Soon, weed-killing chemicals will start falling from the sky over the Red Hill area of Boulder county, Colorado.
asserted
chemicals → kill → county
The wildland is known for its biodiversity, home to hundreds of important species and a concentration of rare environmental resources.
asserted
wildland → know → resources
It is a key habitat for beloved herds of elk and bighorn sheep, with farms and ranchland lying at its base.
asserted
farms → lie → base
But any day now, hundreds of acres of Red Hill are set to become the target for drone spraying of a chemical herbicide that some researchers warn come with concerns.
asserted
researchers → set → concerns
County officials say the plan is an effective and essential move that will wipe out invasive weeds and mitigate the risk of dangerous and costly wildfires that could use the unwanted vegetation as fuel.
uncertain
that → say → fuel
They tout Boulder county as “ground zero” for research and testing of indaziflam - a relatively new herbicide developed by Bayer, the German chemical and pharmaceutical conglomerate, that has been approved for use across millions of acres of public lands as a tool for preserving native ecosystems.
asserted
that → tout → ecosystems
But the drone spray project has prompted an outcry from many people living and working in the area as some scientists say the chemical comes with serious risks for vulnerable species and poses health dangers for people and animals, including through water that runs off the steep slope into rivers and creeks and into groundwater supplies for crop irrigation, though the chemical’s manufacturer denies that it is unsafe.
asserted
it → prompt → irrigation
In June, two University of Colorado researchers added fuel to the community concerns, publishing a journal article highlighting risks to ecological and human health from indaziflam spraying and arguing that the cheatgrass issues cited as a basis for spraying are overblown.
asserted
issues → add → spraying
They cited prior published studies that raise concerns about genotoxicity and neurotoxicity.
asserted
that → cite → genotoxicity
“It really directly affects all residents downstream from this,” said Azuraye Wycoff, owner of Yellow Barn Farm, a regenerative agricultural operation tending to crops, sheep, pigs and other livestock located at the base of Red Hill.
asserted
Wycoff → affect → Hill
“There are a lot of people in our community who are really livid about it.”
asserted
who → be → it
Opponents fear the work could start this month.
uncertain
work → fear → ?
Adding to the worries is evidence that the indaziflam product to be used, sold under the brand name Rejuvra, contains per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (Pfas), a class of chemicals linked to a range of health risks and known to persist in the environment.
asserted
product → add → environment
Spraying over Red Hill was supposed to start last year but county officials paused the plan in the face of a backlash from community residents.
asserted
officials → spray → residents
The county plan includes mitigation measures aimed at protecting people and protected species, such as no-spray buffer zones around residential properties and measures to reduce chemical drift.
asserted
plan → include → drift
But critics are not mollified.
asserted
critics → mollify → ?
They say particularly in a place like Boulder county, which boasts of its commitment to environmental health and sustainability, non-chemical measures should be pursued.
asserted
measures → say → health
Overall, the county plan encompasses more than 2,000 acres (810 hectares) and extends beyond Red Hill.
asserted
plan → encompass → Hill
A group of local environmental advocates sued in 2024 to challenge the county’s broad plans.
asserted
group → sue → plans
They alleged, among other things, that the drone spraying of terrain adjacent to homes, organic farms, trails and water features violated Fifra, a federal pesticide law, by contradicting labeling prohibitions of applications that will contact persons “directly or through drift”.
asserted
that → allege → drift
But in a 9 October ruling, a district court judge ruled against the plaintiffs, dismissing their claims.
uncertain
judge → rule → claims
Now, with the drone spray plan for Red Hill revived, community members are scrambling to see whether they can find another way to delay the plan.
asserted
they → revive → plan
Opponents are pushing a “Delay the Spray” call for action to mobilize residents to contact the county.
asserted
residents → push → county
And two conservation groups have filed a notice of intent to bring a new lawsuit against Boulder county officials, this one alleging violations of the federal Endangered Species Act.
asserted
groups → file → Act
Even some Boulder City officials have questioned the wisdom of the spray strategy after recently completing a series of multiyear studies about the effects indaziflam could have on the area.
uncertain
indaziflam → question → area
The city’s report warns of “regulatory testing that shows potentially serious health impacts to people and wildlife, and high toxicity to invertebrates”.
asserted
that → warn → invertebrates
The report cites published research showing indaziflam can have genotoxic effects, or effects on the genes and chromosomes, and notes that the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has identified concerns with the chemical as well.
asserted
Agency → cite → chemical
In a 2010 report, the EPA said indaziflam was “highly toxic” to fish, for instance.
asserted
indaziflam → say → instance
The agency also reported neurotoxicity seen in animal studies as well as effects on the liver, stomach and reproductive organs.
asserted
agency → report → liver
The city’s study findings also highlight particular concerns about the unintended consequences that spraying indaziflam could have on the viability of native seeds.
uncertain
spraying → highlight → seeds
Survival of native plants is critical to ecological balance, and indaziflam, which the city study found persists in the soil for years, could threaten that balance.
uncertain
study → find → balance
“Indaziflam is very effective at killing all seeds, with just a few minor exceptions,” said Brett KenCairn, a senior policy adviser for the city of Boulder on “climate and resilience”.
asserted
KenCairn → kill → climate
KenCairn declined to offer an opinion on the county’s spray plan but said that, in the aftermath of wildfires, “we are desperately going to need that Indigenous seed bank”.
asserted
we → decline → bank
The city shared its report with Boulder county officials in September, but the county remains undeterred.
asserted
county → share → September
Protecting Boulder county’s “extraordinary” biodiversity and environmental health is at the core of the county’s approach to weed management, said a Boulder county spokesperson.
asserted
spokesperson → protect → management
The chemicals used in the spray plan “are specifically designed to target plant biology and have minimal impact on mammals”, including people, the spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → use → people
Drones are needed because of the rugged terrain that is “unsuitable” for other methods, she said.
asserted
she → need → methods
Bayer did not respond to a request for comment.
asserted
Bayer → respond → comment
The company sold its indaziflam product Rejuvra in 2022 as part of an asset divestiture that led to the formation of a new company called Envu.
asserted
that → sell → company
Envu, which now sells Rejuvra, said a wider base of evidence supports the safety and efficacy of the product.
asserted
base → sell → product
…and 13 more, not listed.
The Aporia
