Britain could be left at risk of accusations of 'genocide' if the UN's top court accepts a looser definition of the term, legal and military experts have warned.
uncertain
experts → leave → term
The International Court of Justice (ICJ), based in The Hague, is due to deliver a judgment this week on whether Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority.
asserted
Myanmar → base → minority
It is expected to be one of the most significant moments in international law since the end of the Second World War.
asserted
It → expect → War
The landmark case could set a new 21st-century benchmark for genocide with far-reaching implications.
uncertain
case → set → implications
But a new paper, published today by the Policy Exchange think tank, argues against lowering the standard of proof for finding that genocide has occurred.
asserted
genocide → publish → proof
The authors warn about the consequences for Britain's Armed Forces of blurring the line between genocide and the ordinary laws of wars.
They also note genocide claims are already being made against the UK over past events, with concerns they could move from political argument into courts of law.
uncertain
they → warn → law
The report points to the Irish potato famine in the mid-19th century and the Mau Mau rebellion in Kenya in the 1950s as historical events that have seen Britain accused of genocide.
asserted
Britain → point → genocide
The International Court of Justice (ICJ), based in The Hague, is due to deliver a judgment this week on whether Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority
Ex-ambassador Sir John Jenkins, international law experts Dr Tom Grant and Dr Yuan Yi Zhu, and former RAF officer Air Marshal Edward Stringer are the paper's authors.
They also warn that malign actors such as Russia and Iran, as well as their proxies, are already weaponising genocide allegations.
asserted
actors → base → allegations
Their report highlights how the Myanmar case could be cited as authority when the ICJ considers other 'genocide' allegations, including South Africa's claims against Israel over Gaza.
uncertain
ICJ → highlight → Gaza
'Misuse of the word 'genocide' complicates diplomacy and military operations, problematising operations from airstrikes to counterinsurgency, to military cooperation, to weapons sales,' they wrote.
asserted
they → complicate → sales
'Western democracies are the intended audience of false claims of genocide, because public pressure in Western democracies affects foreign policy, whereas in autocracies it does not.
uncertain
it → affect → autocracies
'Accepting these claims means letting tendentious notions propagate, undermining the moral basis of our foreign policy.
uncertain
notions → accept → policy
'Erasing the distinction between the range of international humanitarian law rules and the prohibition of genocide exposes British politicians, policymakers, and service members to potential liability.
asserted
Erasing → erase → liability
'Likewise, it opens the way to the extreme legalisation of warfare, complicating military operations and making it harder to end conflicts.'
asserted
it → open → conflicts
The authors added: 'Using the term for rhetorical purposes to condemn acts that fall short of genocide risks diluting its impact and weakening responses to real instances of genocide.
asserted
that → add → genocide
The recent move by Ireland at the ICJ to reduce the threshold for a finding of 'genocide', such that the term would capture Israel's conduct in Gaza, is part of this broader trend.'
asserted
term → reduce → trend
In a foreword to the report, Dmytro Kuleba - a former foreign minister of Ukraine - urges international states to hold fast to the established understanding of genocide.
asserted
Kuleba → urge → genocide
He notes how Ukraine resisted the temptation to lower the standard of proof in its own proceedings against Russia.
asserted
Ukraine → note → Russia
'The hardest part was resisting temptation,' he wrote.
asserted
he → resist → temptation
'The strain of the war and the mood in Ukrainian society pushed us to answer Russia's accusation with one just as loose.
asserted
strain → push → one
'We at the foreign ministry resisted it.
asserted
We → resist → it
We did not ask the Court to find Russia guilty of genocide.
'
asserted
Russia → ask → genocide
We asked it to declare that Ukraine had committed none, and that Russia had no right to use the Convention as a pretext for war.
asserted
Russia → ask → war
'A lower bar would have helped Moscow more than us, because it would have put our case on the same shelf as Russia's invented one.'
asserted
it → help → one