When Tucker Carlson co-founded the Daily Caller in 2010, it was to be the Republican Party’s answer to The New York Times.
asserted
it → co → Times
A few identity crises later, the publication has followed Carlson into a hard turn against Donald Trump’s war in Iran, and against Israel — choices that have injected into the publication the digital energy of the new online right, and cost it the support of some of its backers.
asserted
that → follow → backers
“I’ve had some of the most aggressive donor pressure over this — the single most aggressive donor pressure over this, of anything I’ve seen in journalism in 20 years,” Daily Caller publisher Neil Patel told Semafor.
asserted
Patel → have → Semafor
He wouldn’t detail the cost of lost financial support to the Caller, which includes both a for-profit firm and the nonprofit Daily Caller News Foundation, but acknowledged that there had been costs.
asserted
which → detail → firm
The Caller has been a pillar of Washington’s conservative media scene since its launch, an important voice in internecine Republican conflicts and a pipeline of journalistic talent whose alumni include employees of both conservative and mainstream outlets.
asserted
alumni → include → outlets
Now it’s at the vanguard of a Republican civil war that Carlson has helped unleash.
asserted
Carlson → ’ → that
“The Iran war is a huge turning point for the conservative movement,” Editor-in-Chief Amber Duke told Semafor on Friday.
asserted
Duke → tell → Friday
Nowhere has that shift been clearer than in the outlet’s X feed since the United States went to war with Iran in February.
asserted
States → go → February
The organization has taken to tweeting the price of diesel every day, emphasizing the war’s cost on drivers, and posts screenshots of Trump’s posts about the war in Iran, adding spicy commentary.
asserted
organization → take → commentary
“What if instead of “banning” a term, we stopped spending endless amounts of money on foreign wars?” the outlet wrote of Trump’s command that AI be referred to as “super intelligence.”
asserted
AI → ban → intelligence
The Daily Caller has similarly gone after Israel, questioning its decisions in the Middle East.
asserted
Caller → go → East
It has blasted Benjamin Netanyahu and his policies, and repeatedly highlighted Israeli settler violence, particularly against children.
asserted
It → blast → children
The criticism has gotten the attention of pro-Israel hawks, who have accused the publication of antisemitism and crudely implied it is pro-Islamic propaganda.
asserted
it → get → antisemitism
“Daily Caller means Al Jazeera in Arabic,” Fox News host and commentator Mark Levin wrote.
asserted
Levin → mean → Arabic
The fissures at the Caller — and in the broader conservative movement — began widening when the activist Charlie Kirk was assassinated last September, according to most of the nine current and former Caller employees who I spoke to over the last week.
uncertain
I → widen → week
The movement that had united around Donald Trump devolved into a frenzy of unfounded conspiracy theories, many blaming Israel for Kirk’s death.
asserted
many → unite → death
The podcaster Candace Owens drove those theories, infuriating her former employer, Daily Wire founder Ben Shapiro.
asserted
podcaster → drive → employer
Shapiro laid into Owens for perpetuating what he said were antisemitic conspiracy theories, attacked podcaster Megyn Kelly for not condemning Owens, and criticized Carlson for what he described as a cozy interview with self-proclaimed white nationalist Nick Fuentes.
asserted
he → lay → Fuentes
The Daily Caller, long a younger and slightly edgier outlet than other right-leaning publications like the Washington Examiner, The National Review, or even Breitbart, followed that online energy.
asserted
Caller → lean → energy
Some on staff noted that former editor Dylan Housman left the publication the Friday before the Iran war started, and the tone shifted significantly following his departure.
asserted
tone → note → departure
Duke, a former Caller staffer, replaced him and encouraged the publication to adopt an aggressive posture on social media.
asserted
Duke → replace → media
Employees also said they sensed that Patel seemed to side with Carlson, Patel’s longtime friend and business partner.
asserted
Patel → say → Carlson
While Carlson has long been unaffiliated with the outlet, Patel retains business connections with Carlson, while Carlson’s brother Buckley Carlson has served on the Daily Caller nonprofit’s board.
asserted
brother → retain → board
Patel told Semafor he is not involved in day-to-day operations at the Caller, on which he defers to Duke and others, and stressed that Carlson’s stances had no bearing on the outlet.
asserted
stances → tell → outlet
Still, he said he encouraged the Caller’s leaders to remain independent and reflect the publication’s values.
asserted
he → say → values
That reality for average Americans, he said, has turned against Trump.
asserted
he → say → Trump
“Things just aren’t going that well today.
asserted
Things → go → ?
I think if you’re at all looking at this objectively, it’s hard to make the case that things are going great in a lot of areas.
asserted
things → think → areas
And so if our coverage has changed, I think it’s changed just to reflect that,” he said.
asserted
he → change → that
The concern, of course, is whether it could go too far.
uncertain
it → go → course
Some former Daily Caller staff told Semafor they are worried the publication has drifted a bit too close to the “groyper” wing of the right, whose criticism of Israel reflects its antisemitism.
asserted
criticism → tell → antisemitism
In October, Semafor reported that the Daily Caller tweeted a cartoon of Bill Gates and the devil posing with disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein wearing an Israeli flag Speedo.
asserted
Caller → report → flag
The post was quickly deleted, but not before it caught the attention of Republicans who have grown increasingly concerned about the Caller’s anti-Israel turn.
asserted
who → delete → turn
The publication told Semafor that while the post didn’t meet the publication’s standards, it hadn’t been posted with any “malicious intent.”
asserted
it → tell → intent
Other Caller alumni suggested to Semafor that the recent pivot could threaten what in the last decade has become an important talent pipeline and incubator for the right.
uncertain
what → suggest → right
The Daily Caller has brought up some of the most prominent young political media figures in America, some of whom have left the conservative media sphere (like CNN’s Kaitlan Collins and Semafor’s Shelby Talcott), and others who have built major franchises in independent media (like Breaking Points’ Saagar Enjeti) or moved into positions within the Republican Party apparatus.
asserted
who → bring → apparatus
Max’s view
The Daily Caller is clearly positioning itself for a landscape not just post-midterms but post- Trump, and for a bitter and intensifying intra-party media battle.
asserted
Caller → position → battle
The issue of how each side talks about Israel and the war in Iran has played out in both parties, as was clear on Sunday when Rep. Haley Stevens, the former Michigan Democrat Senate candidate, endorsed the Republican in the race over the Democratic nominee Abdul El-Sayed, citing her view that he had not done enough to condemn antisemitism.
asserted
he → talk → antisemitism
While Israel has garnered much of the attention, the Caller has taken stances against Republican Party orthodoxy on other issues.
asserted
Caller → garner → issues
The publication has published critical pieces about the impact of artificial intelligence and the coziness between business interests and the Trump administration.
asserted
publication → publish → interests
…and 11 more, not listed.
The Aporia
