Six-year-old Gaza burn victim caught in Israeli dispute over aid
CAIRO/GAZA, Nov 13 -
asserted
victim → catch → aid
The excruciating burns run around the side of Masa Yassin's tiny face, behind her ear, over her scalp and down her neck.
asserted
burns → run → neck
Since her family's tent burst into flames when a nearby cooking gas tank exploded in July, part of the 6-year-old girl's treatment has been a clear plastic 3D-printed mask, which helps manage swelling and control the scars on her face.
asserted
which → burst → face
But soon she will outgrow it, and the international medical charity Medecins Sans Frontieres, which operates the only clinic in Gaza that can make her a new one, says it has been barred by Israel from importing the plastic.
asserted
it → outgrow → plastic
"Should there be no masks, my daughter will grow more scar tissue," said Masa's mother Islam Yassin, as she gently adjusted straps on the mask of the girl on her lap on a plastic chair in their tent in a camp in Gaza City.
asserted
she → grow → City
"We would have to resort to surgery instead of masks, and there are no such surgeries in Gaza."
asserted
We → have → Gaza
ISRAELI DISPUTE WITH MSF
More than a year since a ceasefire halted major fighting in Gaza, the entire population of more than 2 million Palestinians lives confined to around a third of the tiny enclave's territory, mainly in makeshift tents and damaged buildings.
asserted
population → halt → tents
Israeli forces still control everything that enters and exits.
asserted
that → control → everything
Israel says it allows in all needed medical equipment and supplies.
asserted
it → say → equipment
But many aid groups say restrictions make it impossible to provide basic treatment desperately needed by a vulnerable population besieged inside a conflict zone.
asserted
it → say → zone
The custom masks provided by MSF for scores of Gazan burn victims have become embroiled in a dispute between the international medical charity and Israel over Israeli demands for information about local staff working for foreign groups.
asserted
masks → provide → groups
Israel has banned MSF's international staff from Gaza and barred the group from importing any supplies since the end of February, after MSF refused an Israeli demand to submit names of all its local staff in Gaza.
asserted
MSF → ban → Gaza
MSF says it cannot provide such lists without assurances staff would be safe, because hundreds of medics have been killed during the war.
asserted
hundreds → say → war
In a response to a request for comment, COGAT, the unit of the Israeli military responsible for aid to Gaza, confirmed it had barred imports by MSF for failure to comply with requirements, including supplying staff lists needed to prevent "the misuse of humanitarian aid by terrorist organisations".
asserted
it → confirm → organisations
It said that unlike MSF, other aid groups had complied and were operating freely.
asserted
groups → say → MSF
It had approved the entry of more than 24,000 tons of medical supplies into Gaza, it said, and rejected accusations that it was blocking medical aid as a falsehood spread by Hamas militants.
asserted
it → approve → militants
MSF says complying with the Israeli registration requirement would put its staff in danger, and that the victims of the restrictions are vulnerable Palestinian patients like Masa.
asserted
victims → say → Masa
"A child's mutilated face can no longer receive even a basic treatment, not because the technology or the expertise is lacking, but because Israel imposes a regime under which healing itself is a privilege," Filipe Ribeiro, MSF's head of mission for Palestine, said in a message to Reuters.
asserted
Ribeiro → mutilate → Reuters
At an MSF clinic in Gaza City, technicians measured Masa's face to try to see if they could make adjustments to her existing mask so she can keep wearing it for longer as she grows, since they do not have supplies to make a new one.
uncertain
they → measure → one
"We have now exhausted our stock of plastic sheets and printer filament," said Mohammed Al-Qatrawi, supervisor of physiotherapy for MSF France in Gaza at the clinic.
asserted
Qatrawi → exhaust → clinic
Once Masa grows and her mask no longer fits properly, it could cause her pain and limit the benefits, he said.
uncertain
he → grow → benefits
Demand has been surging.
asserted
Demand → surge → ?
There are 70 patients, including 50 children, receiving treatment for facial burns, 20 of whom need masks urgently, he said.
asserted
he → be → masks
With so many children needing new masks, MSF has been decorating some of them with drawings of cartoon characters such as the Smurfs and SpongeBob SquarePants.
asserted
MSF → need → Smurfs
If the clinic were forced to halt its service, patients such as Masa would "develop scar-related complications that can affect speaking, eating, drinking, vision, and facial movement," he said.
asserted
he → force → speaking
Children would have worse deformities that could leave them ostracised.
uncertain
that → have → them
Back outside her tent, Masa plays marbles in the dirt with her twin sister and their younger sister.
asserted
Masa → play → sister
You can see her face beneath the clear plastic as she smiles.
asserted
she → see → plastic
The Aporia
