Imagine a state senator posts an internship ad.
asserted
senator → imagine → ad
It offers a $1,000 stipend in her office, but the requirements are that applicants must identify as Christian or white and have a 3.5 GPA.
asserted
applicants → offer → GPA
Before lunch, the story would be national news, the senator would be defending herself on cable, and a civil rights lawyer would be drafting a complaint.
asserted
lawyer → defend → complaint
Colorado State Senator Iman Jodeh, the first Muslim elected to the state legislature, and Representative Yara Zokaie — the first Iranian-American elected to the Colorado legislature, both Democrats — recently posted an internship advertisement for the MENASA & Muslim Joint Legislative Caucus; qualifications are explicit: applicants must identify as Muslim and/or Middle Eastern, North African, or South Asian.
asserted
applicants → elect → Caucus
No other religious or ethnic identity need apply.
asserted
identity → apply → ?
The ad does not invite Christians, Jews, Hindus, atheists, or anyone outside the approved categories.
asserted
ad → invite → categories
This is a government-adjacent internship funded and operated through the machinery of the Colorado legislature, yet it filters candidates by faith, ethnicity, race, and ancestry.
asserted
it → fund → faith
The reaction has been predictable among those still attached to the old, valuable, and honorable American idea that the state should not prefer one religion over another.
asserted
state → prefer → another
The same criteria applied to any other group — an internship restricted to practicing Christians, or to Jews, or to white applicants — would trigger immediate legal action and institutional panic.
asserted
criteria → apply → action
American anti-discrimination law, rooted in the Equal Protection Clause and statutes that govern public employment and government programs, rejects official classifications based on religion or national origin when they exclude citizens from opportunity.
asserted
they → root → opportunity
Courts have long treated such barriers with skepticism precisely because the state is supposed to remain neutral among citizens.
asserted
state → treat → citizens
One need not invent a fictional Supreme Court ruling to grasp the principle.
asserted
One → invent → principle
A public internship that announces “Muslims preferred, others need not apply” collides with that principle.
asserted
others → announce → principle
The selective silence surrounding this particular exclusion is revealing.
asserted
silence → surround → exclusion
The same voices that police every micro-aggression against protected classes suddenly discover the virtues of “affinity groups” and “lived experience” when the affinity is Islamic, and the experience is Middle Eastern.
asserted
experience → police → groups
Equal protection, it turns out, is not a principle.
asserted
it → turn → ?
But a deeper religious layer is worth examining, one rooted in Islam.
asserted
layer → examine → Islam
Muslims frequently emphasize solidarity and collective identity, placing the interests of the Muslim community above those of other religious groups.
asserted
Muslims → emphasize → groups
This sense of unity extends into the political arena, where shared religious identity can shape voting patterns and political mobilization.
asserted
identity → extend → patterns
At the religious level, the outlook is often tied to the concept of the Ummah — the global Muslim community — and the belief that Muslims constitute the best community brought forth for humanity.
asserted
Muslims → tie → humanity
From that perspective, strengthening bonds among Muslims, including those living in non-Muslim societies, is regarded as a religious virtue favored by Allah.
asserted
strengthening → strengthen → Allah
This theological dimension matters because it raises unavoidable questions about the relationship between Islamic religious obligations, communal allegiance, and the Western principle of equal treatment for all religious groups.
asserted
it → matter → groups
Can a religious framework that prioritizes the interests and solidarity of one faith community be fully reconciled with a secular democratic system founded on equal citizenship, religious neutrality, and the impartial treatment of every community?
asserted
interests → prioritize → community
It is a concrete administrative choice by elected officials holding public office.
asserted
It → elect → office
When those officials construct an official pipeline that privileges Muslim identity, they are not merely expressing personal piety.
asserted
they → construct → piety
They are reflecting a communal Muslim preference into the operations of the state.
asserted
They → reflect → state
The language of diversity and inclusion collapses under this anecdote.
asserted
language → collapse → anecdote
This language is only deployed when it fits their religious preferences and political aspirations.
asserted
it → deploy → preferences
Diversity loses any coherent meaning when it is selectively applied to privilege certain religious or ethnic constituencies while locking others out.
asserted
it → lose → others
Inclusion becomes a synonym for exclusion once the approved identities are named and the disapproved ones are barred.
asserted
ones → become → exclusion
The same Muslim officials who would denounce a Christian-only internship as theocratic now defend a Muslim-only one as equity.
asserted
who → denounce → equity
Americans should understand that Islam is not solely a private religious devotion.
asserted
Islam → understand → ?
It is a religiopolitical ideology that extends religious principles into public institutions and political governance.
asserted
that → extend → institutions
In this paradigm, political participation can be used to advance a particular religious agenda, potentially exploiting the freedoms and democratic protections of Western societies in ways that test the very principles upon which those freedoms rest.
asserted
freedoms → use → which
Western democracies were not designed to host parallel systems of communal preference, let alone preferred legal particularities.
asserted
democracies → design → preference
They were designed to treat citizens as individuals equal under the law, regardless of the faith they bring into the public square.
asserted
they → design → square
It normalizes the idea that government offices may sort applicants by religion and ancestry when the sorting favors the right groups.
uncertain
sorting → normalize → groups
Once that door is opened, it does not close easily.
asserted
it → open → ?
The result will be a permanent contest of religious and ethnic favoritism dressed up as representation.
asserted
result → dress → representation
Muslim Senator Jodeh and Iranian-American Representative Zokaie have chosen the Ummah over equal citizenship.
asserted
Jodeh → choose → citizenship
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
