Being “disrespectful or rude or acting like a crazy idiot” towards women during sex is not a crime if there is consent, Russell Brand’s barrister has said.
asserted
barrister → act → sex
Ian Winter KC’s remarks came as he concluded his closing speech at Southwark Crown Court on Monday, where he urged the jury to separate Brand’s sexual behaviour and treatment of women from the question of whether he committed crimes.
asserted
he → come → crimes
Brand, 51, denies three charges of rape, three counts of sexual assault and one count of attempted indecent assault against six women, in allegations spanning 10 years from 1999.
asserted
Brand → deny → 1999
Mr Winter told jurors: “It is not criminal to treat women unkindly before, during or after sex.
asserted
It → tell → sex
“It is not, I am afraid, criminal to be disrespectful or rude or to act like a crazy idiot.
asserted
I → act → idiot
“If there is consent it is lawful.”
asserted
it → be → ?
The barrister said that their allegations came “very, very many years” later, adding that they “only did so once the well of justice had been corrupted and contaminated” and until the “ground had been cut from under his feet and the public mind poisoned against him.”
Read More
He questioned how none of the women came forward during the MeToo movement.
Mr Winter said: “How is it that it’s only three out of the many, many women, how is it that not even these ones, not even these allegations on this indictment, came to light during MeToo.
“Many women were questioning whether they had a bad experience sexually at the hands of a famous person.
asserted
they → say → person
It could not have been more publicised,” he said.
uncertain
he → publicise → ?
“How is it that not one of them thought what happened to them involved a crime during the MeToo movement?”
asserted
happened → think → movement
Brand’s comedy was “radical and different” as he was “telling the truth about what was going on consensually between adults”, Mr Winter said.
asserted
Winter → tell → adults
The barrister said: “You may think that while his comedy was certainly not to all tastes and very much the product of the time, he was honest then about it, he was honest then about what sort of sex he was engaged in.”
uncertain
he → say → sex
He said Brand’s stand-up comedy was focused on him “telling the truth”, adding: “When you put yourself back to the time, it was radical and different because someone was telling the truth about what’s going on consensually between adults.”
asserted
what → say → adults
Mr Winter said reporting in a Channel 4 Dispatches documentary and by The Times and The Sunday Times prompted the complainants to come forward, but had created a “fundamentally compromised” case against the comedian.
asserted
reporting → say → comedian
Opening his speech, the barrister quoted 19th-century philosopher John Henry Newman and his description of an attempt to “poison the wells”.
asserted
barrister → open → wells
He told jurors that journalists had “poisoned the well of justice” in Brand’s case, saying the women had been “drawn forth” by the 2023 allegations rather than independently deciding to report their own.
asserted
women → tell → own
He said: “They all came forward for reasons connected to the TV programme, not for reasons personable to themselves.”
asserted
They → say → themselves
Mr Winter said the women were “not random, not independent”, adding that they had each been “thoroughly contaminated” by the documentary.
Of the allegations, he said that the women may “think it now”, but this does not “reflect what they were actually thinking back then”.
He added: “That is the precise consequence of the poisoning of the well.
uncertain
That → say → well
Mr Winter also argued that the passage of time had created another problem for the case, describing the delay between the alleged offences and reports to police as “monstrous”.
asserted
passage → argue → police
He said: “Delay makes it impossible to litigate the issues in the way you would if it wasn’t in the way.”
asserted
it → say → way
Mr Winter added that delay “does something particularly savage in a case where it’s one person’s word against another person’s word.”
asserted
it → add → word
He told jurors they were dealing with a “quagmire of doubt and inaccurate recollection”.
asserted
they → tell → doubt
Brand “genuinely believed” the women were consenting which is why he was described as acting normally, the barrister said.
asserted
barrister → believe → ?
Mr Winter said there was a “curious feature” to the evidence from the complainants, adding: “They have all given evidence that Mr Brand’s behaviour was normal either during and/or after the incidents.”
asserted
behaviour → say → incidents
He added: “That, we suggest, is something that simply cannot have occurred if he is guilty.”
asserted
he → add → ?
The barrister said the fact he behaved normally showed Brand believed they had consented.
asserted
they → say → ?
He added: “He couldn’t have been behaving normally if he knew they were not.
“He obviously genuinely believed that they were consenting because that’s the only thing that would explain why his behaviour was normal.”
asserted
behaviour → add → ?
Mr Winter added that there is “no evidence he is some sort of psychopath who rapes people and thinks it’s normal”.
asserted
it → add → people
He also told jurors: “What matters is he (Brand) had an immense amount of sex and none of it was unlawful.”
asserted
none → tell → it
He added: “Disgusting, distasteful, immoral, who cares?
asserted
who → add → ?
“It’s irrelevant to your consideration.”
asserted
It → ’ → consideration
Mr Winter put to jurors: “Why is it that only three rapes in 10 years?”
asserted
it → put → years
The barrister also pointed to the evidence of Mr Brand’s wife, adding: “She fell in love with that man in full knowledge of what he was doing.
asserted
he → point → what
“She married him, she bore him three children.”
asserted
she → marry → children
He added that she would not have done so if Brand was “guilty as charged”.
asserted
Brand → add → ?
The barrister said the prosecution had reached for Brand’s 2007 memoir My Booky Wook in a “bid of desperation”.
asserted
prosecution → say → desperation
Mr Winter said it was a “funny book” containing jokes, highlighting a passage alongside a childhood photograph in which Brand wrote: “This is the exact moment when I decided to act gay to attract girls.”
asserted
I → say → girls
The barrister added: “It was so obviously a joke…
“The joke is that it didn’t work.”
asserted
it → add → ?
Mr Winter said the 2023 allegations against Brand had had a “truly devastating effect” on him, reminding jurors of the defendant’s recounting of being blocked from visiting his baby son when he was having open heart surgery at Great Ormond Street Hospital.
asserted
he → say → Hospital
Mr Winter said: “That tells you the extent to which public opinion has been perverted and corrupted.”
asserted
opinion → say → which
Brand sat upright and looked straight ahead in the dock during his barrister’s closing speech.
asserted
Brand → sit → speech
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
