Having devoted most of my adult life to reporting on, campaigning against, and exposing the corrosive influence of money in politics, I’m gratified that this cause was – finally – front of mind in a national election.
asserted
cause → devote → election
That’s right: in the midterms, corruption topped the list of Americans’ concerns, and candidates won by waging campaigns promising to reject corporate Pac money and linking Washington’s pay-to-play culture to the affordability crisis.
asserted
candidates → ’ → crisis
Looking ahead to 2028, the Democratic Georgia senator Jon Ossoff is now generating presidential buzz, dripping out clips of his speeches deriding a “coin-operated” government and slamming Citizens United – a ruling he rightly calls “the most destructive supreme court decision in modern American history”.
But as righteous and expansive as Democrats’ anti-corruption jeremiads have been amid billions spent to try to buy the midterm elections, the rhetoric so far has been accompanied by shockingly small proposals for mere nibble-at-the-edges reforms.
asserted
rhetoric → look → reforms
Ossoff would have you believe a real anti-corruption agenda is pushing to overturn Citizens United, a congressional stock trading ban and prohibiting traditional corporate political action committees.
asserted
agenda → have → committees
Ahead of his likely 2028 presidential campaign, the former Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel argues the answer to endemic corruption is banning government officials from betting in prediction markets, forcing them to put assets in blind trusts, and prohibiting them from accepting foreign gifts.
asserted
answer → argue → gifts
Emblematic of most challenger candidates this election cycle, the Democratic Kansas senator-elect Adam Hamilton vaguely insisted to the American Prospect: “What I’d like to do is figure out how we help get money out of politics instead of having it dictating politics” – but he offered only Emanuel’s prescriptions, plus a ban on lobbying by retired members of Congress.
asserted
he → insist → Congress
All of those are laudable ideas, but they are the equivalent of pruning a few saplings of corruption – they hardly constitute an agenda that rips up the roots and branches of Washington’s entire forest of graft.
asserted
that → prune → graft
Indeed, even repealing Citizens United would unto itself do little to truly corruption-proof the financing of political campaigns.
asserted
repealing → repeal → campaigns
So what is a real anti-corruption agenda that actually addresses the crisis?
asserted
that → address → crisis
To start, a Democratic Congress must use its subpoena power to build off investigative reporting and expose how Super Pacs have become a key vehicle for quid-pro-quo corruption in both parties.
asserted
Pacs → start → parties
Congressional inquiries exposing these schemes could both boost existing federal legislation to outlaw Super Pacs, as well as a landmark federal court case aiming to limit donations to Super Pacs.
uncertain
inquiries → expose → Pacs
Democrats must also pass their longstanding legislation requiring full disclosure of the sources of $1bn of dark money, and they must pass Senator Chris Van Hollen’s new bill closing loopholes that let federal contractors – and their owners, such as Elon Musk – easily circumvent the existing ban on election spending.
asserted
contractors → pass → spending
At the same time, Democrats in other states can follow Michigan and pass tough campaign spending disclosure laws – and prohibit utilities and government contractors from flooding money into elections.
asserted
Democrats → follow → elections
They can also follow Montana and Hawaii and amend their existing incorporation laws to bar companies from spending in elections.
asserted
They → follow → elections
And they can institute new internal Democratic party rules that reward primary candidates for rejecting Super Pac spending, and that punish those who rely on it.
asserted
who → institute → it
But even if all that happened – and even if Citizens United were successfully repealed and election spending could be restricted – the single most significant problem remains.
uncertain
problem → happen → ?
Candidates will still need resources to run campaigns and communicate their ideas to voters.
asserted
Candidates → need → voters
So where could they find resources that do not come from donors demanding legislative favors in return?
uncertain
that → find → return
One answer has been small-dollar donors – but save for the highest-profile politicians in the highest-profile nationalized races, most candidates for lower-profile offices will never be able to celebritize their candidacies and tap into national networks of thousands of grassroots contributors.
asserted
candidates → save → contributors
And we shouldn’t want them to – we shouldn’t want the election of your local school board member to be predicated on candidates’ ability to make spectacles of themselves in order to go nationally viral on Instagram.
asserted
election → want → Instagram
It is an old idea involving public money – an idea that is starting to be mentioned by a handful of insurgent candidates, but you have to listen closely for it, because it isn’t yet generating big headlines or going viral.
asserted
it → involve → headlines
How we take action
asserted
we → take → action
“There are things that we could do, like publicly fund campaigns, where if there’s a Super Pac that spends on a campaign, then it triggers public funding equal and opposite to that expenditure,” the Michigan Democratic senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed told me earlier this year.
uncertain
elect → be → me
Similarly, Maine’s Democratic senator-elect Troy Jackson says a real anti-corruption agenda “means advocating for publicly financed federal campaigns modeled after Maine’s historic clean-election system”.
asserted
agenda → say → system
Over in the House, the incoming Democratic representative Daniel Biss has touted his community’s local public financing system as a model for Congress, and Denver’s incoming Democratic representative Melat Kiros has said: “We need to have a caucus that is laser-focused on actually pushing through publicly financed elections.
asserted
that → tout → elections
That’s going to be one of the first things that I do.”
asserted
I → go → that
The call is even coming from a corner of the consulting class.
asserted
call → come → class
“The Democratic party should explore the idea of trying to create a system of public financing for elections,” longtime Democratic strategist Tad Devine told me.
asserted
Devine → explore → me
“We’re going to have to fight within our own party to make it happen, because it’s going to put the Wall Street guys out of business.
asserted
it → go → business
In different ways, they are all referring to what’s known as clean-election systems, which typically match candidates’ small-dollar, private donations with public money at multiples that let candidates run competitively resourced races.
asserted
candidates → refer → races
The idea is to give candidates a way to run for office that does not force them to finance their campaigns with money that comes with the expectation of legislative favors.
asserted
that → give → favors
A system of publicly financed federal elections isn’t some pie-in-the-sky idea – such systems already exist in a handful of states and cities across the country.
asserted
systems → finance → country
That includes Biss’s hometown of Evanston and Kiros’s hometown of Denver, as well as New York City, where Zohran Mamdani’s historic mayoral campaign against the billionaire class probably would never have gotten off the ground without municipal matching funds.
asserted
campaign → include → funds
“It’s incredibly important,” Mamdani told me when I asked him how significant his city’s public financing system was in his campaign.
asserted
system → ’ → campaign
“What it allows is the amplification of the voice of ordinary New Yorkers, as opposed to the billionaires who have grown used to buying our elections.”
asserted
who → allow → elections
Another rare historical moment of opportunity
Proposals to publicly finance federal elections have periodically been considered by Congress – and have gotten extremely close to becoming the law of the land in the aftermath of corruption scandals.
asserted
Proposals → finance → scandals
We’re now living in the Trump age of the perpetual corruption scandal – which should once again put public financing back on the agenda in states and in Washington.
asserted
which → live → Washington
For example: blue states can use new majorities from an anti-Trump election wave to start adopting public financing systems.
asserted
states → use → systems
Kiros’s state could be a good test case: after Democrat Phil Weiser won his gubernatorial primary on a promise that “the future of Colorado will not be decided by out-of-state billionaires,” he expressed support for the concept of public financing campaigns.
uncertain
he → win → campaigns
He and the new congresswoman could spearhead a ballot measure asking voters to extend a version of Denver’s public financing system to the whole state.
uncertain
He → spearhead → state
…and 20 more, not listed.
The Aporia
