The News
Progressive Democrats are trying a tricky feat as their party takes power: endorsing Medicare for All while quietly pushing for smaller steps toward it.
asserted
party → try → it
Their dilemma began with the party’s remarkable midterm success.
asserted
dilemma → begin → success
Democrats are united in attributing their electoral triumph in part to voter backlash against GOP healthcare moves — and this year, even purple-district candidates won while backing Medicare for All.
asserted
candidates → unite → All
But now, the left is split on how to make it happen.
asserted
it → make → ?
Without a filibuster or veto-proof majority in Congress next year, Democrats are calibrating their expectations for change based on what can potentially pass through the maneuver known as reconciliation, which requires only a simple majority.
asserted
which → calibrate → majority
Some progressives are calling for a unified drive to lower the Medicare eligibility age, add guaranteed coverage up to age 19, and add dental and vision coverage.
asserted
progressives → call → coverage
That could offer a middle ground for party leaders who are looking to stave off fights over bills likely to be vetoed by President Donald Trump.
uncertain
who → offer → Trump
Embracing a big step toward pure Medicare for All could also hand a victory to progressives who have long pushed for legislative action — if they can settle for something less than the litmus test they set up.
uncertain
they → embrace → test
“It’s the perfect way for us to get ready for the next trifecta if we pass those three bills, and then if we mark up the entire Medicare for All bill,” said Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., the lead sponsor of the House’s Medicare for All bill.
asserted
Jayapal → ’ → bill
Others on the left may not be content with pushing off action on the marquee policy until later.
uncertain
Others → push → policy
An incoming cohort of progressives want to push their party to vote on the full government-run healthcare package now.
asserted
cohort → want → package
Rep.-elect Melat Kiros, D-Colo., said the program was “one of our number one priorities.”
asserted
program → say → priorities
“I’ll never let perfect be the enemy of the good,” she added.
asserted
she → let → good
“But if we’re not fighting like hell to actually get healthcare to every single American, then I don’t know what we’re doing here.”
asserted
we → fight → what
Centrists wanted the party to work towards consensus — a tall order for Democrats.
asserted
party → want → Democrats
Quite a few in the caucus want the party to focus on the underlying drivers of healthcare costs before considering a system where taxpayers pay for all healthcare.
asserted
taxpayers → want → healthcare
“I think we should talk more about cost and less about coverage,” said Rep. Jake Auchincloss, D-Mass.
Democratic leaders have said they would need to have a “family conversation” on their path forward; a working group led by Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., and Terri Sewell, D-Ala., laid out a menu of options that included Medicare for All alongside many other proposals.
asserted
that → think → proposals
“Are we messaging or are we getting something done?” said Rep. Adam Gray, D-Calif., a member of the moderate Blue Dogs.
asserted
Gray → message → Dogs
“We know that we have broad agreement that we want healthcare to be affordable, that we want it to be accessible … and that every American should have it, and so what are the solutions we can get agreement on to do that?”
asserted
we → know → that
The Plan
Democrats across the ideological spectrum have coalesced around their healthcare agenda in the near term.
asserted
Democrats → coalesce → term
After relentlessly campaigning on reversing GOP-enacted Medicaid cuts and restoring lapsed health care subsidies, Democrats plan to put those up for a vote.
asserted
Democrats → campaign → vote
They may even use the issues as leverage in the looming December government funding fight.
uncertain
They → use → fight
“I think everything should be on the table,” said Rep. Glenn Ivey, D-Md.
asserted
Ivey → think → table
“It’s important for us to make sure we listen to and respond to the message of the voters, and I think they want to really get relief.”
asserted
they → ’ → relief
Rep. Kim Schrier, D-Wash., said that she wants both of those priorities to advance, but cautioned that “we still have the same president in the White House.”
The View From The Senate
Across the Capitol, Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., is pushing to use reconciliation to immediately advance his bill to lower the Medicare eligibility age to 55, add dental, vision and hearing coverage to the federal health insurance program for seniors, and ensure universal coverage for children through age 19.
asserted
Sanders → say → age
Sanders already has one powerful ally: Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., the expected chair of the Senate Finance Committee, said he wants “to push for the boldest, best bill possible.”
asserted
he → have → bill
“I’m not taking anything off the table,” Wyden said, when asked about whether he supported using reconciliation to advance the legislation.
asserted
he → take → legislation
Other senators are already calling for a more moderate approach.
asserted
senators → call → approach
On Tuesday, Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wis., introduced a bill that would lower the Medicare eligibility age to 50 and allow adults to buy into traditional Medicare or Medicare Advantage plans.
asserted
adults → introduce → plans
The legislation would allow adults eligible for Affordable Care Act cost-sharing subsidies and premium tax credits to continue to use such assistance to help make Medicare plans more affordable.
asserted
plans → allow → assistance
But it would not give adults taxpayer-funded Medicare before they turn 65.
asserted
they → give → 65
Nicholas and David’s View
Democrats are going to eventually grapple with what exactly “Medicare for All” means to the disparate factions in their caucus.
asserted
Medicare → go → caucus
While Republicans will be quick to paint any effort as a first step toward implementing a single-payer healthcare system that replaces private insurance, the truth is more complicated.
asserted
truth → paint → insurance
The reality is that very few Democrats on the campaign trail explicitly called for the enactment of a single government-run insurance plan.
asserted
Democrats → call → plan
But with dozens of Democrats expected to launch presidential campaigns over the coming year, supporting universal healthcare coverage may quickly become, yet again, an up-or-down question for primary voters.
uncertain
supporting → expect → voters
The Aporia
