Bomb threats have caused diversions and emergency landings for at least 15 flights across Europe, renewing questions about a possibly coordinated effort to disrupt travel.
uncertain
threats → cause → travel
The series of warnings on Thursday morning affected flights between Italy, Ireland, the UK, Spain, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland, Finland, Austria, Denmark, Belgium, Portugal, Greece and Czechia.
asserted
series → affect → Italy
On Tuesday seven planes across Europe were searched or diverted after malicious hoax bomb alerts.
asserted
planes → search → alerts
On Monday a flight from the UK to Bulgaria was diverted after a threat that was apparently without substance.
asserted
that → divert → substance
The latest alerts affected flights by Ryanair, Aer Lingus, Wizz Air, Finnair and LOT.
asserted
alerts → affect → Ryanair
All landed safely.
asserted
All → land → ?
Initial searches of some of the planes found nothing suspicious.
asserted
searches → find → nothing
Two Ryanair flights from Copenhagen and Madrid to Sofia made emergency landings in the Bulgarian capital while a Ryanair flight from London to Sofia was diverted and landed at Plovdiv, Bulgaria’s second largest city.
asserted
flight → make → Plovdiv
A Bulgarian government spokesperson said: “Upon landing, the necessary inspections were carried out in accordance with the applicable procedures and no issues were identified.
asserted
issues → say → procedures
Airport operations at both Sofia airport and Plovdiv airport have returned to normal.”
asserted
operations → return → airport
An Aer Lingus flight from Dublin to Rome was diverted to the Évreux-Fauville military airbase in northern France.
asserted
flight → divert → France
A Wizz Air flight from Milan to Warsaw was diverted to Vienna, while a Ryanair flight from Porto and an Aegean Airlines flight from Thessaloniki, both to Milan, were searched upon arrival at Milan’s Malpensa airport.
asserted
flight → divert → airport
Also affected were an LOT Polish Airlines flight from Warsaw to Brussels, two Finnair flights from Helsinki to Rome and Vienna and four flights by other airlines to Prague
asserted
flight → affect → Prague
A Czech police spokesperson said: “Security measures at Prague airport have just ended, with pyrotechnic inspections yielding negative results.”
asserted
inspections → say → results
The threats against the Finnair flights were “unfounded or hoax”, said an airline representative.
asserted
representative → say → flights
“Unfortunately, air traffic is sometimes subject to threats, as we have seen this week, when also other airlines in Europe have faced hoax bomb threats.
asserted
airlines → see → threats
The travel disruption followed cyber-attacks this week against supermarket refrigeration systems.
asserted
disruption → follow → systems
Some analysts speculate the disruption, along with drone incursions and triggering of app alerts, is part of a hybrid campaign to unsettle Europe on behalf of Iran, Russia or other state actors.
asserted
disruption → speculate → Iran
A Kremlin spokesperson said on Thursday it was “absurd” to blame Vladimir Putin’s administration for the hackers who targeted fridges.
asserted
who → say → fridges
“We have such baseless accusations against our country, implicating it in everything,” Dmitry Peskov told reporters.
asserted
Peskov → have → reporters
Many of the affected flights on Thursday were operated by low-cost carriers but there was little discernible pattern surrounding the incidents.
asserted
Many → operate → incidents
The Italian news agency Ansa, citing police sources, said the warning for the Helsinki-Rome and Dublin-Rome flights came from an anonymous email written in Italian and sent to the Rome airport company, ADR, and other affiliated companies.
asserted
warning → cite → company
Aviation experts say fake threats occur daily but that such a number of credible threats, even if malicious hoaxes, appears to point to coordinated action.
asserted
number → say → action
Capt Martin Drake, a former airline pilot and technical adviser to the Balpa union, said airlines had security teams who assessed each threat on a traffic-light scale: green to keep going or red to be grounded, with an amber option only for flights yet to take off, allowing tighter checks and searches of the plane before clearing it to fly.
“If you want to deliberately disrupt a flight, then you need to do so once it’s airborne,” said Drake.
asserted
Drake → say → flight
Pilots have a QRH – a quick response handbook – whose instructions will probably include to descend quickly as well as divert to the nearest airport on receipt of a red alert.
asserted
instructions → have → alert
At cruising altitude, “aircraft pressurisation would do a lot of the work of any improvised explosive device”.
asserted
pressurisation → do → device
Diversions are expensive as well as highly disruptive, but airlines have little choice in the face of any remotely credible threat.
asserted
airlines → have → threat
The ready availability of airline operations information on the internet means that any hoaxer now has a level of detail about the schedules, the type of plane and its technical specifications that would have eluded all but insiders decades ago.
asserted
that → mean → all
Rhys Jones, an analyst at Osprey Flight Solutions, an aviation intelligence firm, said the confidence of airlines in European airport security should not mean any change to normal protocols after the hoaxes, but “one of the natural responses will be to see double-downed security, media coverage and public concern about travelling”.
asserted
one → say → travelling
He said the threats seemed linked but “a reasonably chaotic campaign with no particular region targeted”, and while they could weaken future security responses through the normalisation of threats, simply creating disruption could be regarded as a success by those carrying out the hoaxes.
uncertain
creating → say → hoaxes
The Aporia
