Hungary’s new government will on Wednesday reveal the names of tens of thousands of state informants from the communist era in an attempt to confront the past and rebuild public trust.
asserted
government → reveal → trust
From 1945 to 1989, Hungary’s communist state-security services relied on an extensive network of informants to monitor society and suppress dissent.
asserted
services → rely → dissent
Some were blackmailed or coerced into reporting on neighbours, friends, colleagues and even family members; others were recruited through promises of various advantages.
asserted
others → blackmail → advantages
For decades, the extent of this network was hidden from public view.
asserted
extent → hide → view
The “agent files”, held in the basement of the Historical Archives of the State Security services, remained largely inaccessible to the public, despite repeated calls and partial leaks.
asserted
files → hold → calls
During his campaign leading up to Hungary’s April parliamentary elections, Péter Magyar promised to make the state-security files public, a promise he seems intent on fulfilling now he is in power.
asserted
he → lead → power
In September, his government passed a law paving the way for the files to be made public, a move more than two-thirds of the country supported according to polls.
uncertain
thirds → pass → polls
The release was initially scheduled for the anniversary of the 1956 anti-Soviet revolution but was pushed back to 4 November.
asserted
release → schedule → November
“A democratic society has the right to know its past,” Zoltán Tarr, the minister of social relations and culture, wrote on Facebook.
asserted
Tarr → have → Facebook
Previously, access to the reports on informants was restricted to researchers and relatives of victims.
asserted
access → restrict → victims
With the new, searchable online database, Hungary’s former state-service will become the most transparent in the former eastern bloc, researchers say.
asserted
researchers → become → bloc
“We are opening wide a door that was left ajar,” said István Papp, a historian and head of the academic department of the archives.
asserted
Papp → open → archives
“As a historian, I agree with the release of the files.
asserted
I → agree → files
But on a personal level, I feel for those who will face their family’s history for the first time,” Papp said.
asserted
Papp → feel → time
Of the 50,000 to 60,000 people whose names appear in the files, historians estimate 10% are alive today.
asserted
% → appear → files
For three decades, the former eastern bloc has been divided on how to publish agent files, and when.
asserted
bloc → divide → files
In East Germany, the Bundestag opened state security Stasi files in 1992.
asserted
Bundestag → open → 1992
In the Czech Republic, they became open to the public in 2003.
asserted
they → become → 2003
Most recently, Latvia published files on informants in 2018.
asserted
Latvia → publish → 2018
Miklós Kiss, a survivor of a Hungarian forced labour camp and president of an association for victims, would have preferred if Hungary had followed Germany’s example and released the files earlier.
asserted
Hungary → force → files
“If that would have happened, everything would be done and dusted by now.
asserted
everything → happen → ?
“People will learn that there were traitors in every family, in every neighbourhood and street,” he added.
asserted
he → learn → neighbourhood
“But what are we supposed to do with that now?”
asserted
we → suppose → that
Placed side by side, the documents would stretch for three miles, enough to trace the perimeter of London’s Hyde Park.
asserted
documents → place → Park
Even so, the collection is small compared with that of the Polish or Romanian secret services, Papp said.
asserted
Papp → compare → services
In Hungary, many files were destroyed during the 1956 anti-Soviet uprising; others disappeared during the transition of 1989, a gradual, largely peaceful process that gave the authorities time to get rid of incriminating material.
asserted
that → destroy → material
Many of the records will be incomplete, as the agent’s motivation, or extent of reporting, will remain unknown.
asserted
motivation → remain → reporting
Of the 60,000 people mentioned in the files, the archives include detailed files, background checks and statements for only 9,000 people.
asserted
archives → mention → people
These will be released in February, after personal information, including details of health, addictions and sexuality, as well as information about victims, has been redacted in accordance with privacy laws.
asserted
information → release → laws
Alexander Faludy, a freelance journalist and Anglican priest, read the files on his family almost two decades ago.
asserted
Faludy → read → family
His grandfather, György Faludy, spent more than three years in a Hungarian labour camp on fabricated accusations, and later while in exile wrote his book, My Happy Days in Hell.
asserted
grandfather → spend → Hell
One report in the files, by a Hungarian woman living in London who befriended Faludy’s grandmother as she was dying of cancer, made him particularly angry.
asserted
him → live → cancer
“But then, I looked at the details of the informant.
asserted
I → look → informant
Suddenly, my anger evaporated.
asserted
anger → evaporate → ?
I just felt very sorry for her,” Faludy said.
asserted
Faludy → feel → her
“Exile was very painful for my family, but it also conferred certain moral luxuries.
asserted
it → confer → luxuries
And that makes me hesitant in terms of passing judgment on people for what they did if they had to stay in Hungary,” he added.
asserted
he → make → Hungary
The identities of secret-service agents have long fascinated Hungarians.
asserted
identities → fascinate → Hungarians
Since the 2000s, several partial lists have emerged, naming politicians and prominent artists.
asserted
lists → emerge → politicians
Many of them denied involvement, but the allegations alone were enough to plunge governments into political crises.
asserted
allegations → deny → crises
…and 15 more, not listed.
The Aporia
