Katrina, a 29-year-old postgraduate student, lives in an Edwardian mansion in Hampstead, London, as part of the property guardian scheme, paying £580 per month for her room including bills and council tax. The article highlights that property guardians have significantly fewer rights than private renters, with landlords able to evict them with just 28 days' notice. Katrina enjoys the communal aspect of living with others in the mansion, but notes the precarious nature of the arrangement, which is set to end when a developer converts the building into flats. The scheme allows people to live in unusual properties for discounted rent, but raises concerns about the temporary and often vulnerable situation of property guardians.
Written by the local model on 2026-08-21,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The article presents a neutral tone, but notes some potential drawbacks of property guardianship, such as fewer rights and precarious living arrangements. However, the use of words like 'incredible', 'romantic', and 'brilliant' to describe the mansion and its community may slightly bias towards a more positive view.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score -0.35 for article 156 · logged 2026-07-31
- Published
Would you live in a disused care home, pub or bank in exchange for a heavily discounted rent?
asserted
you → publish → rent
As cost of living pressures persist, a growing number of people are applying to become so-called property guardians - living in vacant residential or commercial buildings to protect them from squatters, vandalism and disrepair.
asserted
number → persist → squatters
They typically pay 30-50% less rent than private tenants, sometimes with bills thrown in, in exchange for looking after the buildings.
asserted
They → pay → buildings
However property guardians also have significantly fewer rights than private renters and can be evicted with just 28 days' notice.
asserted
guardians → have → notice
Katrina, 29, has spent the last 10 months living with around 50 other people in an Edwardian mansion in Hampstead, London, which was used as a care home until 2015.
asserted
which → spend → 2015
The postgraduate student, who says she could not afford to rent privately in the capital, currently pays £580 a month for her room including bills and council tax, about £400 below the London average, external.
uncertain
she → say → average
Katrina says guardianship gives her the chance to live in an unusual property and describes the mansion as an "incredible" and "romantic" place despite it being "quite run down".
asserted
it → say → place
Set in 1.7 acres of gardens, the building has grand staircases, south-west-facing balconies and chandeliers in some rooms, but it does have some downsides: "We've had mushrooms growing on the walls, leaks, parts of the balcony stonework have fallen off," says Katrina.
Katrina says she loves the communal aspect of guardianship, which is "somewhere between living in university halls, a block of flats and a fancy squat".
asserted
which → Set → flats
She lives with "all sorts of people", from lawyers to artists, sharing bathrooms, a kitchen and communal living areas, and regularly socialising.
But there are disagreements over things like noise, she says.
asserted
she → live → noise
And while Lowe, the company that manages the property, operates a stringent vetting process for its guardians, two residents have been asked to leave because of antisocial behaviour - one for alleged sexual harassment.
asserted
residents → manage → harassment
Lowe tells the BBC it acts "quickly and decisively" on the rare occasion someone breaches its standards and that the "overwhelming majority" of guardians go on to be "brilliant, community-minded residents".
asserted
majority → tell → guardians
In general, guardians have fewer rights than private renters, external because they hold a "licence to occupy" rather than a tenancy.
asserted
they → have → licence
Guardianship companies are not obliged to protect their deposits or carry out repairs not specifically provided for in the agreement.
asserted
companies → oblige → agreement
Landlords can also visit at any time, without warning, and evict residents without giving a reason.
asserted
Landlords → visit → reason
Katrina admits she worries about the temporary nature of her arrangement sometimes.
asserted
she → admit → arrangement
A developer bought the former care home last year and plans to turn it into flats, so she will eventually have to leave.
asserted
she → buy → flats
It's not guaranteed to last.
asserted
It → guarantee → ?
If anyone doesn't like that, it's not for them," she says.
asserted
she → like → them
Last year, the Property Guardian Providers Association (PGPA) estimated there were between 10,000 and 15,000 property guardians in the UK, mainly in major cities, with most aged between 20 and 35.
asserted
most → estimate → 20
The trade group says the number of people applying has risen sharply as rental costs soar.
asserted
costs → say → people
David Hale, 32, became a guardian almost 10 years ago to save money and has never lived in standard rental accommodation.
asserted
Hale → become → accommodation
He and his wife now rent a "massive" space at a former primary school in Brixton, South London, for around £1,500 a month, including bills and council tax.
asserted
He → rent → bills
He says they wouldn't be able to afford a similar property otherwise and save about £1,000 a month.
asserted
they → say → 1,000
You may stay for several years, or you may need to move on with relatively short notice.
uncertain
you → stay → notice
Choose an established guardian company: Look for a reputable provider with good health and safety procedures
Read your licence agreement carefully: Understand your responsibilities to the building, house rules and visitor policies
Know your rights: Guardians are legally entitled to a court order before they can be evicted and their home must be safe to live in
Embrace community living: Be considerate of those you live with and respect shared areas.
asserted
you → choose → areas
Sources: the Property Guardian Providers Association, Shelter, Ad Hoc Property Management
Around 20 guardians live in the school's open classrooms and offices, sharing a kitchen and large garden.
asserted
guardians → live → kitchen
But while David has enjoyed communal living, he and his wife are saving to buy their own home: "We wouldn't want to share toilets and bathrooms forever.
asserted
We → enjoy → toilets
We also want to start a family."
asserted
We → want → family
The PGPA believes guardianship could help ease the UK's housing crisis by providing affordable temporary accommodation for thousands of people.
uncertain
guardianship → believe → people
It points out that over a million homes currently stand empty, along with tens of millions of square feet, external of non-residential property.
asserted
homes → point → property
But housing charity Shelter argues the rise of property guardianship shows how people are being forced "further and further afield just to keep a roof over their heads".
asserted
people → argue → heads
"For most, this isn't a good alternative to an affordable, stable home," says chief executive Sarah Elliott.
asserted
Elliott → say → home
