In short:
The Greens want the government to commit to reforming charity rules in exchange for passage of its tax bills.
asserted
government → want → bills
A "name and shame" proposal for trusts and beneficiaries is not a red line and the Greens have no major issues with the government's CGT carve-out.
asserted
Greens → have → out
The government is trying to pass two tax bills through the Senate by the end of next week.
asserted
government → try → week
The Greens could pass Labor's two major tax bills by the end of next week if the minor party can extract a promise to reform the charities sector.
uncertain
party → pass → sector
Treasurer Jim Chalmers wants the parliament's support for legislation to impose a minimum tax on some trusts and to carve out start-ups from the new capital gains tax (CGT) regime.
asserted
Chalmers → want → regime
The Coalition is opposed, making the Greens the only viable pathway in the Senate.
asserted
Greens → make → Senate
The minor party is comfortable with the principle of both measures and would support them subject to a small number of changes, several Greens sources told the ABC.
asserted
sources → support → ABC
The party's red line is an exemption for private schools and other non-tax-paying recipients, which they want repealed along with a commitment to consider broader charitable sector reform, including the tax treatment of religious institutions.
asserted
they → pay → institutions
But the Greens have no apparent red lines on the CGT start-up carve-out and appear unlikely to support independent MP Allegra Spender's proposed alternative, despite expressing openness to it yesterday.
asserted
Greens → have → it
Mr Chalmers revealed this morning that he had written to Ms Spender outlining Treasury's concerns with her proposal.
asserted
he → reveal → proposal
That letter, seen by the ABC, said her idea would be "neither simple nor straightforward" and would be inequitable.
asserted
idea → see → ABC
Spender proposal not 'fairer', Chalmers says
The CGT issue relates to a workaround the government devised in response to a complaint from start-ups that the new inflation-based discount would unfairly penalise them, because they start from scratch and so had no cost base to be "inflated".
The government's proposed concession would apply to businesses less than 15 years old, subject to a test to establish whether they were developing or commercialising "genuinely innovative products, processes, services or methods".
Ms Spender said the exemption was too narrow and subjective and that any "active" business assets should instead get a 40 per cent discount, which she said would raise a similar amount of money but be simpler.
asserted
she → say → money
In his letter to Ms Spender, Mr Chalmers said Treasury had "identified a number of issues and concerns".
asserted
Treasury → say → issues
"Their analysis suggests that your proposal is unlikely to be simpler, fairer or enhance productivity, as you suggest," he wrote.
uncertain
he → suggest → productivity
"Your proposal would introduce a second set of tax arrangements for capital gains and replaces one arbitrary distortion in the tax system with another, for the majority of assets.
asserted
proposal → introduce → assets
[It] risks introducing more complexity, not less.
asserted
It → risk → complexity
In the letter, Mr Chalmers said early-stage start-ups, which were most likely to be innovative, would likely stand to pay higher taxes under the 40 per cent idea and that identifying which assets were "active" would be complex.
asserted
assets → say → idea
"This would need to occur regularly and across all businesses to ensure shareholders understand an entity's status, as opposed to the current definition that only applies to small businesses in years where CGT events arise," he wrote.
asserted
he → need → years
He added that the proposal could "introduce pervasive incentives to restructure for tax reasons", such as by putting properties and other assets into an "active" business vehicle to pay less tax.
uncertain
proposal → add → tax
In a statement, Ms Spender told the ABC her proposal was "gathering wide support in the business community" and reiterated her call to the government to "listen seriously to what business is saying and carefully analyse and evaluate the advantages" of her model.
asserted
business → tell → model
"I would welcome a thorough and serious parliamentary inquiry," she said.
asserted
she → welcome → inquiry
Greens sources told the ABC the party had no particular inclination to support Ms Spender's proposal, saying that Senator McKim's suggestion yesterday that he was "open" to it should not be read as an endorsement.
asserted
he → tell → endorsement
The sources said the minor party was broadly supportive of the idea of giving innovative start-ups the option to choose between the old 50 per cent discount and the new discount.
asserted
party → say → discount
The Greens opted not to support a Coalition motion today to refer the bill, which also includes research and development tax incentive changes and changes to the EV discount, to a Senate inquiry reporting in the new year.
asserted
which → opt → year
But the minor party is keeping its options open on that front and sees no urgency to pass either of the tax bills by the end of the year if the government is unwilling to give ground.
asserted
government → keep → ground
Charitable exemption for trusts under microscope
On trusts, the Greens' sole concern is that an exemption for charitable giving is too broad, allowing people to escape the 30 per cent tax not just by giving to registered charities but to any income tax-exempt entity, including private schools and sporting clubs.
asserted
people → allow → schools
Senator McKim, the party's economic spokesperson, used a Senate inquiry into the bill to recommend this be restricted to registered charities only, and that the government agree to respond to a 2024 Productivity Commission report into charity rules.
asserted
government → use → rules
That report found the granting of "deductible gift recipient" and tax-exempt status to non-charities had "no coherent policy rationale".
asserted
granting → find → rationale
It advocated excluding private and religious schools and religious activities.
asserted
It → advocate → schools
A Greens source emphasised that the government would not necessarily need to agree to go this far, but that there was appetite to see the issue probed.
asserted
issue → emphasise → ?
Recent scrutiny over the election activity of Exclusive Brethren church members was cited as a motivator.
asserted
scrutiny → cite → motivator
The source said another recommendation from the inquiry, to facilitate a public register of trusts and their beneficiaries, was not a red line for negotiations.
asserted
recommendation → say → negotiations
No rush to pass by end of year
Sources said there had been no tangible progress to report on any concessions.
asserted
Sources → pass → concessions
When the Greens' concerns about private schools were first reported by the ABC last month, Mr Chalmers said he had learned of the concern from the reporting.
asserted
he → report → reporting
"I haven't had the opportunity to engage directly …
asserted
I → engage → opportunity
we've tried to make sure that there are reasonable arrangements for charities, for not-for-profits, which reflect some of the current arrangements that are in place," he told Radio National at the time.
asserted
he → try → time
[Private school giving] is a very specific sliver of what's being proposed here."
asserted
what → propose → ?