Who should replace Mauricio Pochettino as the USMNT manager? – Tom S
asserted
Who → replace → manager
Although the salary I’m sure will be excellent, I think the US job is going to be a really difficult sell to a top-level coach.
asserted
job → ’m → coach
The 2030 World Cup is a long way away and I’m not sure the Concacaf Nations League, the Gold Cup or even the 2028 Copa América carry much appeal for a manager with European experience or aspirations.
asserted
League → ’m → experience
But I’m not entirely sure that sort of coach is necessarily a great idea.
asserted
sort → ’m → coach
The last two World Cups, after all, have been won by low-key coaches who have come from within the federation and have worked with many of the players at youth level.
asserted
who → win → level
That’s the positive from appointing from within; appointing from without is almost certainly more expensive and there’s the danger the next foreign manager does just what Mauricio Pochettino does, and has his head turned by the first vaguely attractive European job that comes calling.
The United States’ interest in Pep Guardiola, and his talks with Italy earlier, have me wondering – what separates club and international management?
asserted
what → ’ → management
Could Pep, as successful as he’s been, do well in either?
uncertain
he → do → either
– Joe P
International and club management seem to me related but essentially different jobs.
asserted
International → seem → jobs
It’s one thing to have the players every day and be able to drill them over and over to impose a philosophy; quite another to pick them up for perhaps a dozen training sessions over a calendar year, plus major tournaments.
asserted
It → ’ → year
International football is necessarily less sophisticated than club football, more based on individual excellence or heroism.
asserted
football → base → excellence
Guardiola, you suspect, would be able to adapt, but it’s not certain.
asserted
it → suspect → ?
Plus there’s the fact that at major tournaments players are with their manager for a month or more, cooped up in the same hotel with no release.
asserted
players → ’ → release
With the more intense coaches, such as Marcelo Bielsa, that seems to become problematic.
asserted
that → seem → Bielsa
And it’s notable that at the last World Cup the nations with the big-name managers – England, Brazil, the United States, Germany – fared less well than those who had appointed technocrats from within.
asserted
who → ’ → within
Michael Carrick’s firing highlighted the lack of top-class English managers.
asserted
firing → highlight → managers
Why has an Englishman never managed a Premier League club to a title?
asserted
Englishman → manage → title
I think there are two related issues here.
asserted
I → think → ?
To which the answer appears to be that there are nowhere near as many as there ought to be.
asserted
answer → appear → which
The various changes in player development enacted by the elite player performance plan and the England DNA project have, over the past 10-15 years, led to the development of far more technically proficient English players than there have ever been before, which has been reflected in the uptick in England’s performances at major tournaments.
asserted
which → enact → tournaments
St George’s Park was supposed to be about developing coaches as well as players but, as yet, that seems not to have happened.
asserted
that → suppose → coaches
That said, it’s probably also the case that it’s very hard for British coaches to be appointed to top Premier League jobs.
asserted
coaches → say → jobs
Say they get their start at a mid-sized Championship club and win promotion; they then have to amend their approach in the Premier League to scrap for points in a relegation battle.
asserted
they → say → battle
If they fail they are written off as not good enough for the top division; if they succeed, they’re seen as not playing the right sort of football for an elite club.
asserted
they → fail → club
It’s happened to Scott Parker … even the likes of Gary O’Neil or Eddie Howe seem somehow not quite right for the elite who, perhaps understandably, prefer to turn to somebody with experience of European competition.
asserted
who → happen → competition
Is there any part of you that feels sympathy for the current Man City players, who will presumably have to play out a “lost season” thanks to actions they had nothing to do with, and which probably happened long before their time at the club?
asserted
which → feel → club
To an extent, yes, but they’re pretty naïve if they didn’t realise the potential issue they were walking into.
asserted
they → ’re → issue
I have far more sympathy for those players who played for clubs who were denied success by City’s cheating.
asserted
who → have → cheating
It’s not just the teams who finished second in the league, lost to City in cup competitions or missed out on European qualification because of City; it’s those teams, most obviously Arsenal and Aston Villa, whose development was derailed by City taking their best players, offering wages and transfer fees that it turns out they had no business offering.
asserted
they → ’ → business
Italy have gotten some big results in the Nations League.
asserted
Italy → get → League
This question, to be fair, was sent in before the 4-1 defeat to Belgium on Sunday.
asserted
question → send → Sunday
But anyway, beating France at home may be a big result, but that and two wins over Turkey seems limited evidence to say they’re back.
uncertain
they → beat → Turkey
They have definitely looked sharper under Roberto Mancini than they have probably since winning the Euros under him five years ago, but that’s a long way from being back.
asserted
that → look → him
Even if they were to win the Euros in 2028, it wouldn’t alter the fact they haven’t qualified for three World Cups in a row.
asserted
they → win → row
They need to qualify for 2030 and then probably get to at least the quarter-finals before you can start to say they may be back.
uncertain
they → need → finals
And even then, Serie A is way off what it was at its peak – and how many of this squad would get in a Spain or England squad?
asserted
many → get → squad
Email soccerwithjw@theguardian.com, and he’ll answer the best in a future edition.
asserted
he → email → edition