The Supreme Court has made clear that racial discrimination has no place in public school admissions.
asserted
has → make → admissions
But when schools hide discrimination behind race-neutral policies, lower courts have let them get away with it — as long as the targeted racial group isn’t hurt too much.
asserted
group → hide → it
On Oct. 19, the court agreed to hear a case brought by parents in Montgomery County, Md., challenging an admissions policy designed to reduce Asian-American enrollment at the county’s magnet middle schools.
asserted
court → agree → schools
At stake is a fundamental question: Does the Constitution protect students as individuals, or do their rights depend on how others of their race perform?
asserted
others → protect → race
With this case, the Supreme Court could reverse a Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals precedent that Justice Alito once called "flagrantly wrong" and "a virus that may spread if not promptly eliminated."
uncertain
that → reverse → that
It’s fundamental.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Does the Constitution protect us as individuals?
asserted
Constitution → protect → individuals
Or do our rights depend on the outcomes of racial groups?
asserted
rights → depend → groups
Montgomery County is a suburb of Washington, D.C., straddling the Capital Beltway and home to at least 10 federal agencies.
asserted
County → straddle → agencies
Its school system is one of the largest in the country and includes four magnet middle schools for gifted students.
asserted
system → include → students
In 2015, Montgomery County’s school system hired consultants to examine the racial makeup of its gifted programs, including its magnet schools.
asserted
system → hire → schools
At the time, Asian-American students made up nearly half the enrollment at these four schools, which admitted students based on grades, a cognitive abilities test and teacher recommendations.
asserted
which → make → grades
The consultants reported "significant racial and socioeconomic disparities" at the schools.
asserted
consultants → report → schools
Black and Hispanic students were underrepresented compared to their countywide enrollment numbers.
asserted
students → underrepresente → numbers
Montgomery County should "revise the criteria and process used to select students," the consultants urged.
asserted
consultants → revise → students
By introducing "non-cognitive criteria" and "group-specific norms" into the selection process.
The Board of Education listened.
asserted
Board → introduce → Education
One board member described his vision for the magnet program "not simply as a matter of creating opportunity and having that be blind and neutral but in fact ensuring there were controls so that in fact those choices could reflect the community that we live in."
uncertain
we → describe → that
Privilege, he warned, "is not going to go away.
asserted
he → warn → ?
Now there is a lottery for Montgomery County magnet schools — but it’s not an open lottery.
asserted
it → be → schools
It has controls meant to produce a specific outcome.
asserted
It → have → outcome
To be eligible, students must score in the 85th percentile on a Measures of Academic Progress (MAP) test, with percentiles "locally normed" so students are measured against a cluster of peers.
asserted
students → score → peers
The result: Students in certain school clusters — those with high Asian American enrollment — need to score in the 93rd district-wide percentile to be eligible for the magnet lottery.
asserted
Students → need → lottery
At other schools, a child only needs to score in the 60th district-wide percentile.
asserted
child → need → percentile
This new process certainly looks like a calculated act of discrimination to balance magnet schools racially.
asserted
process → look → schools
And it’s effective: Asian-American enrollment has sharply dropped since 2016.
asserted
enrollment → ’ → 2016
At one participating school, Asian-American participation dropped from 58.2% to 30.3%.
asserted
participation → participate → %
My firm, Pacific Legal Foundation, promptly sued on behalf of the parents.
asserted
firm → sue → parents
But according to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, Asian-American participation still hasn’t dropped enough to warrant judicial review.
uncertain
participation → accord → review
With this case, the Supreme Court could reverse a Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals precedent that Justice Alito once called "flagrantly wrong" and "a virus that may spread if not promptly eliminated."
uncertain
that → reverse → that
The court refused to allow the parents’ case to go to trial, dismissing their argument because the share of Asian-American enrollment hadn’t yet dropped below the share of applications.
asserted
share → refuse → applications
In other words, Montgomery County’s new admissions policy may disadvantage Asian-American students because of their race.
uncertain
policy → disadvantage → race
But because Asian-American applicants are still achieving at a high level as a group, the government’s discrimination doesn’t count.
asserted
discrimination → achieve → group
This isn’t how the law works.
asserted
law → work → ?
The Constitution protects human beings, not statistical groups.
asserted
Constitution → protect → beings
No child’s rights should be contingent on how well other children of the same race perform.
asserted
children → perform → race
In 2024, Pacific Legal Foundation tried to bring a similar case to the Supreme Court, this one about admissions at Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology in Virginia.
asserted
Foundation → try → Virginia
The Fourth Circuit rejected parents’ right to argue discrimination.
asserted
Circuit → reject → discrimination
The Supreme Court declined to take the case.
asserted
Court → decline → case
But Justice Alito warned, in a dissent from denial joined by Justice Clarence Thomas, that the court would soon need to address the Fourth Circuit’s "dangerous" reasoning.
asserted
court → warn → reasoning
"What the Fourth Circuit majority held, in essence, is that intentional racial discrimination is constitutional so long as it is not too severe," Justice Alito wrote.
asserted
Alito → hold → essence
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
