A five-star Sydney hotel has left me wondering whether taking home a slice of leftover birthday cake really ought to require legal representation.
asserted
taking → leave → representation
After celebrating my daughter Audrey's 18th birthday at Sydney's rather grand Fullerton Hotel at the weekend, I made the apparently reckless decision to ask if we could take her uneaten dessert home.
uncertain
we → celebrate → dessert
I had anticipated a cardboard box.
asserted
I → anticipate → box
And the damn near useless wooden fork that manages to combine the texture of a Paddle Pop stick with the functionality of a toothpick.
asserted
that → manage → toothpick
Instead I was presented with a legal waiver.
asserted
I → present → waiver
Before staff would release the remaining cake into our custody I was required to acknowledge the food safety risks and agree to 'defend, indemnify and hold harmless' not only the hotel but also its trustees, beneficiaries, directors, officers, employees, agents, successors and assigns.
asserted
I → release → risks
If the venue's signature 32-layer chocolate cake somehow develops criminal gastrointestinal tendencies overnight, an impressive roster of trustees, beneficiaries and related parties can rest easy knowing they're legally protected from the fallout.
asserted
they → develop → fallout
The form, which took up an entire A4 page, even referred to something called 'Licensor's Gross Negligence or Wilful Misconduct'.
asserted
which → take → something
I've no idea who the Licensor is, but I hope they're keeping well.
asserted
they → hope → idea
All this so my daughter could take home the decadent $39 slice of cake she'd spent an entire week plotting to eat.
uncertain
she → take → cake
Made with premium Valrhona chocolate, the dessert comes with all the trimmings of luxury gastronomy including earnest discussions about the origin of the cocoa beans, the soil they were grown in and the climate that nurtured them.
asserted
that → make → them
Celebrating my daughter Audrey's (pictured) 18th birthday at the Fullerton Hotel, I made the apparently reckless decision to ask if we could take her uneaten dessert home
The Fullerton Hotel (pictured) in Sydney's CBD is owned by Sino Group, a leading property developer in Hong Kong
uncertain
Hotel → celebrate → Kong
The form (pictured) even referred to something called 'Licensor's Gross Negligence or Wilful Misconduct'
asserted
form → picture → something
And, look, the hype is justified.
asserted
hype → look → ?
It was, without question, the best cake my unapologetic sugar junkie has ever eaten.
asserted
junkie → eat → question
Leaving the leftovers behind was never going to be an option.
asserted
Leaving → leave → leftovers
So, I was more than a little surprised to discover I needed to sign away my legal rights before taking it home.
asserted
I → discover → it
If the Fullerton's doggy-bag indemnity feels familiar, it's because Australia has seen this movie before.
asserted
Australia → feel → movie
In 2015, diners at George Calombaris' Hellenic Republic in Melbourne made headlines after being asked to sign legal waivers before taking leftovers home.
asserted
diners → make → leftovers
At the time, it was widely dismissed as a case of restaurant red tape gone mad.
asserted
it → dismiss → tape
We may live in an increasingly litigious society, and it's easy to see why some of Sydney's top chefs use waivers to shield themselves from food poisoning claims and dodgy online reviews.
uncertain
some → live → claims
But if I've paid for the meal, I want the leftovers too.
asserted
I → pay → leftovers
Restaurants can choose whether to provide takeaway containers, refuse them under house policy, or allow customers to bring their own clean, reusable containers.
asserted
customers → choose → containers
The viral cake at the Fullerton was one of the best desserts I have ever had
In 2015 diners at George Calombaris' (pictured) Hellenic Republic in Melbourne made headlines after being asked to sign legal waivers before taking leftovers home
The NSW Food Authority says responsibility shifts to the customer once food leaves the premises.
asserted
food → have → premises
Consumers must store and handle leftovers safely to minimise the risk of food poisoning.
asserted
Consumers → store → poisoning
Bacteria commonly linked to food poisoning thrive between 5C and 60C, making prompt refrigeration essential.
asserted
refrigeration → link → 5C
In other words, if you're taking home that half-eaten tiramisu or unfinished lobster thermidor, the onus is on you to get it into the fridge as soon as possible.
asserted
onus → take → fridge
Yet despite decades of restaurant paranoia over leftovers, examples of Australian diners successfully suing a restaurant over food poisoning from a doggy bag are remarkably difficult to find.
asserted
diners → sue → bag
In fact, I couldn't find any.
asserted
I → find → any
John O'Shea, general manager of the Fullerton Hotel Sydney, said the waiver had formed part of the hotel's documented food safety procedures for a number of years.
asserted
waiver → say → years
Once food leaves the hotel, we are no longer able to monitor or control how it is transported, refrigerated, stored, reheated or subsequently consumed,' he told the Daily Mail.
asserted
he → leave → Mail
Mr O'Shea said potentially hazardous food needed to be kept at 5C or below, or 60C or above, and that the acknowledgement was intended to ensure guests understood responsibility for the safe handling and storage of leftovers transferred to them once the food left the hotel.
asserted
food → say → hotel
While some hotels, restaurants and catering businesses use similar waivers, he acknowledged it was not a universal industry practice.
Fullerton Hotel Sydney general manager John O'Shea (pictured) said the waiver had formed part of the hotel's documented food safety procedures for a number of years
'
asserted
waiver → use → years
It also addresses potential claims arising from circumstances outside the hotel's control and does not seek to exclude any rights or protections that cannot lawfully be excluded,' he said.
uncertain
he → address → rights
That's all perfectly sensible as far as food safety goes.
asserted
safety → go → ?
But it's still hard to escape the feeling that the paperwork was slightly disproportionate to the threat posed by a half-eaten slice of birthday cake.
asserted
paperwork → escape → cake
I'd come prepared for death by chocolate.
asserted
I → come → chocolate
I hadn't anticipated having to indemnify half the hotel's organisational chart against it.
asserted
I → anticipate → it
At no point was I offered independent legal advice, although admittedly I didn't ask for any.
asserted
I → offer → any
We just wanted the cake.
asserted
We → want → cake