The sea was calm and the sky half-strewn with clouds on a winter’s morning at Palm Beach Reef, off the Gold Coast, when Andrew Mulville arrived by boat to check on two whales milling in the shallow water.
asserted
Mulville → arrive → water
Members of the public had become worried that one of the humpbacks was injured or entangled, and reported their concerns to Sea World.
asserted
one → become → World
Mulville, a whale rescue boat captain with the organisation, happened to be fishing nearby.
asserted
Mulville → happen → organisation
The whales weren’t hurt, he found, but were behaving strangely.
asserted
he → hurt → ?
An amniotic sack – part of a placenta – floated to the surface.
asserted
sack → float → surface
Mulville dipped his GoPro underwater, and captured what researchers believe is the first detailed documentation of possible grief in a humpback whale over a stillborn calf.
asserted
researchers → dip → calf
Watched by a companion, the young female repeatedly dove to the bottom, lying next to the calf’s body on the sea floor.
asserted
female → watch → floor
She nudged it gently with her head and touched it with her fin.
asserted
She → nudge → fin
“There were what appears to be attempts at eye contact, just observing it to see whether, maybe, there was any sign of life,” said Griffith University whale scientist Dr Olaf Meynecke.
asserted
Meynecke → be → life
“She was going and literally lying on the bottom … she was definitely spending time with the deceased calf.”
asserted
she → go → calf
A new paper by Meynecke and Mulville about the incident, which occurred in July last year, argues the whale probably understood her calf had died, as there was no attempt to lift it to the surface to breathe.
asserted
calf → occur → surface
Based on sightings from the public, Meynecke believes the whales may have remained near the calf for almost three days.
uncertain
whales → base → days
“We think it was a younger female; she wasn’t that big,” he said.
asserted
he → think → ?
The observation adds unique insight into rare “post-mortem attentive responses” in socially complex mammals – also called grief behaviours – which involve mothers carrying, nudging, circling and guarding their dead offspring.
asserted
mothers → add → offspring
The behaviours have been documented mostly in toothed whales, notably the orca known as Tahlequah, who carried the body of a calf for 17 days in 2018 and was observed doing the same with another dead calf last year.
asserted
who → document → calf
Whether these intelligent and social creatures truly mourn, or experience something we would understand as grief, is up for debate.
asserted
we → mourn → debate
“Of course, from a science perspective, we can’t prove it’s grief,” Meynecke said.
asserted
Meynecke → prove → perspective
“It’d be so much easier if you could just ask them.”
uncertain
you → ask → them
The paper notes the behaviours could be explained by confusion, or misfired caregiving instinct.
uncertain
behaviours → note → confusion
But after years of observing humpbacks respond to other whales entangled in nets, and even protect other species from predators, Meynecke believes they must experience an “emotional state that is not necessarily comparable to ours … but there is something there that is quite strong”.
asserted
that → observe → ours
“I don’t even want to think about how horrible or traumatic it might have been for the whales that survived whaling because clearly, they would have had emotional responses,” he said.
uncertain
he → want → responses
Brain studies have discovered “spindle neurons”, which underpin social awareness and empathy, in humpbacks alongside other species that guard and touch their dead, including elephants and chimps.
asserted
that → discover → elephants
If they have evolved similar responses that we have, it might explain some of our quite deeply embedded emotional connections.”
uncertain
it → evolve → connections
Associate Professor Rebecca Dunlop, an expert in whale behaviour from the University of Queensland who wasn’t involved in the study, said “descriptive case studies reporting the potential for animal emotions run the risk of anthropomorphising” animal behaviour.
“However, the study does present a balanced argument of how the observed behaviour could be interpreted and notes that the terms ‘grief’, ‘emotion’, ‘distress’ must be used with caution since we cannot definitively assign these terms to the observed behaviour
uncertain
we → involve → behaviour
,” she said.
asserted
she → say → ?
“The issue is around comparing human definitions of ‘emotion’ to non-humans, since emotion is a human conscious experience, where a human subject self-reports their experienced feelings.
asserted
subject → compare → feelings
”
While this study meditated on the possible deep emotional lives of whales, another paper released on Wednesday showed their close cousins can be thugs.
asserted
cousins → meditate → Wednesday
Scientists from the University of the Sunshine Coast have documented a bottlenose dolphin called Bubbles repeatedly harassing and chasing fish until they regurgitated their food, so Bubbles could eat it.
uncertain
Bubbles → document → it
It’s the first detailed description of “kleptoparasitism” in a whale or dolphin – and provides another warning about viewing wild animals through a simplistic human lens.
asserted
It → ’ → lens
“This perception of dolphins as the ‘good guys of the sea’ has more to do with anthropomorphism – our tendency to assign human characteristics to them – and perhaps that’s because dolphins appear to be smiling,” research co-author Dr Asia Haines said.
asserted
Haines → have → them
“Dolphins are predators and actively hunt their prey, whether it has been stolen from another species or not.”
asserted
it → hunt → species
The Examine newsletter explains and analyses science with a rigorous focus on the evidence.
asserted
newsletter → explain → evidence
The Aporia
