Dr Jade Pagkas-Bather received her first grant from the National Institutes of Health (NIH) in June 2025 – a milestone in any researcher’s career.
asserted
Bather → receive → career
She planned to study basic income as a medical intervention: her randomized control trial would test whether monthly grants of $500-cash helped poor, HIV-positive young people in Chicago stick with treatment.
asserted
people → plan → treatment
Her hypothesis was as straightforward as it was cutting.
asserted
it → cut → ?
“Maybe taking care of your HIV isn’t your priority when you’re unhoused or hungry,” said Pagkas-Bather.
asserted
Bather → take → HIV
That summer, she was through peer-review and about to be funded when NIH program officers started asking for changes, verbally and usually on a video call.
asserted
officers → fund → call
“We had something that said we would include people of all gender identities in the grant.
asserted
we → have → grant
Program officers asked us to remove the term ‘gender identities.’
asserted
officers → ask → term
We had a clause that said Black and Latinx people experience more poverty than other people.
asserted
people → have → people
They asked us to remove that.”
asserted
They → ask → that
Pagkas-Bather removed it all, received funding and enrolled dozens of study participants.
asserted
Bather → remove → participants
Then, in 2026, a bigger ask came: could she remove the entire idea of giving out cash?
uncertain
she → come → cash
She recounted being told: “You can’t use unconditional cash transfer and you need to remove any reference to this having an impact on policy.”
asserted
this → recount → policy
Pagkas-Bather’s experience is a glimpse into the Trump administration’s NIH renegotiation process, an opaque and “Orwellian” political review that uses a “text analysis tool” to flag grants not in “alignment” with the Trump administration’s priorities.
asserted
that → use → priorities
The process has injected uncertainty, confusion and woe into scientific grant-making at the NIH over the past two years.
asserted
process → inject → years
Renegotiations force program officers, who typically take pride in shepherding critical research, to flag grants on topics the Trump administration disfavors.
asserted
administration → force → topics
Even as they do so, they must guess what the “no-no” words are: NIH director Jay Bhattacharya has repeatedly denied a list of banned words exists.
asserted
list → do → words
“Her story is not unique,” said Shalini Agarwal, special counsel at Project Democracy, who is representing Pagkas-Bather in a suit seeking class-action status, and alleging the government is violating the first amendment.
asserted
government → say → amendment
“There are many other researchers in a similar situation who are being asked to subvert their own grant projects that have been peer-reviewed and approved for funding a year or more into the project.
asserted
that → be → project
Data shared exclusively with the Guardian shows re-negotiations surged in the first two years of the Trump administration.
asserted
negotiations → share → administration
In 2023, only 154 of more than 40,000 grants up for renewal changed their titles, abstracts or public health statements: 0.4% of all grants, according to an analysis by Grant Witness, an independent group that tracks canceled government grants.
uncertain
that → change → grants
Those changes increased 21-fold during the Trump administration.
asserted
changes → increase → administration
In 2025, 8.6% of all grants changed year-to-year, or more than 3,401 of the more than 39,000 grant continuations awarded by NIH.
asserted
% → change → NIH
In 2026, 8.5% of all continuing grants changed, or 3,006 of the agency’s nearly 35,500 grants, according to an analysis by Grant Witness.
uncertain
% → continue → Witness
In the 2027 fiscal year, which just started, 64 grants have been renewed.
asserted
grants → start → year
Three have already seen changes.
asserted
Three → see → changes
In one a study initially titled “The Black Zones”, which was to focus on African American neighborhoods, all mentions of “African Americans” was removed, and a new version referenced “Black Americans”.
asserted
version → title → Americans
In another, an HIV grant that would study a specific viral subtype had text changed from including “men and women” to “a wide range of people”.
asserted
text → study → people
HIV grants are almost twice as likely to have been changed, data shows, and were especially hard-hit in early cancelations.
asserted
data → change → cancelations
In part, many likely undertook renegotiations because the Trump administration placed severe restrictions on scientific work in South Africa.
asserted
administration → undertake → Africa
In 2025, of the 1,795 HIV-related continuing grants, 305 were changed, or 17%.
asserted
305 → relate → grants
In 2026, 335 of 1,609 grant continuations were changed, or 20.8%.
asserted
continuations → change → 2026
“The censorship that’s happening now is, I think, pretty much unprecedented,” said Jeremy Berg, a former director of the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, who has closely tracked changes in grant-making at the NIH.
asserted
who → happen → NIH
“It’s very Orwellian in the sense that it’s purely double-speak,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → sense
“It’s a way of exerting political control and control of the terms of the debate,” said Berg.
asserted
Berg → ’ → debate
The Guardian asked the NIH how many grants have been changed, and about the “text analysis” tool employed by NIH.
asserted
grants → ask → NIH
The agency said “more than 5,000 new and continuation grants” have been re-negotiated, “to ensure the agency funds the most meritorious science, addresses urgent health needs, and sustains a robust biomedical research workforce”.
asserted
agency → say → workforce
“During these grant renegotiations, grant scopes were substantively altered wherever possible to replace poorly defined, non-scientific or subjective concepts and variables with well-defined, scientific concepts that have objective and measurable variables,” an NIH spokesperson told the Guardian.
asserted
spokesperson → alter → Guardian
“Renegotiation is a normal process that NIH has used for years on grants for various reasons.
asserted
NIH → use → reasons
All renegotiated grants are assessed by human experts.”
asserted
grants → renegotiate → experts
The NIH’s renegotiation process was set into motion in 2025, after court battles slowed down Trump administration grant cancellations.
asserted
battles → set → cancellations
…and 16 more, not listed.