Trump's Iran threat renews Gulf fears of a war it didn't choose
MANAMA, Nov 2 -
asserted
it → renew → war
US President Donald Trump’s threat to strike Iran again confronts America’s Gulf allies with a stark prospect: another war decided in Washington in which the US bases built to protect them could instead make them targets for harsh Iranian reprisal.
uncertain
them → strike → reprisal
Iranian missiles that struck US military bases and Gulf energy facilities in the last round of fighting exposed a vulnerability at the heart of Washington’s decades-old security architecture.
asserted
that → strike → architecture
Rather than deterring Tehran, America’s sprawling regional footprint gave Iran fixed targets and the Gulf states hosting them pressure points it can exploit.
asserted
it → deter → points
That prospect dominated discussions among ministers, policymakers and security officials at the annual Manama Dialogue security conference in Bahrain over the weekend, as governments weighed what another round of war could mean for US forces and the countries that host them.
uncertain
that → dominate → them
The urgency has grown as Trump again threatened military action, saying he could launch “another little Operation Epic Fury” after Tuesday’s midterm elections, referring to the US-Israeli operation that began on Feb 28.
uncertain
that → grow → Feb
Four European officials said the US had amassed enough forces and assets in the region to attack Iran at short notice, possibly as soon as this week.
uncertain
US → say → week
"War is coming," said a fifth European official who has close contact with Gulf leaders.
asserted
who → come → leaders
Egypt's Foreign Minister Badr Abdelatty told the Manama conference another round of fighting would be more dangerous and destructive than the last: “It will lead to nowhere.”
asserted
It → tell → last
FROM SHIELD TO TARGET
Two of the European officials told Reuters any US attack would likely target Iranian nuclear sites, including research and development facilities.
asserted
attack → tell → facilities
Among likely locations is Pickaxe Mountain, a site linked to Iran's nuclear program, although the officials said military action would probably be able only to weaken Tehran's capabilities rather than destroy them.
asserted
action → link → them
Iranian officials have told Reuters that Tehran has drawn up detailed target lists in retaliation for another US-Israeli attack, including undersea communications cables and military bases, some covert.
asserted
some → tell → cables
The strategy could widen the cost of war beyond the battlefield, with energy infrastructure, desalination plants, communications networks and highly visible targets in Gulf cities at risk.
uncertain
strategy → widen → risk
Iran cannot match the United States and Israel militarily.
asserted
Iran → match → States
But it does not need to, three delegates said.
asserted
delegates → need → ?
Its strategy is increasingly one of attrition: make US forces expensive to defend and sustain, turn the Gulf states hosting them into pressure points, and leverage any American retrenchment as evidence that Washington cannot protect its partners.
asserted
Washington → make → partners
"What the Iranians really care about is the departure of US forces from the region," said Emile Hokayem, director of regional security at The International Institute for Strategic Studies, which organises the Manama conference.
asserted
which → care → conference
Tehran's message to Gulf powers, he told Reuters, is mainly: "You spent four decades investing in the US and after 40 years, those bases didn't protect you, they exposed you.
asserted
they → tell → you
Near its base in Juffair, the scars of strikes were still visible metres from residential areas: the corrugated iron roof and front of a warehouse were torn open and charred where projectiles had struck, while a radar facing Iran was missing a third of its dish.
asserted
radar → tear → dish
The damage has forced Washington to confront a question far beyond Bahrain: whether to rebuild, harden or withdraw a military footprint built to project US power, not withstand sustained missile and drone attacks.
asserted
damage → force → missile
THE GULF PAYS THE PRICE
asserted
GULF → pay → PRICE
For Bahrain, fears of Iranian threats are layered onto an older sectarian and historical faultline.
asserted
fears → layer → faultline
In 2011, mass protests led largely by the Shi’ite community challenged the Sunni Al Khalifa monarchy.
asserted
protests → lead → monarchy
Bahrain's rulers crushed the revolt and accused Iran of manipulating the unrest, a charge Tehran denied.
asserted
Tehran → crush → charge
Since the latest war began, some Iranian hardliners have again invoked Bahrain as Iran’s “14th province”, despite Tehran abandoning its territorial claim in 1970.
uncertain
Tehran → begin → 1970
Against that history, strikes on US facilities threaten not only America’s military presence in Bahrain but the kingdom hosting it.
asserted
strikes → threaten → it
"We're basically looking at the worst-case scenario," a Gulf official told Reuters, anticipating that the US would soon strike Iran, leading to Iranian retaliation against civilian infrastructure across the Gulf.
asserted
US → look → Gulf
Another Gulf official said that “in the end, only one person decides” whether conflict resumes and how intense it becomes, a reference to Trump that underscored the Gulf states’ limited power to shape a conflict whose consequences they would bear.
asserted
they → say → consequences
In response to questions for this article, a White House official said “all options” remained available and Iran faced “the easy way or the hard way,” adding: “President Trump holds all the cards.”
asserted
Trump → say → cards
“The Iranian campaign is to exhaust the Americans.
asserted
campaign → exhaust → Americans
It's not to win,” Hokayem added.
asserted
Hokayem → win → ?
“They can force you to spend more energy, more weapons, more money over time.”
asserted
They → force → time
RACING TO AVERT ANOTHER WAR
That concern is pushing Gulf states towards diplomacy.
asserted
concern → race → diplomacy
Senior officials from Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Pakistan held talks with Iranian officials in Tehran last month, with Saudi Arabia saying the effort was intended to “prevent the return of military escalation.”
asserted
effort → hold → escalation
Qatari officials also held meetings in Tehran and Doha over the weekend to avert renewed war.
asserted
officials → hold → war
"We are hoping that there is a diplomatic breakthrough.
asserted
We → hop → ?
We don't really want to see another round of confrontation in the region," United Arab Emirates senior official Anwar Gargash told the Manama conference.
asserted
Gargash → want → conference
The UAE was, however, "braced for the worst," he said.
asserted
he → brace → worst
The European official close to Gulf leaders said there was deep pessimism about whether diplomacy can bridge the Washington-Tehran divide, with renewed war seen as a matter of when, not if.
asserted
war → say → if
The question is no longer whether Washington remains committed to the Gulf, but what a US security guarantee means when the infrastructure underpinning it is itself a target.
asserted
infrastructure → remain → it
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
