- Published
There are stories that can damage reputations, tarnish legacies and put asterisks next to achievements.
asserted
that → publish → achievements
Are Pep Guardiola's trophies at Manchester City rendered worthless by financial rule breaches?
asserted
trophies → render → breaches
Would either of the Houston Astros or Boston Red Sox have won the World Series without sign stealing?
asserted
either → win → stealing
How much fake blood was spilled by Harlequins?
asserted
blood → spill → Harlequins
Now, sandpapergate has morphed into Usman Khawaja's-book-gate, opening old wounds and asking questions that have hung over Australian cricket since Cameron Bancroft hid some DIY equipment in his jockstrap in 2018.
asserted
Bancroft → morph → 2018
Published on Tuesday, Khawaja's autobiography – Sabr – is only suggesting what plenty have suspected for the past eight years.
asserted
plenty → publish → years
It always seemed likely that Bancroft, Steve Smith and David Warner were not the only three members of the Australia camp with knowledge of the sandpaper plot.
asserted
Bancroft → seem → plot
Careful with his words, perhaps for legal reasons, Khawaja has said enough to reignite a row that once consumed the entire nation of Australia.
asserted
that → say → Australia
Crucially, the former batter has not named individuals and, in the opinion of Cricket Australia (CA), not presented enough evidence to merit a new investigation.
asserted
batter → name → investigation
It was Nathan Lyon who once said Australia know how to "headbutt the line, but we won't go over it".
asserted
we → say → it
Khawaja has headbutted the line of whistle-blowing, without taking a full toot.
asserted
Khawaja → headbutt → toot
Writing in Sabr, Khawaja says: "I'm going to use the term 'we' throughout this chapter, because 'we' are team Australia – although in this book I'm not speaking on behalf of anyone but myself.
asserted
I → write → myself
In a video posted on Instagram, he added: "You would have seen when I mentioned it was all of us, that's implying that whether we like it or not, we are all responsible for what happened together.
asserted
what → post → it
As a team, we need to take that collectively.
asserted
we → need → that
Then, to ABC on Tuesday: "I'm not here to go on a witch hunt.
asserted
I → go → hunt
All I've ever wanted is for us to take accountability as a team."
asserted
us → want → team
Rather than directly accusing his team-mates, Khawaja is asking the Australians present in Cape Town to share the blame that was given to Smith, Warner and Bancroft.
asserted
that → accuse → Smith
An individual can be culpable for what happened, even if they were not the one to directly rub sandpaper on the red leather.
asserted
they → happen → leather
Khawaja has also explained that much of his motivation for telling this story comes from loyalty to his childhood friend Warner.
asserted
much → explain → friend
Warner has had his say and, like Khawaja, has not named anyone else he feels should be implicated.
asserted
he → have → anyone
There are questions as to why neither man has spoken up over the past eight years.
asserted
man → be → years
If they felt strongly, they could have come forward at any time, even if Khawaja is proved correct in his claim he was not interviewed in the original investigation.
uncertain
he → feel → investigation
Warner may yet reveal more in the future, ditto for Smith and Bancroft.
uncertain
Warner → reveal → Smith
This latest evidence has done little to shift views that were entrenched before Khawaja put pen to paper.
asserted
Khawaja → do → paper
Darren Lehmann, Australia coach at the time, has stuck to his story of denial, as has Mitchell Starc.
asserted
Starc → stick → denial
Chadd Sayers, another seamer in the 2018 squad, has come out in support of Khawaja and Warner.
asserted
Sayers → come → Khawaja
It leaves the ball in the court of the other Australian players involved, the coaching staff and CA.
asserted
It → leave → players
On Tuesday, CA chief executive Todd Greenberg said, with a straight face, he did not see "any compelling reason" to reopen the investigation into the ball-tampering saga.
asserted
he → say → saga
What evidence could compel Greenberg to act?
uncertain
evidence → compel → Greenberg
Even if Khawaja has not directly pointed the finger at anyone else in the dressing room that day, surely CA should be curious about the claims that are currently causing so much reputational damage, especially when Khawaja and Warner have called into question the rigour of the original investigation.
uncertain
Khawaja → point → investigation
The Cape Town files have never been made public.
asserted
files → make → ?
In 2021, David Saker, an Australia assistant coach in 2018, called for them to be released.
asserted
them → call → 2018
Now, Saker is not named but is among the staff Khawaja has implicated in the book by claiming a member of the backroom team encouraged Bancroft.
asserted
member → name → Bancroft
That allegation alone surely merits further scrutiny by CA.
asserted
allegation → merit → CA
Of the players in the Australia XI on that Saturday at Newlands, three were punished; now Khawaja has accepted his share of responsibility, making four.
asserted
Khawaja → punish → four
Tim Paine inherited the captaincy, a reign that ended in his own scandal.
asserted
that → inherit → scandal
Mitchell Marsh remains an active player and is about to skipper Australia in the limited-overs series against England.
asserted
Marsh → remain → England
Marsh will speak on Thursday.
asserted
Marsh → speak → Thursday
That makes seven.
asserted
That → make → seven
They remain as a quartet, hunting prizes that have previously eluded them over the coming year – an away Test series win in India, winning the Ashes in England.
asserted
that → remain → England
…and 13 more, not listed.
The Aporia
