Claims extracted
18
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
28%
5 of 18 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
64/100
Evening Standard's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
2
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Melissa Phillips, 49, suffered spiral fractures to her left fibula and tibia during a fall as she descended a set of stairs in March 2023.
asserted
she → suffer → March
Her legal team claims, according to court documents filed at the civil court, the tumble was because of the airline’s "negligence".
uncertain
tumble → claim → negligence
Her barrister said in court documents that there was “minimal crowd control or direction” from cabin crew as passengers ventured down “damp” steps to leave the aircraft.
asserted
passengers → say → aircraft
They claim it was these conditions which led to Ms Phillips being “jostled and knocked” before then falling.
uncertain
Phillips → claim → ?
BA is defending the claim, with its barrister stating that Ms Phillips was negligent as she “descended the steps without looking, or adequately looking”, and that the most likely cause of the fall was Ms Phillips “simply losing her footing”.
uncertain
Phillips → defend → footing
Katherine Deal KC, for Ms Phillips, said in court documents that disembarking passengers from the flight from Israel to Heathrow was “chaotic”.
asserted
disembarking → say → Heathrow
She said: “Had the steps not been full of jostling passengers, the claimant would not have been knocked off balance.”
asserted
claimant → say → balance
Read More
Ms Deal also said that the airline failed to “avoid or materially reduce the risk of passengers jostling each other on overcrowded steps”, and “otherwise failed in all the circumstances to provide reasonably safe air transport services”.
asserted
airline → read → services
The barrister said that Ms Phillips underwent surgery after being taken to hospital, before being flown back to the US days later.
asserted
Phillips → say → US
She said: “The claimant underwent therapy and treatment but continues to experience pain, some limitation of movement and loss of amenity affecting aspects of her daily life over and above her pre-accident symptoms.
“
asserted
claimant → say → symptoms
Her ability to run her home was impaired.
asserted
ability → run → home
“The claimant has some psychological distress as a result of her ongoing pain and immobility.
asserted
claimant → have → pain
Her symptoms are expected to be permanent.”
asserted
symptoms → expect → ?
Christopher Loxton, representing BA’s defence to the claim, said passengers were not going down the steps in an “unusual or unexpected manner”, and denied that the steps were damp.
He said it was “not normal operating procedure” for crowd-control measures to be in place, or for cabin crew to give directions.
uncertain
crew → represent → directions
Staff did not see “any disorderly or unusual passenger disembarkation”, Mr Loxton added.
asserted
Loxton → see → disembarkation
He said: “It is the defendant’s case that the likely cause of the claimant’s fall was simply paying insufficient attention to the way in which she was descending the steps and that she lost her footing and fell down the same steps.”
asserted
she → say → steps
Mr Loxton said BA claimed that Ms Phillips “caused herself to come into contact” with other passengers or their luggage, and failed to hold on to the handrails, meaning she “failed, in all the circumstances, to exercise reasonable skill and care”.
asserted
she → say → skill
A hearing in the claim is yet to take place.
uncertain
hearing → take → place