The last straw for Democratic congresswoman Haley Stevens came on Saturday afternoon.
asserted
straw → come → afternoon
She was on the cusp of appearing at a unity event with Abdul El-Sayed, who defeated her in an August primary and became Michigan’s Democratic Senate nominee.
asserted
who → appear → primary
Several powerful intermediaries had been trying to broker peace between the former rivals, who were sparring over El-Sayed’s strong criticisms of Israel.
asserted
who → try → Israel
But after Stevens issued a hostile statement on Friday morning calling upon El-Sayed to condemn an ad made by a supportive political action committee and make other concessions, he stepped before reporters and said what his campaign had been signalling privately: he no longer wanted Stevens to join him at a Detroit church on Sunday.
asserted
Stevens → issue → Sunday
It was one thing not to be welcomed by El-Sayed’s Senate campaign.
asserted
It → welcome → campaign
It was quite another for him to say so in public.
asserted
him → say → public
So Stevens on Sunday did what she had been telling everyone she would not do.
asserted
she → do → everyone
She endorsed former congressman Mike Rogers, El-Sayed’s Republican opponent in a race critical to control of the Senate.
asserted
She → endorse → Senate
“Abdul made very clear that I was not welcome in his campaign, that he didn’t need me there, that he didn’t want me there,” Stevens said while standing next to Rogers outside a black church in Detroit, where they had just attended the Sunday service.
asserted
they → make → service
“I did endorse the Democratic nominee, and he chose to close this campaign by saying I wasn’t welcome.
asserted
I → endorse → campaign
I’ve never been invited to a campaign event.
asserted
I → invite → event
That’s fine.
asserted
That → ’ → ?
You know, he’s busy.
asserted
he → know → ?
He’s running all around.”
asserted
He → run → ?
Stevens’ extraordinary declaration and church appearance with Rogers were a stunning denouement of her weeks-long feud with El-Sayed, who narrowly defeated her in the Michigan Senate primary.
asserted
who → defeat → primary
Throughout their evident tension this northern fall, she insisted she was a team player and a good Democrat who would grit her teeth and back El-Sayed while working hard for other party members on the ticket.
asserted
who → insist → ticket
Their dispute is deeply personal, involving slights between two mercurial millennial politicians of sizable egos quick to take offence.
asserted
dispute → involve → offence
El-Sayed, supremely confident, did not wish to give an inch to a defeated rival.
asserted
Sayed → wish → rival
Stevens, still absorbing her primary loss, eventually felt scorned by his campaign’s failure to include her in events or reach out for her views, and embarrassed to be told to stay away.
asserted
Stevens → absorb → views
But the breach also represents a major fissure coursing through the Democratic Party about what its relationship with Israel and Jewish donors should be.
asserted
relationship → represent → Israel
El-Sayed, if he wins on Tuesday (US time) and enters the Senate in January, would be the most anti-Israel US senator since the formation of the Jewish state 78 years ago.
asserted
he → win → state
For now, the collapse of the Stevens-El-Sayed alliance has created an embarrassing and potentially costly drama for Democrats in a race that holds Republicans’ best chance of flipping a Senate seat.
asserted
that → create → seat
Stevens faced a swift backlash Sunday from her party, which was caught off-guard by her defection.
asserted
which → face → defection
“It’s just really unfortunate given the stakes that this has turned into such a spectacle because of one person,” said Lonnie Scott, a veteran Michigan Democratic operative.
asserted
Scott → ’ → person
“It is definitely not ideal that we’d be talking about Haley Stevens three days out from an election.”
asserted
we → talk → election
This account of their split is based on interviews with more than a dozen people involved in or briefed on talks with El-Sayed’s camp and Stevens’ team, some of whom spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe private conversations, as well as public remarks from El-Sayed, Stevens and Rogers.
asserted
some → base → Sayed
A unity breakfast, and then nothing more
Days after El-Sayed won a bitter primary race against Stevens in August that centred on disagreements over Israel, they appeared together at a unity breakfast.
asserted
they → win → breakfast
Stevens gave him a hug.
asserted
Stevens → give → hug
Since then, El-Sayed’s campaign hired a handful of Stevens’ campaign staff members, but he had next to no communication with her, according to Stevens and two others with knowledge of their relationship.
uncertain
he → hire → relationship
She was never invited to campaign with him, nor were her thoughts solicited about how to proceed.
asserted
thoughts → invite → him
At times, other Democrats tried to include her in the campaign.
asserted
Democrats → try → campaign
In mid-September, Ray Wert, whose wife, Mallory McMorrow, had run in the Democratic Senate primary but finished a distant third, texted Stevens.
asserted
wife → run → Stevens
He had a request.
asserted
He → have → request
Wert, who is active in Democratic circles, wanted to publish an opinion essay in Stevens’ name attacking Rogers in a Jewish news outlet.
asserted
who → want → outlet
Stevens was initially receptive, according to screenshots of texts Wert provided to The New York Times.
uncertain
Wert → accord → Times
“I really like what you wrote,” she messaged to Wert on September 20.
asserted
she → like → September
Wert replied, “I hope I captured your voice.”
asserted
I → reply → voice
“You did,” she replied.
asserted
she → do → ?
In late September, Stevens was suggesting edits to the essay over text.
asserted
Stevens → suggest → text
But something seemed to change at the end of the month.
asserted
something → seem → month
…and 77 more, not listed.
The Aporia
