ABC sues U.S. broadcast regulator over early licence reviews, calling it an 'existential threat'
Latest skirmish in long confrontation between network and regulator
Further escalating its battle with the Trump administration, ABC on Tuesday took the rare step of suing the Federal Communications Commission on First Amendment grounds, saying the agency's demand for early review of broadcast licences posed an "existential threat" to its operations.
asserted
demand → sue → operations
In the lawsuit, ABC, its parent company Disney and the eight local stations whose licences are affected asked a federal court to stop the early renewal proceedings.
asserted
licences → affect → proceedings
The FCC under chairman Brendan Carr, an ally of U.S. President Donald Trump, had ordered the early review in April — itself a rare move — of eight licences owned by ABC, well before they are set to expire.
asserted
they → order → ABC
It cited the network's diversity practices as a reason, but the development came shortly after a joke by ABC's late-night host Jimmy Kimmel — an outspoken Trump critic — had infuriated the president.
asserted
joke → cite → president
"Again and again, the administration has attacked ABC's speech — the stories its journalists report and the viewpoints its network programs air," the network alleged in its lawsuit.
asserted
network → attack → lawsuit
"Over time, those attacks have escalated into express demands that ABC be stripped of its broadcast licences because of its speech."
asserted
ABC → escalate → speech
"Facing this existential threat," it added, "plaintiffs have no choice but to seek redress from the judicial branch for the administration's blatant retaliation for their First Amendment speech."
It said ABC had "no alternative means to eliminate these ongoing and immediate threats other than total capitulation to the administration's demands."
It asked the court to "immediately enjoin defendants from taking or threatening to take any action against plaintiffs in relation to the early licence renewal applications."
asserted
It → face → applications
The early licence review is only one part of a long-simmering confrontation between ABC and the FCC.
asserted
review → simmer → ABC
The network has also been fighting Carr's efforts to make the morning talk show The View, whose hosts and guests are often critical of Trump, subject to equal-time rules.
asserted
hosts → fight → rules
That's a question ABC says the agency itself decided — in the network's favour — more than two decades ago.
asserted
agency → say → favour
The lawsuit Tuesday also spoke of ramifications that go well beyond one network.
"
asserted
that → speak → network
The consequences of the administration's campaign against free speech reach well beyond ABC," it said.
asserted
it → reach → ABC
"If the administration gets its way, the message to every media company in the country will be unmistakable: tell only the stories the administration deems favourable, or face the coercive machinery of the federal government.
asserted
administration → get → government
In such a world, the press could in no way be described as free."
uncertain
press → describe → way
It added: "The FCC chairman has left little doubt that this is his goal."
asserted
this → add → doubt
FCC Democrat lauds lawsuit
The sole Democrat on the commission, Anna Gomez, commended ABC and Disney for pushing back against the FCC's actions.
asserted
Democrat → laud → actions
"For months, the FCC has waged a campaign of censorship and control against Disney's ABC stations," she said in a statement, "using the threat of broadcast licence revocations to punish a company for speech this administration doesn't like.
asserted
administration → wag → speech
"
"I have long called on companies to push back against this kind of government intimidation, and I'm glad Disney has shown courage and stepped up," she said.
asserted
she → call → courage
"This should be a welcome sign for every broadcaster who has felt the weight of this overreaching government pressure in silence.
asserted
who → feel → silence
In late July, Carr defended his agency's actions against ABC, saying broadcasters have a duty to "operate in the public interest."
asserted
broadcasters → defend → interest
The FCC, he said, was merely trying to restore that standard.
asserted
he → say → standard
Broadcasters like ABC, Carr said in an interview on the Fox Business Network, "struck a deal with the American people.
asserted
Carr → say → people
You broadcasters get subsidized access, free access to a valuable public resource, the airwaves, worth billions of dollars.
asserted
broadcasters → get → dollars
In exchange, you have to operate in the public interest.
asserted
you → have → interest
"
"Look, as a country, we should have a trusted, respected news media, and we're not there," Carr said.
asserted
Carr → look → media
"So I hope more broadcasters return to their public interest obligations."
asserted
broadcasters → hope → obligations
On Tuesday, an FCC spokesperson reiterated that position.
asserted
spokesperson → reiterate → position
"All broadcasters have a legal obligation to operate in the public interest — even Disney," said a statement from the commission, responding to the lawsuit.
asserted
statement → have → lawsuit
"The FCC has been examining claims that Disney engaged in illegal DEI [diversity, equity, and inclusion] discrimination for over a year.
uncertain
Disney → examine → year
Disney is obviously very concerned about the FCC's proceeding, as evidenced by their ongoing campaign of disinformation as well as their decision to ask a court to stop the FCC from further pursuing matters.
asserted
Disney → evidence → matters
The FCC will continue to follow the facts and law wherever they lead."
asserted
they → continue → facts
The Aporia
