In short:
A key invoice from Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate's trip to US President Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago resort has not been supplied in a freedom of information request.
asserted
invoice → supply → request
The invoice from the mayor's three day stay at the resort was taken out of the office by the mayor himself, council officers say.
asserted
officers → take → mayor
A council officer says it has "no practical ability" to obtain the receipt.
asserted
it → say → receipt
Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate's troublesome trip to US President Donald Trump's holiday retreat at Mar-a-Lago has thrown up another twist, after a key invoice could not be found within council.
uncertain
invoice → throw → council
The mayor's office has explained the absence by saying the feisty politician only brought a paper invoice about the Florida trip into the office once, then took it away with him and no-one took another copy.
asserted
one → explain → copy
The invoice is an important part in how Mr Tate had nullified conflict of interest concerns about a proposed $1.5 billion Trump Tower on Gold Coast beaches earlier this year.
asserted
Tate → nullify → beaches
He had faced an outcry after initially declaring having received free accommodation at Mar-a-Lago from the Trump Organization, while the controversial tower was proposed within council boundaries.
asserted
tower → face → boundaries
But Mr Tate later changed his declaration to say he had personally paid for accommodation during his three-day trip in February at the exclusive club based on 20 acres of landscaped gardens alongside the Atlantic Ocean.
asserted
he → change → Ocean
The politician maintained he had always intended to pay himself but an invoice "was not received promptly".
asserted
invoice → maintain → himself
"When I asked for the invoice on check out, they didn't have it," he said in September.
"
asserted
he → ask → September
I followed it up, I got the invoice, and we got it paid."
asserted
it → follow → invoice
The four-term mayor has declined to hand over the invoice and now proclaimed the trip — for which he was invited as mayor and for which ratepayers paid airfares — was "private".
asserted
ratepayers → decline → airfares
Council has twice rejected ABC right to information requests for the invoice.
asserted
Council → reject → invoice
In an internal appeal, a council officer explained no copy was found in any council systems, emails or physical records.
asserted
copy → explain → systems
The office of the mayor further advised that the mayor brought a physical copy into the office, retained it with him when he left, and that it was not printed, copied, saved or otherwise managed by the office of the mayor staff
asserted
it → advise → staff
," they wrote.
asserted
they → write → ?
They indicated they would not demand it either: "I do not believe [council] has a present legal right or practical ability to require production of that privately held copy."
Transparency International Australia chief executive Clancy Moore said that ideally some record of the invoice should be recorded for record-keeping purposes.
"Otherwise, it could be perceived as the old 'the dog ate my homework' excuse," he said.
uncertain
he → indicate → excuse
"There is clearly a lot to explain about this trip, the nature of the hospitality, the costs, and the extent that the mayor was there on official, private or personal business."
asserted
mayor → be → business
Outstanding questions include about how much the mayor was charged.
asserted
mayor → include → much
He has declined to say the amount but insisted he did not get "mate's rates".
asserted
he → decline → rates
His office issued a single line in response to questions: "The office of the mayor has fulfilled all (right to information) requirements."
asserted
office → issue → requirements
Other private information about the February trip has been released previously: Council has detailed how Mr Tate spent more than $13,000 personally upgrading flights.
asserted
Tate → release → flights
The whole trip proved controversial after the mayor initially boasted of dining with the president at Mar-a-Lago, describing an evening of tomahawk steaks and expensive wine at the club, founded by Mr Trump in 1995.
asserted
mayor → prove → 1995
But the ABC later revealed a sparsity of documentation and that the White House said the president "did not have dinner" with the mayor.
asserted
president → reveal → mayor
The Trump Organization further branded Mr Tate's account as a "complete fabrication", saying the president only briefly said hello to the mayor's table from the patio.
asserted
president → brand → patio
Mr Tate at a press conference maintained: "Recollections may vary."
uncertain
Recollections → maintain → conference
During questioning at that conference about the trip accounts and his payments, a frustrated Mr Tate eventually told a journalist to "f—k off", twice, and stormed out.
asserted
Tate → tell → journalist
The Gold Coast mayor had also said he was invited to Mar-a-Lago by the Trump Organization, and not the Queensland developer working with the organisation for the proposed $1.5 billion tower.
asserted
he → say → tower
No record of the invitation turned up in right to information requests.
asserted
record → turn → requests
The mayor's office said that was because the "invitation was issued verbally".
asserted
invitation → say → ?
The Trump Tower proposal, which had attracted almost 100,000 objection petitioners, eventually collapsed.
asserted
which → attract → petitioners
The Aporia