The Trump administration is finalizing a rule to reimburse doctors who diagnose, treat and counsel patients with side effects from vaccines in what experts believe is an attempt to undermine trust in vaccines and to create an evidence base on their purported risks.
asserted
experts → finalize → risks
Robert F Kennedy Jr, the secretary of the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), also announced the creation of a vaccine “injury” research center at the National Institutes of Health and has sought to reshape the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) – actions that point to Kennedy’s longtime activism against vaccination as well as the profits he and his network have made from vaccine lawsuits.
asserted
he → announce → lawsuits
Kennedy and his allies have also profited from growing misinformation peddled through books, paid speaking events and the supplement industry.
asserted
Kennedy → profit → books
“I do think he’s a real ideologue – he really believes in this,” said Dorit Reiss, professor of law at UC Law San Francisco.
asserted
Reiss → think → Francisco
But Kennedy and his allies are likely “very happy to make money doing it”, she said.
asserted
she → make → it
Peter Hotez, professor and dean of Baylor College of Medicine’s National School of Tropical Medicine, agreed, saying Kennedy’s actions are likely a combination of “being an ideological zealot and making money either for himself or for his associates”.
asserted
actions → agree → associates
Emily Hilliard, an HHS spokesperson, said the department “categorically reject claims that Secretary Kennedy is pursuing personal gain or seeking to dismantle American medicine”.
uncertain
Kennedy → say → medicine
, Kennedy disclosed $2.5m in income from referrals for vaccine-related lawsuits.
asserted
Kennedy → disclose → lawsuits
In the hearing, Kennedy would not commit to forgoing compensation from vaccine lawsuits after he leaves office.
asserted
he → commit → office
Elizabeth Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, listed several ways in which Kennedy’s actions, some of which have now happened, could influence future litigation.
uncertain
some → list → litigation
“Kennedy can kill off access to vaccines and make millions of dollars while he does it,” Warren said at the hearing.
asserted
Warren → kill → hearing
“Kids might die.
uncertain
Kids → die → ?
But Robert Kennedy can keep cashing in.”
asserted
Kennedy → keep → ?
She pointed to Kennedy’s involvement in litigation against Merck for its HPV vaccine – lawsuits that were settled for more than $50m in June 2026.
asserted
that → point → June
After the confirmation hearing, Kennedy said his son would receive the money, expected to be 10% of the total; it’s unclear if he did.
uncertain
he → say → total
“For most of us, money going to our children isn’t exactly money not going to us,” Reiss said.
asserted
Reiss → go → us
“There’s a dozen ways he and his family could benefit” from Kennedy’s actions, she added.
uncertain
she → ’ → actions
Kennedy has long profited from his anti-vaccine misinformation.
asserted
Kennedy → profit → misinformation
Tony Lyons, Kennedy’s publisher and a central figure in the constellation of Maha political organizations, reportedly paid Kennedy $4m in book advances over the past year.
uncertain
Lyons → pay → year
The publisher also paid Kennedy $451,000 in consulting fees before he became HHS secretary.
asserted
he → pay → fees
That’s on top of other book sales and paid speaking engagements over the years
asserted
That → ’ → years
Kennedy also earned $326,000 for the 15 weeks he served as chairman of Children’s Health Defense in 2023 – more than half of his $510,000 salary in 2022.
asserted
he → earn → 2022
More recently, he received free flights and trips on a yacht from a former donor to his presidential campaign, who is now under investigation by the Senate for the gifts totaling some $250,000.
asserted
who → receive → 250,000
As HHS secretary, Kennedy has also loosened regulations on peptides, a booming part of the largely unregulated wellness industry.
asserted
Kennedy → loosen → industry
“I think he’s doing what everyone knew he was going to do,” said Hotez.
asserted
Hotez → think → ?
Kennedy, before and during his tenure as leader of HHS, has been “chipping away at public confidence in vaccines and immunizations in favor of products that can be sold by the wellness industry”, he added.
asserted
he → chip → industry
Aaron Siri, Kennedy’s former lawyer who represents people who say they have experienced severe side effects, has advocated for changing all vaccines to “shared clinical decision-making”.
asserted
they → represent → making
If those changes took place, Siri could argue that the vaccines are not covered under the VICP and therefore open to litigation.
uncertain
vaccines → take → litigation
“A lot of what he is doing is geared toward setting up a more profitable litigation atmosphere,” Reiss said.
asserted
Reiss → do → atmosphere
Siri did not respond to the Guardian’s question about profiting from litigation, but instead argued that “if vaccines are as ‘safe’ as touted by the government, then there should be no need for immunity to liability and, likewise, there should be very few, if any, successful cases”.
asserted
vaccines → respond → liability
The most common claim to VICP – making up more than half – has to do with where the vaccine is administered, not the vaccines themselves.
uncertain
vaccine → make → vaccines
The VICP was established in 1986 in order to expedite compensation for anyone who experienced adverse side effects from vaccines.
asserted
who → establish → vaccines
There are real costs to undermining the program, Reiss said.
asserted
Reiss → be → program
It’s very rare for people to develop severe side effects after vaccination, but when they do, they should be compensated, she said.
asserted
she → ’ → vaccination
But if false claims about vaccine harms proliferate, they will obscure those with legitimate claims.
uncertain
they → proliferate → claims
Filing a VICP claim is an easier process than winning a lawsuit, which takes time and effort and also demands a higher burden of proof.
uncertain
which → file → proof
“That’s why the whole vaccine injury system was set up,” Hotez said.
asserted
Hotez → ’ → ?
“It was actually to the plaintiff’s benefit to get a faster judgment without having to show detailed evidence of proof.”
asserted
It → get → proof
Without VICP, patients would need to pay lawyers a large chunk of their settlements, if their case moves through the courts at all, Reiss said: “The lack of contingency fee means they don’t have to pay 30% to 50% of their earnings through the lawyer.”
asserted
they → need → lawyer
Compensating doctors for reporting side effects to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) risks offering “the wrong incentives” to unscrupulous providers who could increase such activities to become a new revenue source, Reiss said.
uncertain
Reiss → compensate → activities
…and 13 more, not listed.