a fair few people and got some new ideas on how to look after that [the hamstring] better.” asserted
I → have → hamstring
Pezet said it was the influence of Brisbane assistant coach Trent Barrett that ultimately drew him to Queensland, with the former 295-game halfback, who spearheaded his side’s attack, labelled a “special mind” by his new pupil. asserted
who → say → pupil
When Pezet signed with the Broncos, he had done so for the defending champions, rather than a side that plummeted to 14th place. asserted
that → sign → place
But he is undeterred, refusing to label his latest rugby league chapter a rescue mission. asserted
he → refuse → chapter
“We still have a premiership outfit. asserted
We → have → outfit
This roster and club is built on success ... that’s on us now to build this,” Pezet said. asserted
Pezet → build → this
“Last year they came back in January pretty much, and had four or five weeks of pre-season in the lead-up to going over for the World Club Challenge. asserted
they → come → Challenge
This year, we’re going to have four months until we play a game.” asserted
we → go → game
The student: Tom Duffy When Duffy slotted a field goal against the North Queensland Cowboys in round six, having also come up with two try assists, it announced a genuine face-off with Pezet was around the corner. asserted
off → slot → corner
While a late Heilum Luki try cost the Broncos that night, Duffy demonstrated the composure and game management necessary to blossom into a long-term halfback. asserted
Duffy → cost → halfback
He even showcased his goal kicking, nailing all five attempts, to offer a skill set Brisbane must cover without Reynolds. asserted
Brisbane → showcase → Reynolds
Having been shifted between halfback, five-eighth, and even hooker, Duffy is relishing the prospect of settling into his preferred role. asserted
Duffy → shift → role
And he stressed he was more than ready to meet the occasion. asserted
he → stress → occasion
“I just feel comfortable at the NRL level now,” he said. asserted
he → feel → level
“The evidence of what you did on the field gives you confidence to do it again. asserted
you → give → it
I enjoy playing seven and controlling the team, definitely my kicking game and my communication among the team are my two strengths.” asserted
game → play → team
The veteran: Ben Hunt Hunt wants the halfback duties, rather than the hooker role he has largely taken. asserted
he → want → role
While he is the seasoned figure, the zest and running game he brought in his younger days must be seen more to fend off his younger peers. asserted
he → bring → peers
When the Broncos clinched the 2025 title, they did so on the back of Reece Walsh’s heroics. asserted
they → clinch → heroics
But Hunt and Walters, who played four games together in the injury absences of Reynolds and Ezra Mam, were lauded for identifying when to pull the strings and when to unleash Walsh. asserted
who → play → Walsh
Pezet insisted he was not viewing the summer as a battle to prove he warranted the job at Hunt’s expense, believing his experience would be to his benefit, not downfall. asserted
experience → insist → downfall
“Dozer’s done everything in the game – he’s played for Australia, he’s won Origins for Queensland – so I’m just excited to learn off him,” Pezet said. asserted
Pezet → do → him
“I’m sure he’s going to push me just as much as I’m going to push him. asserted
I → ’m → him
…and 1 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support