We're now less than a month away from the expiration of the Collective Bargaining Agreement between the Major League Baseball Players Association and the league's owners, with a lockout a near-guarantee starting in early December.
asserted
lockout → start → December
For months, owners and the league office have been promoting the lockout to fans as necessary to address the sport's imaginary competitive balance problems.
asserted
owners → promote → problems
That this lockout wouldn't be like the others, because baseball needs a salary cap, the league said.
asserted
league → need → cap
The gap in spending, the marketing campaign went, made it impossible for small market teams to compete thanks to the disparity in payroll.
asserted
teams → go → payroll
Fast-forward to the end of the 2026 World Series, and it's hard to imagine an argument aging worse than that one.
asserted
argument → forward → one
The Milwaukee Brewers, who ranked 19th in team payroll in 2026, completed one of the most dominant postseason runs in the history of baseball.
asserted
who → rank → baseball
They went 11-2 in October, with their two losses coming by a combined total of two runs.
asserted
losses → go → runs
They swept the high-powered Los Angeles Dodgers, never once seeming in doubt of losing a game, let alone the series.
asserted
They → sweep → game
They were three outs away from sweeping the World Series and becoming the first team in history to go undefeated in the NLCS and World Series.
asserted
They → sweep → NLCS
Even after blowing that lead with Shane Drohan, they easily handled game five behind likely Cy Young winner Jacob Misiorowski.
asserted
they → blow → Misiorowski
Oh, and that team they played in the World Series?
asserted
they → play → Series
The team Tampa beat to advance to the World Series?
asserted
Tampa → beat → Series
The Cleveland Guardians, who ranked 30th in the league in payroll.
asserted
who → rank → payroll
The New York Yankees didn't reach the ALCS, and by October 2027, it'll be 18 years since their last World Series title.
asserted
it → reach → title
The Mets didn't even come close to reaching the playoffs, and haven't been remotely near a championship since Steve Cohen took over and raised payrolls to the highest in the league.
asserted
Cohen → come → league
Philadelphia didn't reach the World Series, losing in the wild card series.
asserted
Philadelphia → reach → series
And the Toronto Blue Jays finished in last place.
asserted
Jays → finish → place
The timing couldn't have been worse for the owners, now hoping to make their case for a salary cap after the 2026 season showed how little need there is for it.
asserted
season → hop → it
On Tuesday afternoon, they pushed for a salary cap yet again, publicly releasing a new proposal that would start their cap and floor system a year later, in 2028.
asserted
that → push → 2028
"We recognize that clubs will need a full offseason to prepare to operate within the cap and floor system," said MLB spokesman Glen Caplin, per MLB.com.
asserted
Caplin → recognize → MLB.com
"Therefore, with this offseason already underway, we proposed today to begin the cap and floor system in 2028.
asserted
we → propose → 2028
This proposal would allow a smoother transition into the cap and floor system without delaying key player benefits, including earlier free agency, a $1 million minimum salary, a 30% increase to the pre-arbitration bonus pool, and transactional reform that will reduce roster churn.
asserted
that → allow → churn
"The projected salary cap and floor for 2028 continues to provide more money for Major League players while leveling the playing field and giving more teams the ability to participate in the free-agent market and retain their homegrown stars so that every fan believes their team has a fair chance to win it all."
asserted
team → project → it
A statement so thoroughly disconnected from reality, it makes you wonder if the league office has been watching political ads for ideas.
asserted
office → make → ideas
In response, the Players Association predictably stated that the cap system is a non-starter, while correctly identifying that the cap proposal is there for one reason, and one reason only: to make owners more money.
asserted
proposal → state → money
Details of the proposed cap and floor system are complicated, but suffice it to say, the league's contention is absurd and would have nothing to do with competitive balance.
asserted
contention → propose → balance
The floor, a proposed "$180 million," shows how much money small market owners are currently pocketing.
asserted
owners → propose → money
That figure would correspond to an increase of tens of millions, if not over $100 million dollars more than teams like the Guardians and Rays are spending.
asserted
teams → correspond → Guardians
Yes, the cap would require more revenue sharing, but by the league's own admission, there are 12 teams that need to increase their "payroll" by $636 million combined to get to the floor.
asserted
that → require → floor
There isn't enough revenue sharing from the Dodgers or Mets to increase that would cover that difference.
asserted
that → be → difference
Which demonstrates that these owners are simply spending much less than they can already afford.
asserted
they → demonstrate → less
They're choosing not to, because it's so much easier for the fans, and they complain about small markets instead.
asserted
they → choose → markets
Obviously, as 2026 demonstrated, there is no argument to be made that competitive balance requires a cap.
asserted
balance → demonstrate → cap
The Dodgers, for their market size and payrolls, are 3-14 in their last 17 attempts at winning a World Series.
asserted
Dodgers → win → Series
A New York team hasn't won since 2009, and the Mets are up to 40 years since their last title, the seventh-longest streak in baseball.
asserted
Mets → win → baseball
The Padres have paid into the luxury tax for years now, and their reward is one win in the NLCS.
asserted
reward → pay → NLCS
But all these mistakes are the real issue: baseball has no competitive balance problem, because the gaps between teams are so small that competitive balance can never actually be a problem.
asserted
balance → have → teams
For some perspective, in the NBA, the better team wins a best-of-seven series roughly 80% of the time.
asserted
team → win → time
In order for that to happen in MLB, the series would have to be a best-of-75.
asserted
series → happen → MLB
The Dodgers had a $250 million payroll advantage over Milwaukee, and a 58-42% probability of winning in the series in pre-NLCS projections.
asserted
Dodgers → have → projections
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
