Forget seconds — New Yorkers may be forced to think twice before filling their Thanksgiving plates with the usual delicious staples this year.
uncertain
Yorkers → forget → staples
Rising fuel costs, poor harvests due to extreme weather and general inflation are making everything, even the pecans in your grandma’s famous pie, more expensive.
asserted
everything → rise → pie
The Post carved into the numbers to find out just how much more New Yorkers will shell out for Thanksgiving dinner this year — and what shoppers can do to keep costs low and flavor high.
asserted
flavor → carve → costs
Even though national prices for Thanksgiving staples were down on average in 2025, the Empire State bucked the overall trend, according to the 2025 Consumer Price Index.
uncertain
State → buck → Index
Instead of saving dough while making pie dough, New Yorkers were spending nearly 20% more than fellow Americans, with Turkey Day costing an average of $66.06 per meal.
asserted
Day → save → meal
This year, New Yorkers can expect even higher prices.
asserted
Yorkers → expect → prices
The Post spoke with Francisco Martin-Rayo, the co-founder and CEO of agricultural tech company Helios AI, who shared that nearly every table staple will likely eat up your budget.
asserted
staple → speak → budget
Some bites that will cost you: potatoes, pecans, cranberries and the big bird itself.
Last year, the retail price of a frozen whole turkey was $1.03 a pound.
asserted
price → cost → turkey
This year it’s up about 22.3%, costing folks $1.26 a pound.
asserted
it → ’ → 1.26
For a 15-pound turkey, that works out to about $18.90 — or $3.45 more than last year.
asserted
that → work → 18.90
When food costs more to transport, that cost carries on to the consumer.
asserted
cost → cost → consumer
Plus, turkeys must be temperature-controlled during transportation — something that requires even more fuel, and therefore costs even more cash.
asserted
that → control → cash
Also spiking: wholesale potato prices, which are nearly 60% higher than normal, according to price trackers.
uncertain
which → spike → trackers
In New York alone, a 70-count Idaho russet potato is selling for $35 per case — about 50% more than last year’s spud haul.
asserted
potato → sell → haul
That’s no small potatoes, as some Big Apple residents (and restaurants) depend on every dollar.
asserted
residents → ’ → dollar
Dessert fans may want to brace for a not-so-sweet surprise, too, as pecans on this year’s pie will likely cost more than last year.
uncertain
pecans → want → year
Martin-Rayo told The Post that every major pecan state had a bad season due to weather.
asserted
state → tell → weather
Georgia’s growers faced exceptionally wet conditions, with rainfall running 68% above even 2018 levels — when Hurricane Michael wiped out the state’s pecan crop.
asserted
Michael → face → crop
New Mexico was also hit hard after experiencing its wettest growing season in eight years, leaving little time for farmers to recover with a new crop.
“With the season ending in December, we don’t think there’s enough of a window for the season to recover, so shoppers should expect both a smaller pecan crop and higher prices,” Martin-Rayo said.
asserted
Rayo → hit → crop
The former avocado trader-turned-entrepreneur also said cranberry prices may rise, as the bog-grown crop suffered insufficient rainfall and wildfire damage this year.
uncertain
crop → turn → rainfall
Experts say New Yorkers can do three things to ensure full bellies without an empty wallet: Be flexible with this year’s menu, buy your food early and compare prices between stores and farms.
asserted
Yorkers → say → stores
“I would say don’t be so tied to the traditional Thanksgiving meal,” said Martin-Rayo.
asserted
Rayo → say → meal
“You can do sweet potatoes instead of regular potatoes.
asserted
You → do → potatoes
Brussels sprouts should have a pretty good year, and so those costs should be lower.
asserted
costs → have → year
Those things really add up,” he said.
asserted
he → add → ?
The businessman also suggested scooping up shelf-stable items like cranberries early, which makes it easier to take advantage of sales and specials.
uncertain
it → suggest → sales
I think that [shoppers] will be more empowered in terms of how much they’re spending and where they’re spending,” he said.
asserted
he → think → spending
Lastly, that extra bit of work to compare prices between farmers’ markets and grocery stores may give New Yorkers some serious savings.
uncertain
bit → compare → savings
“This is where I think planning is really helpful.
asserted
planning → think → ?
Go to your local farmers market, go to your local co-op, and go see what the prices are and see what you can order ahead of time,” Martin-Rayo told The Post.
asserted
Rayo → go → Post
For canned and tinned items, grocery stores have much bigger margins, which means you may be saving more on their shelves.
uncertain
you → tin → shelves
Conversely, some farmers could let shoppers get a better deal on big-ticket items like turkeys, especially if you offer to buy the food in cash.
uncertain
you → let → cash
It’s just lovely that you all get to get together, and the whole point of it is eating.
asserted
point → ’ → it
So you know, as long as you’re doing that, just be flexible with what you’ll serve.”
asserted
you → know → what