- Published
Scientists say they have been "stunned" by how quickly young children's lungs began to recover and grow after pollution restrictions were brought in where they lived.
asserted
they → publish → ?
Researchers found that children in London whose lung growth had been stunted by pollution showed impressive improvements after the introduction of an Ultra Low Emission Zone (Ulez) in 2019 reduced emissions.
asserted
introduction → find → emissions
The study followed more than 3,400 primary school children in London and Luton and provides what scientists believe is the strongest evidence yet that local clean air zones could help reduce some of the harm caused by pollution during childhood.
uncertain
zones → follow → childhood
But independent researchers caution that other factors must also be considered.
asserted
factors → caution → ?
Air pollution can stunt the growth of young children's lungs leaving them at an increased risk of asthma, heart disease, diabetes and even premature death.
asserted
pollution → stunt → asthma
Children are also more vulnerable to pollution because their lungs and immune systems are still developing.
asserted
lungs → develop → pollution
And when outside, they tend to be closer to the ground and nearer sources of exhaust fumes, for example.
asserted
they → tend → example
In 2020 Ella Adoo-Kissi-Debrah, a nine-year-old girl from London who died following an asthma attack in 2013, became the first person in the UK to have air pollution listed as a cause of death.
asserted
pollution → die → death
In the study, researchers recruited six to nine-year-olds attending primary schools in London's ultra low emission zone and followed the same children for five years, comparing them to similar children (in terms of socio-economic background, physical activity and ethnicity) in Luton.
asserted
researchers → recruit → Luton
Children in the study had annual lung function and capacity tests in the year before Ulez came in and for four years after.
asserted
Ulez → have → years
Initial results showed children's lungs in London were smaller in capacity than those in Luton, which is less polluted than London but has a similar mix of pollutants.
asserted
which → show → pollutants
At the end of the study the children's lung capacity reached near identical levels in both groups.
asserted
capacity → reach → groups
"While we would expect children's lungs to grow year on year, our results indicate that the London children's lung growth had accelerated during the four years to 'catch up' with the control group in Luton to reach similar levels of lung capacity," researchers say.
asserted
researchers → expect → capacity
"I was absolutely stunned when I first saw the results," Prof Chris Griffiths, a senior author on the study, at Queen Mary University of London, told the BBC.
asserted
Griffiths → stun → BBC
"This shows an ambitious clean air zone can drive pollution levels down, rapidly restoring children's stunted lung growth.
asserted
zone → show → growth
"
The main test measured how much air a child could forcibly breathe out in one second after a big breath in.
uncertain
child → measure → breath
In practical terms the improvements could mean children in the London group could run as fast as the Luton group without getting out of breath or blow out the same number of candles for example, Griffiths explained.
uncertain
Griffiths → mean → example
Another way of testing for lung capacity used in the study showed significant improvements too, though not to the same extent - implying there are still gains to be made.
asserted
way → test → extent
Overall the proportion of children in London whose lung capacity was deemed "clinically impaired" (suggesting lung damage resulting in coughs or breathlessness) fell from 14% to 9%.
asserted
capacity → deem → %
In Luton - where some smaller scale measures were put in place to tackle air pollution - the figures were 9% to 7%.
asserted
figures → put → pollution
The team's measurements also showed the level of nitrogen dioxide children were exposed to fell faster in London than in Luton over this time.
asserted
children → show → time
Researchers say this is key as it likely demonstrates that the improved lung growth they saw was related to air quality improvements following the implementation of Ulez.
asserted
they → say → Ulez
London's Ulez was first introduced in 2019 by Mayor Sadiq Khan in a bid to "clean up London's air".
asserted
Ulez → introduce → air
London had high levels of the harmful gas nitrogen dioxide which comes from motor vehicles.
asserted
which → have → vehicles
Older, more polluting vehicles had to pay a daily charge to drive in central London.
asserted
vehicles → pollute → London
The measures were later expanded to cover the whole capital.
asserted
measures → expand → capital
While many supported the policy it provoked political opposition and protests.
asserted
it → support → opposition
Prof Anna Hansell, at the University of Leicester, who was not involved in the study said the improved lung function in children was "likely to have lifelong benefits for their health."
asserted
function → involve → health
She added the study was "carefully conducted by "well-respected researchers" and that the geographical comparisons between London and Luton were important as there had been general reductions in air pollution over time.
"This proved particularly useful, given that the study period included the Covid-19 pandemic – and demonstrates the findings in London are not due to changes related to the pandemic," she said.
asserted
she → add → pandemic
Another aspect to consider was that the London group may have been more likely to walk or cycle to school once Ulez came in.
uncertain
Ulez → consider → school
Meanwhile, Kevin McConway, emeritus professor at the Open University, said it was important to take the full impact of Covid into account and argued that studying other cities could help tease out whether some improvements were due to unmeasured differences between London and Luton.
uncertain
improvements → say → London
Lead author, Dr Helen Wood, at Queen Mary University of London said while the results were very promising there was no room for complacency as "air pollution in both London and Luton – as well as other cities across the UK – remains above WHO guideline levels, so there is still work to be done".
"
asserted
pollution → say → levels
We know clean air zones are a complex area and the impact on businesses and individuals must be considered.
asserted
impact → know → businesses
What we are doing is adding new evidence to inform the debate," Griffiths said.
asserted
Griffiths → do → debate
The work involved researchers from the Universities of Bedfordshire, Oxford, Cambridge, Edinburgh and Southern California and is published in the Lancet Public Health.
asserted
work → involve → Health
The Aporia
