The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) modified its earlier directives on Monday, conditionally allowing the Peshawar High Court (PHC) to hear cases related to the preventive detention of PTI workers and activists under the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance (MPO) following the imposition of emergency and governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
asserted
Court → modify → Pakhtunkhwa
A two-member FCC bench, headed by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and comprising Justice Aamer Farooq, barred the PHC from hearing the cases on Nov 5, following which the PHC had removed the relevant cases from its cause list.
asserted
PHC → head → list
However, today, the bench allowed the PHC to take up the cases on the condition that the high court would not hear pleas that challenged the Oct 11 proclamation of emergency and imposition of governor’s rule in KP, where the army had also been called in aid of civil power.
asserted
army → allow → power
The superior court’s directives had come after the PHC had issued the interim orders, granting bail to detainees against surety bonds of Rs100,000 each.
asserted
PHC → come → Rs100,000
The FCC has been seized with more than 60 appeals against the PHC’s interim orders.
asserted
FCC → seize → orders
The pleas were moved by the KP Home and Tribal Affairs Department additional chief secretary.
asserted
pleas → move → secretary
The FCC had suspended the PHC proceedings in cases instituted under Article 199 of the Constitution.
asserted
FCC → suspend → Constitution
It had referred to clauses 3 and 4 of Article 245 of the Constitution in its order.
asserted
It → refer → order
Under clause 3, a high court shall not exercise any jurisdiction under Article 199 in relation to any area in which the armed forces of Pakistan are, for the time being, acting in aid of civil power.
asserted
forces → exercise → power
Moreover, the court had directed KP Advocate General Sanaullah Khan to furnish a report in relation to the areas in KP where the armed forces were no longer required to act in aid of civil power.
asserted
forces → direct → power
The FCC had indicated that it could reconsider its directives for the suspension of proceedings after examining the report.
uncertain
it → indicate → report
The KP advocate general also mentioned during the proceedings today that the provincial government had submitted the report sought by the FCC.
asserted
government → mention → FCC
In the report, the KP government said that, following the proclamation of emergency, the security apparatus had been operating under a unified civil-military stabilisation framework to safeguard lives, property and state installations across the province.
asserted
apparatus → say → province
It maintained that the deployment of armed forces under Article 245(3) and (4) had resulted in the suspension of high court proceedings under Article 199 instituted on or after Oct 12, arguing that the measure was necessary to protect executive security actions, including preventive detentions under the MPO, 1960, from “premature judicial interference”.
asserted
measure → maintain → interference
The report said security assessments showed that threats, terrorist networks and internal disturbances remained “fluid, volatile and interconnected” across all districts of KP.
asserted
threats → say → KP
The underlying security threats that had necessitated the imposition of emergency and deployment of armed forces had not been sufficiently eliminated or mitigated, it added.
asserted
it → underlie → forces
In view of the prevailing security situation and risks to public safety, the provincial government said the continued deployment of armed forces in aid of civil power remained indispensable across the province.
asserted
deployment → prevail → province
It added that the government did not intend to withdraw or de-notify the armed forces from any district or area at this stage.
asserted
government → add → stage
The KP government urged the FCC to maintain the suspension of Article 199 proceedings instituted on or after Oct 12 throughout the province, citing ongoing security threats and law and order concerns.
asserted
government → urge → threats
Gohar, PBC allowed to become parties
The FCC also allowed PTI Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan and the Peshawar Bar Council today to become parties in the proceedings after both submitted applications seeking the same.
asserted
both → allow → same
For his part, Barrister Gohar argued that the FCC’s Nov 5 order had severely affected proceedings before the high court and brought legal practice to a halt.
asserted
order → argue → halt
He urged the FCC to grant relief, pointing out that several PTI workers and activists remained in detention following the imposition of emergency in the province.
asserted
workers → urge → province
He also claimed that many arrested PTI leaders and workers were being held at Police Lines in KP.
asserted
leaders → claim → KP
Barrister Gohar also maintained that questions regarding the maintainability of the petitions before the PHC were yet to be decided.
asserted
questions → maintain → PHC
During the proceedings, Justice Farooq observed that a literal reading of Article 245 suggested that cases under Article 199 could not be heard.
uncertain
cases → observe → Article
However, he added that a strict interpretation of the provision would bring the entire judicial system to a standstill.
asserted
interpretation → add → standstill
Barrister Gohar further contended that no board had been constituted in KP to review the cases of preventive detentions.
asserted
board → contend → detentions
Responding to that, the provincial advocate general said the board would be formed after three months and that detainees could approach it if their detention exceeded that period.
uncertain
detention → respond → period
Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan observed that, apart from the Peshawar Bar Council’s application to become a party in the case, other such pleas had not yet been fixed for hearing.
asserted
pleas → observe → hearing
He also noted that the pleas had been filed at the FCC’s Peshawar Registry.
asserted
pleas → note → Registry
Justice Farooq said the matter was important and bar councils should be heard, as the issue of the imposition of emergency was of significant constitutional importance.
asserted
issue → say → importance
Governor’s rule and emergency
The federal government imposed emergency and governor’s rule in KP on Oct 11, citing the provincial government’s “deliberate disengagement” from the fight against terrorism.
asserted
government → impose → terrorism
The move has drawn criticism from the opposition, including Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam-Fazl chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman, National Assembly Opposition Leader Mehmood Khan Achakzai and Senate Opposition Leader Raja Nasir Abbas.
asserted
move → draw → Rehman
In the days preceding the imposition of governor’s rule in KP, political tensions between the Centre and the opposition — including the PTI which was in power in KP — had remained high since jailed former prime minister Imran Khan’s party announced a protest march to Islamabad to demand his release.
asserted
party → precede → release
Intense negotiations between the two sides a week before the imposition of governor’s rule had failed to yield any results.
asserted
negotiations → fail → results
Scores of PTI workers and leaders had been detained following the Oct 11 move, including lawmakers.
asserted
Scores → detain → lawmakers
Sohail Afridi, who has been rendered non-functional as the chief minister after the imposition of governor’s rule, has also been detained.
asserted
who → render → rule