Thomas Markle Sr. could potentially avoid standing trial over allegations that he possessed child pornography if his reported move into a dementia care home leaves him unable to understand the criminal proceedings or assist in his own defense, experts tell Page Six.
uncertain
experts → avoid → Page
But the diagnosis alone won’t necessarily get the estranged father of Meghan Markle, 45, off the hook.
asserted
father → get → hook
Former FBI agent Jason Pack tells Page Six that “a dementia diagnosis doesn’t automatically prevent an arrest if investigators have probable cause.”
asserted
investigators → tell → cause
“It could become relevant in court, but those are separate questions: whether someone can understand the charges and help with their defense, and whether they were legally responsible at the time of the alleged conduct,” he explains.
uncertain
he → become → conduct
“A diagnosis alone answers neither,” he adds.
asserted
he → answer → neither
“The evidence and the court process should decide the case, not the court of public opinion.”
asserted
evidence → decide → opinion
Board-certified neurologist Dr. Jeremy M. Liff tells Page Six that a neurological disorder could complicate investigators’ ability to establish whether Markle, 82, was capable of making decisions at the time of the alleged offenses.
uncertain
Markle → certify → offenses
“There could be a problem with the idea that he would lack capacity or the capability of making his own decisions, and how that plays into being able to prosecute someone,” Liff says.
uncertain
Liff → lack → someone
“In some ways, it’s sort of like an insanity plea, except in this case, you have an actual neurological disorder that does not allow you to make competent decisions.”
asserted
you → ’ → decisions
Liff explains that dementia can cause a person to lose inhibitions, particularly when the frontal lobe is affected.
asserted
lobe → explain → inhibitions
“Typically, in dementia, there can be a lack of inhibition, especially in frontal lobe degeneration,” he says, noting that shoplifting and becoming suspicious of others are among the behaviors that can occur.
asserted
that → say → behaviors
However, he cautions against assuming that dementia would explain the specific allegations against Markle.
asserted
dementia → caution → Markle
“In the case of child pornography, certainly if you could demonstrate that someone who was accused was able to carry out the steps that it takes to obtain child pornography or to distribute it, then that goes against their dementia defense because they were able to carry out those other tasks,” Liff says.
uncertain
Liff → demonstrate → tasks
“I think something that specific is not something that you could typically blame dementia on, but of course, it’s a case-by-case basis.
uncertain
it → think → case
Forensic psychiatrist and expert witness Dr. Carole Lieberman tells Page Six that if Markle is ultimately charged, his legal team would likely bring in multiple medical experts to assess his mental and neurological condition.
asserted
team → tell → condition
That evaluation could include a review of his medical records from the past five years, psychological testing to determine competency, an in-depth psychiatric examination and neurological testing, she explains.
uncertain
she → include → competency
If he is deemed incompetent to stand trial, efforts could initially be made to restore his competency.
uncertain
efforts → deem → competency
“However, most dementia cases cannot be reversed,” Lieberman says.
asserted
Lieberman → reverse → ?
She adds that if Markle cannot be restored to competency, the charges could potentially be dismissed or he could be placed in an appropriate inpatient setting.
uncertain
he → add → setting
But that outcome is not automatic, and a finding that someone is incompetent to stand trial does not necessarily mean they cannot face legal consequences.
asserted
they → stand → consequences
Thomas Markle Jr., reportedly contacted authorities after allegedly discovering hundreds, if not thousands, of images depicting child sexual abuse among belongings at his father’s former home in Cebu.
uncertain
Jr. → contact → Cebu
Markle Sr. has vehemently denied the accusations, calling them “sick lies” and telling the Daily Mail that he had never downloaded such material.
asserted
he → deny → material
His daughter, Meghan Markle, said she was “deeply distressed” by the allegations and that her decision to keep her children away from their grandfather was made to protect them.
asserted
decision → say → them
No criminal charges have been announced against Markle Sr. in connection with the allegations
Conversation
asserted
charges → announce → allegations
The Aporia
