Canada is facing a fiscal policy time bomb.
asserted
Canada → face → bomb
While much of the conversation rightly focuses on the rising debt the federal government continues to take on, there’s far less talk about the increasingly precarious fiscal position of Canada’s provinces.
asserted
government → focus → provinces
And provincial debt matters.
asserted
debt → matter → ?
The government of Prime Minister Mark Carney points to Canada’s net debt-to-gross domestic product (GDP) ratio being the lowest among G7 nations.
asserted
ratio → point → nations
That figure includes provincial debt, but the national average obscures how sharply fiscal outlooks differ from one province to another.
asserted
outlooks → include → another
Once that’s accounted for, Canada is one of the most indebted countries in the G7, and things are set to go from bad to worse.
asserted
things → account → worse
Economist Trevor Tombe calculates that combined federal and provincial credit-market debt now exceeds its mid-1990s level as a share of GDP.
asserted
debt → calculate → GDP
His research also shows that every provincial government ran a deficit in 2025, something not seen since the 2008 financial crisis.
asserted
government → show → crisis
Why are things bad and set to get worse?
asserted
things → set → ?
For one thing, many of Canada’s provinces have pursued bad fiscal policies of late, rapidly increasing government spending at levels far beyond inflation plus population growth.
asserted
many → pursue → inflation
And, for another, because of Canada’s aging population, the fiscal pressures on Canada’s provinces, particularly when it comes to health and long-term care, are only set to grow.
asserted
it → age → health
For too long, provincial politicians have chosen to pursue populist policies that aren’t really geared toward ensuring that provincial finances are sustainable over the long term.
asserted
finances → choose → term
Only in a couple of provinces, namely New Brunswick and Quebec, did politicians make choices over the past decade that actually saw their fiscal positions improve.
asserted
positions → make → decade
New Brunswick has since lost some ground.
asserted
Brunswick → lose → ground
In Quebec, policy choices began pushing the debt ratio upward in 2022, and Tombe projects a much steeper rise over the next 25 years.
asserted
Tombe → begin → years
Tombe suggests that provinces are going to have to fundamentally change how they do things.
uncertain
they → suggest → things
Policies must be pursued that encourage stronger economic growth, coupled with changes in the way governments both tax and spend.
asserted
governments → pursue → way
For one thing, to overcome some of the upcoming fiscal challenges, governments are going to need to encourage economic growth, primarily through private-sector job creation and investment.
asserted
governments → overcome → creation
To encourage that, provinces need to make their jurisdictions a more attractive place to do business, which means making the business environment more competitive through lower corporate taxes, fewer regulations and more abundant and affordable energy.
asserted
environment → encourage → taxes
For another, taxation and spending policies must change.
asserted
policies → change → another
For example, Tombe points out that, as the population ages, governments won’t be able to rely as heavily on income tax revenue.
asserted
governments → point → revenue
As folks retire, not only do they put more of a strain on social services like health care, but they also earn less, meaning less tax revenue for governments.
asserted
they → retire → governments
A long-term shift away from taxing income and more toward taxing consumption may be the answer.
uncertain
shift → tax → consumption
So too is reform in the way services are delivered.
asserted
services → deliver → way
Canada’s present health-care model isn’t working.
asserted
model → work → ?
Health-care provision in this country is far too expensive and costs are rising faster than governments can keep up with.
asserted
governments → rise → country
Countries in Europe that have embraced a mixed health-care system have not only had superior health outcomes, but also lower costs for taxpayers.
asserted
that → embrace → taxpayers
Looking at serious health-care reform is a must if provinces want to get their future expenses under control.
asserted
provinces → look → control
On that front, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is leading the way.
asserted
Smith → lead → way
The time to put the adults back in the room has come.
asserted
time → put → room
Canada cannot continue down the road it’s currently on.
asserted
it → continue → road
Present and anticipated future levels of debt are unsustainable and threaten to take away our ability to fund crucial services in the future and respond to future crises.
asserted
levels → anticipate → crises
The provincial debt issue must be addressed and it must be addressed head-on.
asserted
it → address → ?
As Tombe writes, “the next 25 years will be harder than the last ten for most provinces.
asserted
years → write → provinces
The sooner governments adjust, the less painful those adjustments will need to be.”
asserted
adjustments → adjust → ?