An attorney for Democratic Sen. Elissa Slotkin is warning Attorney General Todd Blanche not to bow to President Donald Trump’s demand for a criminal investigation into her political speech.
asserted
attorney → warn → speech
Over the weekend, Trump posted on his social media platform that he was demanding the Justice Department look into the Michigan senator’s recent comments about how Democratic investigations into the Trump administration could send a “deterrence message” to young people thinking about joining the administration in its final two years.
uncertain
investigations → post → years
“By copy of this statement, I am ordering the Department of Justice to look into this criminal act, immediately!” Trump wrote.
asserted
Trump → order → act
In a letter to Blanche made public Monday, Preet Bharara, the former U.S. attorney in the Southern District of New York, wrote that it “should not be hard to make clear that we do not live in an authoritarian regime where mere criticism of the powerful can land anyone in legal peril and possibly prison.”
“That requires a clear and public statement confirming that the Department will not pursue this investigation against Senator Slotkin,” he wrote.
uncertain
he → make → Slotkin
The Justice Department didn’t comment on Trump’s post.
asserted
Department → comment → post
The attorney general is appointed by the president and is a member of his Cabinet, but it’s still highly unusual for the White House to publicly demand an investigation.
asserted
House → appoint → investigation
The Justice Department has long sought to separate politics from the law.
asserted
Department → seek → law
But under Blanche, Trump’s former personal attorney, the department has investigated many of the president’s perceived political enemies.
asserted
department → investigate → enemies
Slotkin, a former CIA and Defense Department official, was also one of a group of lawmakers the Trump administration tried and failed to indict earlier this year over a social media video.
asserted
administration → try → video
A few weeks before the midterm elections, where the GOP saw massive losses, she spoke at the University of Chicago, arguing that Democrats should focus investigative efforts on those who enable Trump.
asserted
who → see → Trump
She said she hoped to deter young people coming out of school from joining the administration.
asserted
she → say → administration
“I want them to be like, ‘Lord, that might be buying myself a ton of problems that I don’t want, and so let me avoid participating in that,’” Slotkin said.
uncertain
Slotkin → want → that
“I want that deterrence message sent.”
asserted
message → want → ?
In his post on Truth Social over the weekend, Trump accused Slotkin of “going to go after all young people that believe in Republican Values, and that give even the slightest inclination to be a Republican.”
asserted
that → accuse → inclination
Trump’s demand came weeks after Trump ally Mike Davis requested that Harmeet Dhillon — who has since resigned as head of the Civil Rights Division — launch an investigation of Slotkin.
asserted
who → come → Slotkin
Bharara wrote that Slotkin’s comments were “entirely lawful” and protected by the First Amendment as well as the “speech and debate” clause of the Constitution, which protects members of Congress.
asserted
which → write → Congress
“There is no conceivable basis to investigate the Senator for reminding members of the executive branch who aid the President’s law breaking that there will be accountability for their actions, or expressing the hope that Americans decline to serve in an administration where leaders may ask them to violate the law or misuse taxpayer dollars,” Bharara wrote.
uncertain
Bharara → be → dollars
“Indeed, the Senator’s statement reinforces the rule of law.”
asserted
statement → reinforce → law
Bharara asked Blanche to publicly decline to follow Trump’s command.
asserted
Bharara → ask → command
“The Department should stop threatening our constitutional freedoms and make clear that you will not again launch another frivolous investigation at the taxpayers’ expense,” he wrote.
asserted
he → stop → expense
The Justice Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
asserted
Department → respond → comment
Bharara’s letter noted that it had been less than a year since the administration failed to indict Slotkin and five other members of Congress over a social media video that reminded members of the military and intelligence communities of their duties not to follow unlawful orders.
asserted
that → note → orders
“Thankfully, the anonymous citizens of a Washington D.C. grand jury unanimously rejected the Department’s attempt to punish a perceived political adversary for her lawful — indeed, constitutionally privileged — speech,” Bharara wrote.
asserted
Bharara → reject → speech
The Aporia
