Fear, outrage grow as Quebec moves to ban religious symbols for elementary students
Experts say PQ's plan would cause harm, say it's 'misguided' and 'disrespectful'
Mehwaish Raja’s 11 year-old daughter surprised her during a conversation this past summer on the way to day camp.
“She shared with me during the car ride: ‘Mama, I will wear my hijab at the end of the summer,’” Raja said.
asserted
Raja → grow → summer
Up until that point, her daughter only wore the hijab for special occasions, and Raja had never insisted she wear it regularly.
asserted
she → wear → it
“I just said, ‘OK.’
asserted
I → say → ?
And by the end of the summer, it actually happened,” Raja said.
asserted
Raja → happen → summer
Her daughter now wears the hijab every day in her Grade 5 class in a public school in Montreal’s West Island.
asserted
daughter → wear → Island
Now, the new Parti Québécois government is proposing a law that would make that practice illegal as part of a series of measures announced on the campaign trail to strengthen secularism.
asserted
practice → propose → secularism
Raja is struggling to understand why.
asserted
Raja → struggle → ?
I'm out of words when I hear things like this,” she said.
asserted
she → hear → this
She doesn’t think the government should be able to decide what her daughter wears to school.
asserted
daughter → think → school
“When we step out of our house, we leave as who we are.
asserted
we → step → house
What part of us do we leave at home?” she said.
asserted
she → leave → home
The previous CAQ government already introduced several laws restricting religious symbols in schools, preventing at first teachers, and then all school staff – even parent volunteers – from wearing them.
asserted
government → introduce → them
Generally, religious symbols bans in Quebec have targeted employees of the state considered to be in positions of authority, but the CAQ opened the door to targeting students by introducing a ban on full face coverings at school.
asserted
CAQ → target → school
Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon is opening that door wider, proposing a blanket ban preventing elementary school students from wearing "conspicuous" religious symbols while at school.
asserted
Plamondon → open → school
“Separating children through what they wear and through religious beliefs at such a young age is not helping cohesion and integration,” St-Pierre Plamondon said in September when announcing the measure, without providing any specific examples.
“We think it's a good policy in terms of letting children just be children, with no connection whatsoever to what their parents believe about religion,” he'd said.
asserted
he → separate → religion
When proposing the religious ban for elementary schools during the election campaign, PQ Leader Paul St-Pierre Plamondon said the symbols 'interfere with cohesion and integration.'
asserted
symbols → propose → cohesion
Winning a minority government in the general election did not soften the PQ's resolve, with new Education Minister Joël Arseneau saying the measure was a "non-negotiable.
asserted
measure → win → resolve
"
"It’s on this basis that we were elected, and it’s on this basis that we’re working,” Arseneau told reporters at the National Assembly in late October.
asserted
Arseneau → ’ → October
Mother says proposed law based on misconceptions
Asma Qureshi says the PQ's proposal comes from a place of ignorance.
asserted
proposal → say → ignorance
Qureshi, who lives on Montreal’s South Shore, has four children.
asserted
who → live → children
Her oldest daughter, now in high school, started wearing a hijab to school when she was in Grade 4.
asserted
she → start → Grade
Her youngest daughter, currently in kindergarten, wore one to school a couple of times this year just to try it.
asserted
daughter → wear → it
Qureshi – who wears a hijab herself – says in both cases, she didn’t ask or order her daughters to wear one.
asserted
she → wear → one
"I told myself that I would never impose it on my kids," she said.
asserted
she → tell → kids
"There’s this narrative that goes around – and it's been there since I was a young kid – that children and women are being forced to wear the scarf."
Qureshi thinks that misconception is what’s feeding the gradual tightening of restrictions on wearing religious symbols in Quebec, particularly in schools.
asserted
what → ’ → schools
She says she hasn’t yet discussed the proposed ban with her daughters.
asserted
she → say → daughters
“How do you tell a child it’s against the law for you to wear something that your mother wears?” she said.
asserted
she → tell → that
Raja says her daughter's decision to start wearing the hijab regularly this fall convinced her to do the same.
asserted
decision → say → same
For Raja, who up until now had been reluctant to wear a hijab in Quebec for fear of standing out, says her daughter's decision to wear one at school this fall convinced her to do the same.
asserted
decision → wear → same
“I'm really proud of her because at 11 years old, she decided to wear it, whereas I’m 40 and I hadn't been able to,” she said.
asserted
she → decide → it
“My daughter truly inspired me."
asserted
daughter → inspire → me
Ban would cause harm, experts say
Experts in secularism and child development told CBC there is no justification for banning students from wearing religious symbols — and that the measure would be harmful.
asserted
measure → cause → symbols
Thomas Dee, an economist at Stanford University who specializes in how education policy affects student outcomes, disagreed with the notion of asking children to leave their parents' religious baggage behind.
“Parents are children's first and most impactful teachers, and to sideline their guidance and insights just seems misguided to me and disrespectful,” he said.
asserted
he → specialize → me
Dee testified as an expert witness in the court challenge to Bill 21, Quebec’s first secularism law.
asserted
Dee → testify → Bill
Thomas Dee, an economics professor at Stanford University who studies the effects of education policy on student outcomes, says a policy that marginalizes parents' values in school is misguided and disrespectful.
asserted
that → study → school
Sivane Hirsch, a professor in the faculty of education at Université Laval who specializes in cultural and religious diversity in schools, believes the ban is a horrible idea.
asserted
ban → specialize → schools
“We don’t want children to feel they’re being taught in school against their parents, against their family,” Hirsch said.
asserted
Hirsch → want → family
Dee said such a conflict would also hurt students’ performance.
asserted
conflict → say → performance
“Anything that makes students feel less welcome or less at ease will imply they're not able to bring their full attention and motivation to the realization of their academic potential,” Dee said.
asserted
Dee → make → potential
Zeinab Diab, a religious studies researcher at Université de Montréal and author of Au nom de la laïcité, a book about Islamophobia in Quebec, said a secularism law that targets young children is inhumane.
asserted
that → say → children
…and 25 more, not listed.