I regret to inform you that we are now two weeks into the 2028 presidential election cycle.
asserted
we → regret → cycle
This is the stage where various factions try to shape conventional wisdom to support their agenda.
asserted
factions → try → agenda
For Democrats, that’s a difficult process, because they so wildly overperformed in the midterms that every faction has a favourable story to tell.
asserted
faction → ’ → story
For Republicans, it’s tougher and uglier.
asserted
it → ’ → Republicans
In a lengthy social media post, Vance offered an explanation for the carnage that was gobsmacking in its intellectual dishonesty, brazenness and rhetorical restraint.
asserted
that → offer → dishonesty
Claiming to have consulted dispassionate experts, Vance insisted that “the main problem is that many people who voted for Donald Trump and Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026.”
asserted
who → claim → 2026
Let’s pause here to note that there were very, very few “Trump/Vance” voters in 2024.
asserted
’s → let → 2024
Vance just tagged along.
asserted
Vance → tag → ?
More importantly, Vance is gussying up convenient hogwash as data-driven conclusions.
asserted
Vance → gussye → conclusions
Of course, some Trump 2024 voters defected to the Democrats.
asserted
voters → defect → Democrats
Roughly 7% nationally, about the same number that stayed home.
asserted
that → stay → ?
In short, the “Blue Tsunami” was powered by massive Democratic and independent turnout combined with the disintegration of Trump’s 2024 coalition.
asserted
Tsunami → power → coalition
Tellingly, the word “independent” doesn’t appear in Vance’s autopsy, perhaps because they don’t vote in Republican primaries.
asserted
they → appear → primaries
Moreover, few would dispute that the Democrats’ best issue was Trump.
asserted
issue → dispute → ?
When a profoundly unpopular president asks voters to pretend he’s on the ballot, it amounts to an in-kind donation to Democrats.
asserted
it → ask → Democrats
Vance’s most absurd claim is that his expert pollster found that voters who “abandoned us” would all come back if Republicans did four things: “1. End the war 2. Focus on cost of living/inflation 3. Put America First 4. Change our relationship to Israel.”
uncertain
Republicans → find → Israel
I call B.S.
Obviously, voters want an end to the wildly unpopular Iran war and to see their economic circumstances improve.
asserted
circumstances → call → war
They probably also want to “put America first,” whatever that means.
asserted
that → want → whatever
No doubt some want to change our relationship with Israel.
asserted
some → want → Israel
What Vance didn’t say says a lot
But the whole thing is a farrago of lies, mostly of omission.
asserted
thing → say → omission
For example, Vance doesn’t mention corruption, even though according to Fox News’ exit poll, 90% of voters considered “government corruption” to be a “major” or “crucial” factor.
uncertain
corruption → mention → voters
Weird that Trump’s handpicked “Fraud Czar” left that out.
asserted
Czar → leave → that
Vance was also utterly silent on the wildly unpopular tariffs he supports that landed so hard on Trump 2024 voters and started Trump’s slide in favourability.
asserted
that → support → favourability
If you look at Vance’s four issues in the broader political context, they boil down to basically two: the economy and Israel.
asserted
they → look → two
His well-publicized opposition to the Iran war is grounded in his desire to pander to the people who largely define America First foreign policy as cutting Israel loose.
asserted
who → publicize → Israel
Yes, they claim to have a broader philosophical opposition to foreign military adventures.
uncertain
they → claim → adventures
But that didn’t stop them from cheerleading Trump’s unconstitutional and illegal “take the oil” adventure in Venezuela that inspired him to replicate it in Iran.
asserted
that → stop → Iran
Vance flatly says, “The reason we lost is the war.
asserted
we → say → ?
The president himself said so last night.”
asserted
president → say → ?
Trump actually said, “I don’t think it’s the war, I think it’s the gasoline prices.”
asserted
it → say → ?
Vance wants to imply it was the decision to go to war, not the high gas prices the war resulted in, that cost the Republicans in the election.
asserted
that → want → election
He wants to leave that impression because he thinks it’s more important to win over anti-Israel voters who think the war was launched for Israel in the first place (it wasn’t).
asserted
it → want → place
This is particularly odd, given that 61% of the Republican voters who did show up said America’s current relationship with Israel is “about right” and another 16% said it’s “not strong enough.”
asserted
it → give → Israel
In other words, Vance cares more about the mythical 7% of anti-Israel Republican voters who cost the Republicans the midterms than he does the 77% actual pro-Israel voters who showed up.
asserted
who → care → voters
Note: I don’t think many Republicans voted on Israel one way or the other.
asserted
Republicans → note → Israel
But Vance thinks he can use animosity toward Israel to win the nomination by solidifying the nationalist faction in a crowded Republican field, then force the rest of the party to hold their nose and back him as the nominee.
asserted
he → think → nominee
And to do that, he first needs to get suckers to buy his theory of why the Republicans lost.
asserted
Republicans → do → theory