People don't trust the mainstream news like they used to.
asserted
they → trust → news
In 1976, 72 percent of Americans told Gallup they had "a great deal of trust" that the mass media was "reporting the news fully, accurately and fairly."
asserted
media → tell → news
In a recent interview with Reason's Nick Gillespie, investigative journalist Matt Taibbi argued that journalists have lost touch with much of America and that this explains a lot of that drop.
asserted
this → argue → drop
The industry does indeed draw on a narrower slice of the country than before: A 2022 survey by The American Journalist found that 96 percent of journalists held bachelor's degrees, up from 58 percent in 1971.
asserted
percent → draw → 1971
Journalism "became a status job," says Taibbi.
asserted
Taibbi → become → ?
What's more, a larger share of journalists live and work in just a handful of coastal cities.
asserted
share → live → cities
Internet-based publications have largely replaced print newspapers, slashing the availability of journalism jobs in rural counties.
asserted
publications → base → counties
Educated urbanites may represent a growing portion of America, but they do not represent everyone, and that may have an effect on people's trust.
uncertain
that → represent → trust
At the same time, the internet has made it possible for independent journalists to share their stories on social media platforms.
asserted
journalists → make → platforms
Major news organizations themselves get increasing amounts of traffic from social media posts.
asserted
organizations → get → posts
Data from the Reuters Institute show that social media is now the most used news source, with 56 percent of Americans getting their stories from it any given week.
asserted
percent → show → it
Even as media consumers have been alienated from mainstream media, consumers have found it easier to seek news elsewhere.
asserted
it → alienate → news
Social media has democratized information, cutting against the oligopoly a handful of heavily regulated broadcasters held in the 1970s.
asserted
handful → democratize → 1970s
Independent journalism has exploded, and a 2025 study by Change Research found that people trust "independent or online journalists" to report "what is happening" more honestly than national news organizations.
asserted
what → explode → organizations
Yet news hosted on social media can be at risk of government strangulation, though not in the same ways that state-licensed broadcasters are.
asserted
broadcasters → host → ways
In a social media environment where five or so companies own the biggest forums, the state can try to control the discussion by pressuring the companies.
asserted
state → own → companies
"The model that everybody is going for is a government agency that makes a recommendation to private companies," says Taibbi.
asserted
Taibbi → go → companies
"The companies then do the censoring."
asserted
companies → do → censoring
This is called jawboning.
asserted
This → call → ?
It was seen during the COVID-19 pandemic, when federal health officials were in constant communication with major social media firms such as Twitter, flagging and reporting content that was deemed "misinformation."
asserted
that → see → content
Taibbi's own reporting revealed that the FBI also jawboned social media firms, mostly related to posts that supposedly undermined "election integrity."
asserted
that → reveal → integrity
But not all online platforms are equally likely to submit to censorship efforts.
asserted
platforms → submit → efforts
Taibbi specifically credits Substack for standing up to jawboning.
asserted
Taibbi → credit → jawboning
"It's gonna take a company that's willing to put up with [government] petitions" to stop this new wave of censorship, he says.
asserted
he → go → censorship
Another possibility, not raised in the interview, is open platforms where you don't have to worry in the first place about how the corporate leadership might bend to censorship.
uncertain
leadership → raise → censorship
Substack also gives space for long-form writers to enter the media market.
asserted
writers → give → market
That does not automatically mean more trust in the news, and it does not automatically mean more factual reporting.
asserted
it → mean → reporting
But a lower barrier to entry allows a broader, less elite-focused news marketplace.
asserted
barrier → allow → marketplace
It also allows more firsthand and personal content.
asserted
It → allow → content
The 2026 midterms saw livestreaming pick up steam, with socialist commentator Hasan Piker's Twitch stream peaking at 241,783 concurrent viewers.
asserted
stream → see → viewers
The January 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol was watched by thousands of Americans firsthand as participants livestreamed it.
asserted
participants → watch → it
Millions of young people watched on social media as the Israeli military bombarded Gaza, even developing parasocial relationships with local reporters.
asserted
military → watch → reporters
That may help explain why younger people—who use social media more—are more hostile toward Israel than previous generations.
uncertain
who → help → generations
It certainly gives them more room to express their opinions on the subject.
asserted
It → give → subject
Substack has grown a staggering amount over the past few years, with over 47 million monthly unique users recorded in September 2025.
asserted
Substack → grow → September
It is hard to compare that number to traditional media readership, but given the trend, especially among youth, independent internet-based reporting sure seems to be the future of news media.
asserted
reporting → compare → media
People are naturally suspicious of new technologies and changing circumstances.
asserted
People → change → technologies
In his conversation with Taibbi, Gillespie pokes fun at this culturally conservative mindset, joking, "Jump cuts on MTV destroyed the kids' ability to read Moby Dick."
asserted
cuts → poke → Dick
They just want different options—and the internet is making those options available.
asserted
options → want → options