DENVER — The race for the next Democratic presidential nomination has begun, with a festival of agreement.
asserted
race → begin → agreement
There was Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, telling the What’s Next conference that voters demanded action, not “shallow litmus tests or where we fall on some political spectrum.”
asserted
we → be → spectrum
There was Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin, explaining that voters did not want “marginal change” and Democrats weren’t in a battle of “progressive versus moderate.”
And there was Pete Buttigieg, who’d noticed the Democrats borrowing his formula.
asserted
Democrats → be → formula
They wanted to pass cost-cutting, pro-family bills with their new majority, then convince voters that they would never go back to pre-Trump neoliberalism.
asserted
they → want → neoliberalism
“It sounds good.
asserted
It → sound → ?
It’s easy to say,” said Buttigieg.
asserted
Buttigieg → ’ → ?
“Everybody thinks they already agree with this.”
asserted
they → think → this
The post-midterms conference, organized by Majority Democrats, was a payoff of a two-year investment by moderate donors.
asserted
conference → organize → donors
Two years before strategists and elected officials landed in Denver and grabbed their lanyards, the venture capitalist Seth London circulated a memo about how new candidate and media investments could steer the party away from “race and group-based identity politics,” and toward “prosperity for more Americans.”
uncertain
investments → elect → Americans
This year’s Democratic landslide carried along every kind of candidate —the ones plugged into the Majority Democrats network, and the ones who worried it was a big-money ploy to defeat the populist left.
asserted
it → carry → left
But the conference elevated the candidates who wanted to build a supermajority, battling big tech and environmental attorneys.
asserted
who → elevate → attorneys
Some donors were in; the donors who wanted them to move left were out.
asserted
them → want → ?
“Tell us which ideas you’ll stop giving permission to, the ones that defy common sense or didn’t work,” said Rep. Jake Auchincloss, the pedigreed Massachusetts Democrat who chairs the Majority Democrats PAC.
asserted
who → tell → PAC
“Tell us which privileges you’ll confront, even if your donors or allies object.”
Celebrating the center
The donors did know how to throw a party.
asserted
donors → tell → party
What’s Next resembled the sort of well-funded, media-friendly conferences that many Democrats have envied on the right, like the multi-day “AmericaFest” put on by Turning Point Action.
asserted
Democrats → ’ → Action
This was a party for the Democratic mainstream, the staffers most likely to work for center-left presidential candidates than for Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-NY.
asserted
This → work → Cortez
For two days, blocks of Denver’s River North Art District were cordoned off for Democrats, the people who elected them, and the reporters asking if they were running for president.
asserted
they → cordone → president
(Their answers were variations on “not yet.“)
There was conflict, but it was largely limited to the argument over who should lead Democrats’ new congressional majorities.
asserted
who → be → majorities
Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., who announced his challenge to Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer on Thursday, paused for 10 seconds of applause when he took the stage and explained why he was running.
asserted
he → announce → stage
“Candidates from different backgrounds and different parts of our party – they ran on a strikingly similar platform,” said Van Hollen.
asserted
Hollen → run → platform
“They didn’t run on the tired Washington labels of progressive versus moderate.
asserted
They → run → moderate
They ran on an economic populist message, on a commitment to fight for working people and take on a rigged economic and political system.”
asserted
They → run → system
Many of those winners showed up in Denver, like Texas Sen.-elect James Talarico and Iowa Gov.-elect Rob Sand.
asserted
Many → show → Talarico
They shared road stories of how they listened to Republican concerns, and would work with the willing ones to lower prices.
asserted
they → share → prices
But it was implied that Democrats should focus on building homes, lowering bills, and expanding health care before they did anything else.
asserted
they → imply → anything
Not every attendee agreed.
asserted
attendee → agree → ?
“The organizers here want a big tent, one big enough to even invite anti-establishment voices like me,” said Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Ca., who Democrats see as a competitor for a Sen. Bernie Sanders lane in the primary.
asserted
Democrats → want → primary
“A big tent cannot mean that we water down principle for political expediency.
asserted
we → mean → expediency
“Apart from Khanna, the likely presidential candidates didn’t quite do that.
asserted
candidates → do → that
Mallory McMorrow, who Majority Democrats supported in her unsuccessful U.S. Senate bid in Michigan, told Semafor that her party had just shown that it could have a loud primary argument and then unite on the basics.
uncertain
it → support → basics
“It’s anti-corruption, getting money out of politics, protecting democracy, ending wars,” said McMorrow.
asserted
McMorrow → get → wars
David’s view
There will be many Democratic “cattle calls,” but I am focusing on how What’s Next was built because it’s the fruit of a two-year effort to ensure that the 2028 primary plays out differently than the 2020 primary.
asserted
primary → focus → primary
There is widespread agreement among Democratic strategists that their last open primary was defined by left-wing organizations that wanted candidates to commit to their ideas, eyeball to eyeball, on camera.
asserted
candidates → be → camera
That meant forums organized by groups like Planned Parenthood and MoveOn, and more progressive labor unions like SEIU.
asserted
That → mean → SEIU
That meant the ACLU asking candidates if they would commit to cutting the federal prison population in half, and Movimiento Cosecha bird-dogging Joe Biden at his own events until he committed to stopping most deportations.
asserted
he → mean → deportations
If the left sees Majority Democrats as an effort to swipe their strongest messaging and junk the rest, they’re right.
asserted
they → see → rest
The economic populism in Denver was more sincere than they might think, but it is against degrowth and for permitting reform; skeptical of single-payer health care, but for incremental steps to “universal” health care; basically, right in the sweet spot of the Democrats’ congressional caucuses.
uncertain
it → think → caucuses
Right now the Schumer-Van Hollen contest is where the fights over ideology and priorities are happening.
asserted
fights → happen → ideology
The 2028 candidates would prefer to agree, for now.
asserted
candidates → prefer → ?
The left was not letting the rest of the party adopt its ideas without a fight.
asserted
rest → let → fight
…and 11 more, not listed.