It was in the Spring of 2022, near the tail end of the pandemic when I sat down at an outdoor café in downtown Los Angeles to interview city councilmember, Nithya Raman.
asserted
I → sit → councilmember
At the time, Raman — the first elected council member backed by the Democratic Socialists of America — was halfway into her first term while two other DSA backed candidates, Eunisses Hernandez and Hugo Soto-Martinez, were vying to join her on the 15-member council.
asserted
candidates → elect → council
I was working on a story for Los Angeles Magazine about where on the political spectrum LA stood as a city, and was eager to include Raman in my reporting.
asserted
LA → work → reporting
It didn’t go well.
asserted
It → go → ?
Within minutes it was clear that Raman was not interested in exploring this idea with me nor did she want to be a character in my larger narrative.
asserted
she → explore → narrative
Despite my best efforts to draw her out, Raman kept repeating that she didn’t approach her policy work from any one political standpoint.
asserted
she → draw → standpoint
She wasn’t keen on discussing political labels nor did she want to take credit for the emergence of Hernandez and Soto-Martinez, both of whom went on to victory.
asserted
both → discuss → victory
After 15 minutes of what was supposed to be an hour-long interview, Raman politely stood up and excused herself.
asserted
Raman → suppose → herself
But the question of political labels has hovered over Raman and her campaign.
asserted
question → hover → Raman
When she announced that she would be running against current mayor and her former political ally Karen Bass in March, there was an immediate rush to compare Raman to New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani, also a DSA-backed candidate.
asserted
she → announce → Mamdani
Raman, however, does not nearly possess the political skills of Mamdani, witnessed by her flaccid debate performances and some of her flubbed media appearances.
asserted
Raman → possess → appearances
An even bigger distinction is how deeply conflicted she has been about the defining element of her political identity — her affiliation with the DSA.
asserted
she → define → DSA
During the primary, Raman seemed keen on staying friendly with the DSA-LA chapter while not actually seeking their endorsement.
asserted
Raman → seem → endorsement
It was a high-wire act which was ultimately foiled by the candidacy of former reality star Spencer Pratt.
asserted
which → foil → Pratt
When Raman found herself polling behind Pratt she pivoted to the left, appearing on left-wing commentator Hasan Piker’s show in May just weeks before the primary.
uncertain
she → find → primary
It was during that interview she stated that she believed Israel had committed genocide in Gaza.
asserted
Israel → state → Gaza
In September, DSA-LA officially endorsed Raman but the national organization recently indicated that they may rescind the endorsement over Raman’s position on the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement.
uncertain
they → endorse → movement
Her awkward dance with the DSA has come at a cost of defining her own political identity.
asserted
dance → come → identity
“She’s been painted by everyone; the Spencer Pratt voters, all slices of the DSA, by her colleagues on the council and the mayor.
asserted
She → paint → council
Yet very few people have a good understanding of who she is and that’s her own damn fault,” said one city hall insider.
asserted
insider → have → understanding
Over the past six weeks, several polls showed Raman with a sizable lead over Bass, but last week a LA Times poll cast them in a dead heat.
asserted
poll → show → heat
With a 28-year gap in their age some outlets have characterized the race between Raman and Bass as a generational one while other outlets have called it a referendum on where the party is headed.
asserted
party → characterize → it
As a city, LA remains a Democratic stronghold.
asserted
LA → remain → city
The last Republican mayor was Richard Riordan and the city council and county board of supervisors are almost entirely populated by registered Democrats.
asserted
council → populate → Democrats
But between the sprawl, the overlapping bureaucracies and its unparalleled mix of religions and ethnicities, LA has never been easy to paint with one political brush — especially at the mayoral level.
asserted
LA → overlap → level
If Raman proves victorious, it may ultimately come down to a climate where disgust with the status quo wins out.
uncertain
disgust → prove → quo
“Voters don’t want ideology from their mayor,” said political consultant Marc Adelman.
asserted
Adelman → want → mayor
“They want things to work and for their city to operate at a varsity level when it comes to safety and fixing street lights.
asserted
it → want → lights
They aren’t looking for party platform bullet points.”
asserted
They → look → points
The Aporia
