Ahead of the midterms, conservative election activists discussed plans to wield a powerful new weapon in the war against fraud: a data tool built by one of their own that could identify suspicious voters and help with contesting their ballots.
uncertain
that → discuss → ballots
The system was put to the test this week in Forsyth County, Georgia, where a member of the county’s election board provided other officials with what he suggested was evidence of wrongdoing: four allegedly dead voters.
uncertain
he → put → wrongdoing
But it turns out all four are alive and well, ProPublica determined.
asserted
ProPublica → turn → ?
The board rejected the attempt to challenge their ballots.
asserted
board → reject → ballots
The effort, though, shows that even after last week’s blue wave, those who believe the 2020 election was stolen have continued to relentlessly search for ways to contest Republican losses.
asserted
election → show → losses
In Georgia, Democrats swept statewide offices.
asserted
Democrats → sweep → offices
The board member who initiated the Forsyth County challenge, Max Clavijo, is a member of the Election Integrity Network, a group led by conservative lawyer Cleta Mitchell that works to restrict voting and tighten election laws and rules.
asserted
that → initiate → laws
Mitchell worked closely with Donald Trump in his attempt to overturn his defeat in the 2020 election and, since he retook the presidency, has been central to his push to assert greater federal control over voting.
asserted
he → work → voting
In the run-up to the midterms, on right-wing media and on private organizing calls, EIN participants outlined plans to search voter rolls with a software tool known as ELLY’s Election Monitor and contest ballots the tool deemed suspicious.
asserted
tool → outline → ballots
ELLY was developed by EIN member Rick Richards.
asserted
ELLY → develop → Richards
It aggregates public data from state voter files, federal change-of-address records, tax documents, obituaries, property websites like Zillow and other sources.
asserted
It → aggregate → Zillow
In Georgia, State Election Board members and top staffers have urged counties to use the tool to search their voter rolls for signs of fraud.
asserted
members → urge → fraud
Richards talked about ELLY’s national potential on a podcast in late September, on which right-wing media personalities and activists touted its capacity to help GOP candidates contest their defeats.
asserted
candidates → talk → defeats
“We can prove the fraud that’s gone on in every state,” one commentator said.
asserted
commentator → prove → state
“This data will be able to set up challenges to those who lose.”
asserted
who → set → those
The following month, on a private call with EIN members and other conservative activists, Richards promised to provide data from more than 3,000 counties to “citizen monitors” and GOP candidates to try to prove fraud, according to a recording reviewed by ProPublica.
uncertain
Richards → promise → ProPublica
In an interview, Richards told ProPublica that he gave Clavijo data on Forsyth County at Clavijo’s request.
asserted
he → tell → request
He said in a subsequent email that their actions were meant to inform the board and remain confidential.
asserted
actions → say → board
Clavijo didn’t respond to questions from ProPublica.
asserted
Clavijo → respond → ProPublica
Richards refused to answer questions about whether Clavijo’s effort was part of a wider EIN campaign to contest votes cast in the midterms.
asserted
effort → refuse → midterms
“That’s irrelevant,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → ?
People can use it for what they want to.”
asserted
they → use → it
Mitchell, EIN’s leader, didn’t respond to questions about the group’s plans related to ELLY, either in Georgia or nationally.
asserted
Mitchell → respond → Georgia
In the months since some on Georgia’s State Election Board started promoting ELLY’s use, its accuracy has been much debated.
asserted
accuracy → start → use
The tool doesn’t have access to personal identifiers such as voters’ Social Security or driver’s license numbers or full dates of birth, which increases the potential for mismatches involving people with the same names.
asserted
which → have → names
Voting rights groups have called ELLY error-prone.
asserted
groups → call → ?
The Cherokee County election director complained to the state board after the tool falsely flagged a county board member’s spouse as dead.
asserted
tool → complain → spouse
State Election Board members and Richards have defended ELLY.
asserted
members → defend → ELLY
Accusations that the data is unreliable were “horse hockey,” Richards told ProPublica, explaining this was “a Southern colloquialism for B.S.”
asserted
this → tell → B.S.
Late last week, according to several people familiar with the matter, Clavijo circulated documents to board members and Forsyth County’s election director.
uncertain
Clavijo → accord → members
Based on data from ELLY, Clavijo questioned whether the names of more than 22,000 people on the county’s voter roll were correct and disputed the eligibility of 69 voters.
asserted
names → base → voters
In addition to four he claimed were deceased, he alleged others had moved out of the county or state, had voter ID irregularities or had registered under fictitious names, giving an initial as their first name.
asserted
others → claim → name
During the meeting, Clavijo claimed that he was not trying to disrupt the election’s certification or formally challenge the voters, a process outlined in statutes that can lead to ballots being tossed or voters removed from the rolls.
asserted
voters → claim → rolls
(Richards also said they had not formally challenged ballots.)
asserted
they → say → ballots
Clavijo said he was merely seeking “to clean the voter rolls” and inform the board so officials could investigate further.
uncertain
officials → say → board
But other board members accused him of doing an end run around the formal challenge process.
asserted
members → accuse → process
Barbara Luth, the board chair, said she felt “sorry for” Clavijo because activists were bypassing the challenge procedure “by coming to you and having you submit it.”
asserted
you → say → it
Under fire from fellow board members, Clavijo admitted he could not vouch for the data’s accuracy.
uncertain
he → admit → accuracy
“I did not make any explicit accusation that the information was 100% correct,” he said.
asserted
he → make → accusation
The cover letter Clavijo submitted with the challenges said that they had not been verified with any “human review,” according to sources familiar with the matter.
uncertain
they → submit → matter
…and 21 more, not listed.
The Aporia
