Pakistan told the UN Security Council on Wednesday that it would respond to terrorist threats emanating from Afghanistan in self-defence as and when needed and in accordance with international law.
asserted
it → tell → law
The assertion by Pakistan’s Permanent Representative to the United Nations Asim Iftikhar Ahmad came during a Security Council meeting on the situation in Afghanistan five years after the Taliban’s takeover of Kabul.
asserted
assertion → come → Kabul
“Pakistan cannot sit idle in the face of this terrorist onslaught,” Ahmad told the UNSC.
asserted
Ahmad → sit → UNSC
“We will respond in self-defence, as and when needed and in accordance with international law.
asserted
We → respond → law
We will defend ourselves against whosoever attempts to harm our citizens and our national security.”
asserted
whosoever → defend → citizens
He said that more than 4,700 Pakistanis had lost their lives to terrorism emanating from Afghanistan over the past three years and added that Kabul had failed to take concrete and verifiable action against terrorist groups operating from Afghan soil.
asserted
Kabul → say → soil
Afghanistan had again become a safe haven for terrorist groups including the banned Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan, Baloch Liberation Army and its Majeed Brigade, Islamic State-Khorasan and the East Turkestan Islamic Movement, as well as their affiliates, Pakistan’s envoy said.
asserted
envoy → become → Pakistan
“The situation [is] made worse by external actors, the spoilers who support proxies inside Afghanistan to target Pakistan and other neighbouring countries,” he added.
asserted
he → make → Pakistan
A recent report by UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres says terrorist groups remain present in Afghanistan, while restrictions on women and girls, exclusionary governance, economic pressures, declining capacity to provide basic services and large-scale returns and migration continue to threaten the country’s longer-term stability.
asserted
restrictions → say → stability
Armed groups opposed to the Taliban also remain active.
asserted
groups → oppose → Taliban
According to the report, such groups claimed responsibility for 88 attacks across 21 Afghan provinces between May 1 and the end of July.
uncertain
groups → accord → July
The report identifies the institutionalised denial of the rights of women and girls and the authoritarian nature of the Afghan Taliban’s political system among the most serious concerns.
asserted
report → identify → concerns
It says these policies affect Afghan society and remain obstacles to the country’s reintegration into the international system.
asserted
policies → say → system
Against this backdrop, Ahmad said Islamabad had supported Afghanistan’s stabilisation through engagement, humanitarian assistance and regional cooperation.
asserted
Islamabad → say → engagement
“Despite reservations with regard to certain policies of the Afghan Taliban, Pakistan abided by its international commitments to allow unhindered humanitarian aid to Afghanistan.
asserted
Pakistan → abide → Afghanistan
As noted in the secretary general’s report, at least 687 humanitarian cargo trucks entered Afghanistan from Pakistan during the reporting period,” he said.
asserted
he → note → period
But, “unfortunately, the hopes and expectations of the international community at that critical juncture five years ago did not materialise and in fact gradually turned into despair and disappointment”.
asserted
hopes → materialise → despair
“The extent of challenges in Afghanistan is evident … and the secretary general’s report highlights that the semblance of relative stability that the Taliban seek to display ‘masks the accumulating risks that could impact the country’s stability over the short and long term’“, he said.
uncertain
he → highlight → term
Ahmad said terrorism had been at the “core of Afghanistan’s problems”.
asserted
terrorism → say → problems
“This finds its roots in the deep nexus between the Taliban and terrorist groups,” he said, adding that the Afghan Taliban had failed to act against the terrorist groups.
asserted
Taliban → find → groups
He further warned about weapons left behind in Afghanistan by international forces and illegal arms trafficking.
asserted
He → warn → forces
The United States took a similarly critical position on the Afghan Taliban, with Ambassador Mike Waltz focusing on the detention of American citizens, terrorism and restrictions on women and girls.
“The United States will not tolerate the Taliban taking American citizens hostage.
asserted
Taliban → take → hostage
Period,” Waltz said, accusing the Afghan Taliban of using American citizens as bargaining chips.
asserted
Waltz → say → chips
He called on the Security Council to condemn the detention of US citizens by the Afghan Taliban and demand their release.
asserted
He → call → release
Waltz also criticised the Taliban’s sheltering of terrorist groups and cited UN reporting on arbitrary arrests and detention, torture, ill-treatment and extrajudicial killings.
asserted
Waltz → criticise → arrests
He highlighted the continuing ban on girls’ education beyond sixth grade and restrictions preventing Afghan women working for the United Nations from entering UN compounds.
asserted
He → highlight → compounds
The envoy questioned how long the international community could continue relying on engagement without seeing concrete changes.
uncertain
community → question → changes
How many years of ‘engagement’ can we pass before we see measurable results?” he asked.
asserted
he → pass → results
“This Council must demand results from the Taliban,” Waltz said.
asserted
Waltz → demand → Taliban
“We need to see action, not words.”
asserted
We → need → action
Russia, on the other hand, argued that engagement rather than pressure remained essential in Afghanistan’s case.
asserted
engagement → argue → case
Ambassador Vassily Nebenzia said there was “no alternative” to genuine, pragmatic engagement with Afghanistan.
asserted
Nebenzia → say → Afghanistan
Recalling the withdrawal of foreign forces five years ago, he said predictions that Afghanistan would collapse or become a “black hole” had not materialised.
asserted
Afghanistan → recall → forces
Nebenzia attributed the country’s relative stability to the Taliban’s focus on development, regional cooperation and building a self-reliant state.
asserted
Nebenzia → attribute → state
He called for trust-based dialogue with the Afghan authorities, “fully free from the language of pressure and blackmail”.
asserted
He → call → pressure
China also argued for continued engagement while acknowledging concerns over the treatment of women.
asserted
China → argue → women
Deputy Ambassador Sun Lei urged all parties to “cherish the outcomes of engagement and dialogue with the Afghan government, show good faith and stay patient”.
But he said restrictions imposed on Afghan women and girls affected their physical and mental health and undermined social stability and development prospects, making it harder for Afghanistan to gain greater international support.
asserted
Afghanistan → urge → support
China called on the Afghan rulers to guarantee the fundamental rights and interests of all Afghans, including women.
asserted
China → call → women
Seemingly referring to the US, it called on a “relevant country” to “bear its historical responsibilities” by resuming aid to Afghanistan, lifting unilateral sanctions, returning the overseas assets of the Central Bank of Afghanistan and providing resources for the country’s reconstruction and development.
asserted
it → refer → reconstruction
The debate highlighted the central disagreement over how the international community should deal with Afghanistan five years after the Taliban takeover.
asserted
community → highlight → takeover
The Aporia
