During his decades-long career with the CIA, Dennis Wilder spent a lot of time in China.
asserted
Wilder → spend → China
And whenever he returned to his hotel room in the evenings, he says, the same thing kept happening.
asserted
thing → return → evenings
"Almost inevitably, a young lady, very attractive, would step onto the elevator," he says.
"
asserted
he → step → elevator
I would press the button for my floor.
asserted
I → press → floor
She would come up with me.
asserted
She → come → me
And then she'd ask if I wanted her to come to my room."
Wilder, who was a China specialist with the agency and now lectures at Georgetown University, says he never took the obvious bait.
asserted
he → ask → bait
But he knows plenty of American men did.
asserted
plenty → know → men
The next morning, they would get a knock on the door.
asserted
they → get → door
They would be greeted by someone with incriminating photos, warned they had broken the law, and encouraged to "cooperate" — often by sharing sensitive information.
asserted
they → greet → information
But it is also a very real method used by China's Ministry of State Security (MSS), Wilder says.
asserted
Wilder → use → Security
The intelligence agency's activities are in the spotlight following the resignation of Nvidia chief Jensen Huang amid a swirl of suggestions he had been in a relationship with a suspected MSS asset.
asserted
he → follow → asset
Several former intelligence officers told the ABC the saga had also highlighted the US's haphazard approach to countering Chinese espionage.
asserted
saga → tell → espionage
"Inside the intelligence community, they'll tell you we're getting shellacked," former intelligence officer Nicholas Eftimiades says.
asserted
Eftimiades → tell → you
"What the US needs is a real strategy, and we don't have one."
asserted
we → need → one
China denies being behind anything nefarious in the Huang case, but multiple investigations are underway.
asserted
investigations → deny → case
Wilder sees it as a cautionary tale.
asserted
Wilder → see → tale
"Many, many American businessmen, diplomats, defence attaches unfortunately have fallen for this," he says.
asserted
he → fall → this
"It happens still, frequently.
asserted
It → happen → ?
The MSS, in fact, is much more bold than they used to be.
asserted
they → use → fact
Avoiding spies
Silicon Valley has become increasingly wary of espionage threats, particularly as the US and China aggressively compete on AI technology.
asserted
US → avoid → technology
OpenAI was reminded of the risks when an employee, a Saudi national, was charged with wrapping a recording device in toilet paper and planting it inside a conference room last month.
asserted
employee → remind → room
OpenAI company training warns employees that spies may try to seduce them, among other strategies, The Wall Street Journal reported in October.
uncertain
Journal → warn → October
The training advises staff to avoid wearing OpenAI's logo outside the office, to use screen protectors to reduce visibility on public transport, and thoroughly wipe whiteboards after use in case onsite cleaning staff are compromised.
asserted
staff → advise → case
But it is rare for someone at CEO level, like Huang, to be a target, says Holden Triplett, a former FBI special agent who worked in Beijing.
"
asserted
who → say → Beijing
It's possible that MSS knew that he had already had out-of-marriage relationships," Triplett says, referring to media reports alleging Mr Huang had two other affairs.
asserted
Huang → know → affairs
"They may have detected a vulnerability and put someone who might be of interest to him nearby.
uncertain
who → detect → him
That is among the theories that may be probed by the FBI, the US Congress and the Nvidia board, which are all investigating Huang's relationship with tech executive Alice Huang (no relation).
uncertain
which → probe → Huang
They will examine whether she was a Chinese asset recruited by the MSS to spy on Jensen Huang, influence his dealings with government, steal Nvidia's secrets, or all of the above.
asserted
she → examine → above
They are also expected to look into her company, Megaspeed.
asserted
They → expect → company
US officials reportedly suspect it has smuggled Nvidia's highest-powered chips into China, despite export restrictions designed to prevent them from reaching the country.
uncertain
it → suspect → country
(Megaspeed this week said it welcomed the government scrutiny and was committed to demonstrating through concrete actions that it operates in accordance with the law.)
asserted
it → say → law
Intelligence agencies have been looking into similar questions for months, according to a series of reports in the New York Times.
uncertain
agencies → look → Times
But China says they are "smears".
asserted
they → say → ?
"The US should stop fabricating the 'Chinese spy' narratives as a pretext for imposing technology restrictions," Chinese spokeswoman Mao Ning said this week.
asserted
Ning → stop → restrictions
Triplett, who now runs a risk-advisory firm, says the most concerning issue is how the relationship may have undermined those restrictions.
uncertain
relationship → run → restrictions
"By potentially having conversations with [Jensen Huang], understanding how export controls work and what Nvidia is willing to do, how much were they able to circumvent the export controls that we've had in the last few years?" Triplett says.
"
asserted
Triplett → have → years
It sounds like quite a bit."
asserted
It → sound → bit
US President Donald Trump was informed about intelligence agencies' suspicions of Alice Huang last year and again in May, according to the Times.
uncertain
Trump → inform → Times
But Trump told a press conference he did not know of the allegations when he invited Mr Huang on a trip to China earlier this year.
asserted
he → tell → China
Pressed further on when he was told, he said he would "have to check".
asserted
he → press → ?
…and 20 more, not listed.