A federal judge has halted construction work on Donald Trump’s towering triumphal arch for 14 days, a major setback for one of the president’s most prominent projects in his vision to remake Washington.
asserted
judge → halt → Washington
The temporary restraining order was issued by US district judge Tanya Chutkan in the early hours of Friday.
asserted
order → issue → Friday
It followed a series of steps taken on Thursday by the government, including the final approval of the 250-foot-high (76-meter) arch by the National Capital Planning Commission in an 8-4 vote after a nine-hour hearing where dozens of witnesses opposed the construction.
asserted
dozens → follow → construction
The arch is one of several projects around Washington that Trump has undertaken as he remakes the city, from renovating one of its storied public golf courses to threatening to demolish the John F Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts.
asserted
he → undertake → Arts
Those projects could soon face greater scrutiny after the Democrats gained control of Congress.
uncertain
Democrats → face → Congress
The administration had said the work on the arch could begin as soon as the approval and the interior department issued a final decision authorizing construction and the proper notification was published by the National Park Service.
uncertain
notification → say → Service
In issuing the delay, Chutkan granted the request of the latest plaintiffs in lawsuits challenging the arch.
asserted
Chutkan → issue → arch
Chutkan also consolidated lawsuits from the District of Columbia and Virginia with a group of Vietnam veterans and an architectural historian.
asserted
Chutkan → consolidate → veterans
It’s unclear how much the project will cost, or how it will be paid for, although some estimates have reached as high as $100m.
uncertain
estimates → ’ → 100
The vote by the planning commission on Thursday came after nine and a half hours and scores of people opposing it.
asserted
vote → plan → it
The vote by the commission broke along federal and local lines.
asserted
vote → break → lines
Those in favor work for the administration or are connected to the president, who was pushing for the immediate construction.
asserted
who → work → construction
Opponents represented the city of Washington.
asserted
Opponents → represent → Washington
The remote, call-in hearing – which crashed repeatedly in the first few hours and was accompanied by a nearly universally negative comment section – drew witnesses who gave impassioned comments opposing an arch that they said would destroy the solemnity of the nearby Arlington national cemetery, where hundreds of thousands of fallen service members and military veterans are buried.
asserted
thousands → call → members
The panel’s Trump-appointed chair launched the meeting with a gushing appraisal of the towering monument and lauded Trump for wanting to build it.
“President Trump understands as president and a superb builder that it’s important to our national identity to display who we are through grand monuments,” said Mark Paoletta, the commission’s chair.
asserted
Paoletta → appoint → monuments
As Trump has often remarked, “the great cities around the world have arches: Paris, Rome, London,” said Paoletta, who also serves as general counsel for the White House Office of Management and Budget.
asserted
who → remark → Management
Commissioner Paul Ingrassia, a lawyer for the General Services Administration, said the arch was “not about politics.
asserted
arch → say → politics
It’s about remembrance.
asserted
It → ’ → remembrance
It’s about celebrating our history.
asserted
It → ’ → history
It’s about commemorating veterans.
asserted
It → ’ → veterans
And it’s really something that’s a noble tribute to our nation and something that we can all rally behind.
asserted
we → ’ → that
But DC city council member Phil Mendelson, who also serves on the planning panel, said the project had not received required approval from Congress, nor had Congress appropriated any money for it.
asserted
Congress → serve → it
The plan submitted to the commission does not include a reference to military use cited by Trump and other administration officials, Mendelson said.
asserted
Mendelson → submit → Trump
“We cannot approve final site and building plans until we have the final site and building plans,” he said.
asserted
he → approve → site
Representative Jared Huffman, a California Democrat who is set to chair the House Natural Resources Committee, called the project ill-advised and illegal.
asserted
who → set → project
“This arch would dishonor America,” Huffman told the commission.
asserted
Huffman → dishonor → commission
He called the proposed arch “a tribute to Donald Trump,” not veterans, as Trump administration officials claim.
uncertain
officials → call → Trump
The monument is similar to those built for emperors or kings, Huffman said, adding that Trump was using veterans as a pretext to build a memorial to himself.
asserted
Trump → build → himself
The Aporia
