A former cop has blasted a push for tougher speeding fines after NSW raked in almost $325million from penalties this year, saying drivers who once might have received a warning for creeping over the limit are now fined by a 'robot'.
uncertain
who → blast → robot
Former Victoria Police officer Naomi Oakley said she is not surprised police are sometimes accused of 'revenue raising' amid concerns Australia's traffic enforcement system has gone too far.
asserted
system → say → concerns
'When I was in the police, we were taught to use discretion,' Ms Oakley told the Daily Mail.
asserted
Oakley → teach → Mail
'If someone was caught doing a few kilometres over, you'd chat to them, use a common-sense approach.'
asserted
you → catch → approach
Officers now had little leeway and Ms Oakley said with so many speed cameras on the road, drivers were more likely to be caught.
asserted
drivers → have → road
'When you get caught by one of the cameras, you are not dealing with a human, you're dealing with a robot,' she said.
'
asserted
she → catch → robot
The current penalty framework, combined with the growing number of speed cameras across suburban and urban areas, is placing disproportionate pressure on everyday drivers.
asserted
framework → combine → drivers
Post-Covid, there has been a marked increase in speed cameras, including in built-up and suburban streets where speed has not historically been a significant issue.'
asserted
speed → include → streets
Former Victoria Police officer Naomi Oakley has blasted a push for tougher speeding fines after NSW collected almost $325million from speed and red-light camera penalties in 2025–26
Oakley said police once had the discretion to warn drivers who strayed a few kilometres over the limit.
asserted
who → blast → limit
Now, she says, motorists are being fined by a 'robot'
asserted
motorists → say → robot
Ms Oakley, who served in the police force for 12 years, said it was now too easy for a driver to lose their licence and that fines could place significant pressure on families.
uncertain
fines → serve → families
'I know of people who are driving without a licence so they can get to work - they have to pay the bills,' she said.
asserted
she → know → bills
'Everyday people are now losing their licence and it's clogging up the court system.'
asserted
it → lose → system
Ms Oakley said she wants change for drivers caught committing low-level speeding offences, including shorter demerit point reset periods, as well as a wholesale review of Australia's demerit point system.
asserted
she → say → system
'A two-year window is a more balanced response measure for low-level or infrequent offences, avoiding excessive penalties for otherwise responsible drivers,' Ms Oakley said.
asserted
Oakley → avoid → drivers
'Reducing the demerit point window from three years to two years will maintain road safety while delivering a fairer, more balanced system that supports both compliance and community wellbeing.'
Claims that police are expected to issue a set number of fines via a quota have fuelled anger among motorists who accuse authorities of using traffic enforcement to raise revenue.
While she said there was no quota system during her time in the force, Ms Oakley said she had heard claims that targets may now operate in some areas, particularly highway patrol, and that parking inspectors work under a quota system.
uncertain
inspectors → reduce → system
While speeding fines vary by state and territory, drivers who exceed the limit can face fines up to $3,135
Her comments come after authorities recently expanded the use of artificial intelligence road safety cameras across Australia.
Earlier this month, Queensland adopted new software that allows AI to monitor drivers as they pass through traffic cameras, with hefty penalties issued to motorists caught using a mobile phone while driving or wearing a seatbelt incorrectly.
In South Australia, 17 new AI-powered road safety cameras are due to be rolled out within weeks, with the changes expected to generate around $1.1billion in revenue over the next four years.
asserted
changes → vary → years
Dr Raphael Grzebieta, emeritus professor at the University of NSW's Transport and Road Safety Research Unit, said enforcement fines are nowhere near enough.
asserted
fines → say → enough
He believes fines are the most effective way to make drivers realise they are putting others at risk.
asserted
they → believe → risk
'They’re lucky the fines are so low,' he told Nine.
asserted
he → ’re → Nine
Maybe the message will get through to people that they should stop speeding.'
Dr Grzebieta told the Daily Mail that fines could also be linked to a person's salary.
uncertain
fines → get → salary
'In countries like Norway and Finland, they link it to your salary.
asserted
they → link → salary
Depending on how much over the speed limit, people have had to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars,' he said.
asserted
he → depend → dollars
Six in 10 speeding fines issued by NSW cameras in 2025–26 went to drivers travelling 10km/h or less over the limit
Dr Raphael Grzebieta said Australia's fine system doesn't go far enough and needs a 'cultural' approach to change, laying the blame directly at the feet of politicians
'
asserted
system → issue → politicians
What we've got in Australia is fairly tame in comparison... these are countries that have extremely low (road) fatality rates.'
When asked why Australia's infringement notice rates continue to climb, Dr Grzebieta said it was a broader 'cultural issue' that needed to be addressed through legislation and education, laying the blame directly at the feet of politicians.
asserted
that → get → politicians
'Non-effective speed cameras!' he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
'Actually, from my perspective, it's the politicians that have blood at their feet, they're the ones that are governing.
asserted
that → have → feet
They can do things.
asserted
They → do → things
They can make changes, but they've ignored it.'
asserted
they → make → it
Dr Grzebieta said behavioural change would occur when drivers realise they could be 'booked' anywhere, at any time.
uncertain
they → say → time
He added: 'So what they've done in NSW, for example, where (police) put a sign out in front of a mobile speed camera, is just dumb.'
asserted
police → add → camera
Among the changes Dr Grzebieta is calling for are a greater rollout of red-light and point-to-point cameras, electronic speeding fines, and intelligent speed assistance systems for repeat offenders that prevent vehicles from exceeding the legal speed limit.
asserted
that → call → limit
'What I'd like to see for those that have copped a couple of fines is for them not to lose their licence, and instead have to use this interlock system, which would read speed signs or use GPS,' he said.
asserted
he → like → GPS
Australia's demerit point system has been exploited on the black market, with motorists paying others to take demerit points on their behalf
'
asserted
motorists → exploit → behalf
Europe's done it.
asserted
Europe → do → it
It's now mandatory for all new vehicles sold in the European Union to require this assistance.
asserted
vehicles → sell → assistance
He also called for federal Transport Minister Catherine King to introduce legislation that would close a loophole that currently allows motorists to transfer their demerit points to another driver.
asserted
motorists → call → driver
'At the moment, when I log onto my computer, I use my fingerprint to log on.
asserted
I → log → fingerprint
Or on your phone, you can use a facial image.
asserted
you → use → image
Why can't we have these vehicles linked to that?' he said.
asserted
he → have → that
…and 8 more, not listed.