A review of the University of Toronto’s policies and practices has found the school has a “general pattern of over-policing and under-protecting” Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians, with a report laying out dozens of recommendations related to academic freedom, on-campus security methods, institutional autonomy and other concerns.
asserted
school → find → campus
The university, however, says it cannot accept the report or recommendations issued by its Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian discrimination working group, which it says “departs significantly from past equity reports in several ways,” such as including “lengthy commentary about events abroad.”
asserted
it → say → events
The school nonetheless promises to take immediate actions to address discrimination against those groups at the university.
asserted
school → promise → university
The nearly 300-page report is based on consultations with 85 people and small groups as well as 525 responses to a survey of students, staff, faculty and librarians across the school’s three campuses.
asserted
report → base → campuses
These were carried out between March of last year and January.
asserted
These → carry → year
The university says it received the working group’s final report a month ago and is releasing it as part of its commitment to transparency.
asserted
it → say → transparency
Both the report and the school’s response were shared online Thursday.
asserted
report → share → ?
The report describes restrictions on speech and events, inconsistent processes in dealing with complaints, and double standards in enforcement related to protests and postering, as well as repeated complaints about the university’s successful litigation to get rid of a pro-Palestinian encampment on campus two years ago.
asserted
report → describe → campus
Similarly, there were recurring concerns that “the university’s institutional commitment to radical, critical teaching and research suffers from a Palestine exception,” the report said.
asserted
report → be → exception
The working group also heard about bigoted attitudes and assumptions steeped in stereotypes painting Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians as terrorists, misogynists and antisemites, it said.
asserted
it → work → terrorists
“The most prevalent pattern we encountered, however, was a generalized ignorance of the histories, cultures, and lived experiences of Muslims, Arabs, and Palestinians, and the ways in which anti-Muslim, anti-Arab, and anti-Palestinian discrimination and harassment take shape,” the report said.
asserted
report → encounter → shape
“Relatedly, we learned about instances when innovative research or outreach activities on issues of interest to Muslim, Arab, or Palestinian members of the university were viewed as instances of antisemitism calling for disciplinary action.
asserted
research → learn → action
The report lists 57 recommendations that include reviewing safety and risk metrics and how they get applied; ensuring that protests and postering are policed in a content-neutral manner; issuing stronger guidance to administrators on procedural fairness in handling complaints and regarding the cancellation or postponement of events that have already been scheduled.
asserted
that → list → events
Other recommendations relate to addressing concerns of bias in the university’s partnerships with organizations such as school boards that accept student-teacher placements and hospitals involved in affiliation agreements.
asserted
that → relate → agreements
One example cited in the report says that many clinical faculty reported “being cited for unprofessionalism when signing an open letter supporting medical workers in Gaza.”
asserted
faculty → cite → Gaza
The report makes further recommendations regarding the university’s investments, including that it “consider an absolute prohibition on investments that aid and/or abet violations of peremptory norms of international law.”
asserted
that → make → law
The consultations showed that “what happens around the world has implications locally on our campus, in our hallways, and in our classrooms,” the report said.
asserted
report → show → classrooms
“Our consultations began in 2025 as Israel continued its campaign of large-scale violence in the Gaza Strip, the West Bank, Syria, Lebanon, Yemen and Iran.
asserted
Israel → begin → Strip
University members explained how their experiences on campus were refracted through this global conflict and its history,” it said.
asserted
it → explain → conflict
“Many reflected on the university in light of published reports from human rights organizations, genocide scholars, international lawyers, and multilateral and international bodies that increasingly described Israel’s actions in Gaza as apartheid and/or genocide.
asserted
that → reflect → apartheid
In a written response, the university acknowledged that anti-Muslim, anti-Arab and anti-Palestinian discrimination exists at the school and said it is committed to addressing the issue.
asserted
it → write → issue
Still, it’s understandable that the working group and the university administration wouldn’t fully agree on the range of issues raised in the report, “nor about the ideal responses to those issues – particularly given the fraught circumstances, passionate feelings, and ongoing global conflict informing many of the situations described,” it said.
asserted
it → ’ → situations
“While we expect that the working group’s report will validate the experiences of many members of our community, aspects will also be offensive and upsetting to other members of our community, including some Jewish and Israeli colleagues and students,” it said.
asserted
it → expect → colleagues
The school cited multiple reasons for rejecting the report and its recommendations, including that some recommendations clash with collective agreements and protections related to academic freedom, some fall outside the university’s jurisdiction, and some don’t align with the university’s “position of institutional restraint.”
asserted
some → cite → restraint
The university said it already offers spaces that Muslim communities can use for prayer and spiritual practice, but will do more work to ensure there are appropriate Muslim prayer spaces and multi-faith spaces on each of its three campuses.
asserted
communities → say → campuses
The school’s new office of human rights, equity and inclusion will also release an e-module on discrimination against Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians, and hold an information session for members of its governing council.
“The university has supported and is committed to continued support for a range of scholarly activities, including research related to Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian communities, as well as academic initiatives focused on Palestinian history and culture,” it said.
asserted
it → release → history
The Aporia
