On Friday, Andy Yen, the CEO of Proton, cancelled a series of nearly company-wide ‘re-interviews’ that would have forced employees to explain how they are using AI, with the clear intention that they may be fired if not using it enough in the eyes of Proton leadership, according to six current Proton employees and audio of an around two hour all-hands meeting obtained by 404 Media.
uncertain
they → cancel → Media
The move came after 404 Media published an investigation on Thursday, which showed how Yen was aggressively pushing AI across Proton, in some cases despite security concerns from employees.
asserted
Yen → come → employees
In one exchange, an employee in the company’s security Slack channel urged Proton to at least take a few days to pentest newly written code before pushing it live.
asserted
employee → urge → it
“That’s bullshit and loser thinking.
asserted
That → ’ → ?
Of course it’s possible to be fast and secure,” Yen wrote in the channel at the end of August.
asserted
Yen → ’ → August
Yen added, “stop lovingly handcrafting all our code and use AI more.”
asserted
Yen → add → AI
The re-interview cancellations likely don’t address the concerns of many Proton users, who are more focused on Proton’s deprioritization of security; many Proton users have blasted the company’s leadership on social media over the last 24 hours and explicitly called for Yen to resign.
The investigation was based on conversations with eight current and one former Proton employees, Slack chats, meeting audio, and an AI manifesto written by the company’s CTO Bart Butler.
asserted
investigation → address → CTO
It painted a picture of Proton that is very different to the public’s perception of a company carefully protecting privacy.
asserted
that → paint → privacy
Instead, Proton is barreling ahead with AI in large part to achieve more annual revenue.
asserted
Proton → barrel → revenue
The investigation also found a culture of fear across Proton, where employees have genuine concerns about security or being asked to develop security-focused products with AI, but feel unable to voice them because Yen mocks or insults employees in front of everyone else.
asserted
Yen → find → everyone
“I don’t think he will change anything, and I think the only reason we had this meeting is because he has a rebellion on his hands,” one employee told 404 Media after the all-hands meeting on Friday.
asserted
employee → think → Friday
Near the start of the meeting, Yen said, “I want to acknowledge myself, personally, that there was a communication failure on my part and there are many things that probably could and should have been communicated differently, and this is something that I’ll have to reflect on and improve over time.
uncertain
I → say → time
So I will do that.”
asserted
I → do → that
“So what does that mean going forward?
asserted
that → mean → what
Going forward, I'm still going to push,” he added.
asserted
he → go → ?
Yen said leadership gathered in the last couple of days to talk about the re-interviews, and spoke to the Proton board too.
asserted
leadership → say → board
“They’re closely monitoring the situation,” Yen said.
asserted
Yen → monitor → situation
(Proton is owned by the Proton Foundation, whose board of trustees includes Yen, Sir Tim Berners Lee, Prof. Carissa Veliz, Dingchao Lu, and Antonio Gambardella.)
asserted
board → own → Yen
After those discussions with leadership and the board, “We’ve decided to actually cancel the re-interviews,” Yen said.
asserted
Yen → decide → interviews
Well, I think actually in a, let’s say, unintentional way, they have actually already served their purpose.”
asserted
they → think → purpose
As in, employees are now talking and learning about AI.
asserted
employees → talk → AI
Yen also mentioned “org changes,” and said that part of this is “redistributing talent across teams.”
asserted
part → mention → teams
He said that the reorganization will happen next month, “but there will be no loss of jobs from AI.”
asserted
reorganization → say → AI
Later in the call, Butler said Yen “needs to, and he has committed to, doing better” regarding how he communicates with his employees.
asserted
he → say → employees
“Using AI effectively and pragmatically does not mean that we’ve given up on security, or good architecture, or sound software engineering principles,” he added.
asserted
he → use → security
“We fucked up, we know we fucked up,” Butler later said in response to an employee’s comments in the meeting.
asserted
Butler → fuck → meeting
“Your old job is gone,” Butler’s AI manifesto, posted to Slack, told engineers, 404 Media reported on Thursday.
asserted
Media → go → Thursday
He wrote that not embracing AI posed an “existential threat to the success of the mission itself.”
asserted
embracing → write → mission
Reactions to the re-interview cancellations were split across the Proton employees 404 Media spoke to.
asserted
Media → split → employees
One said, “Some are happy as it’s progress.
asserted
it → say → ?
Others believe that this won’t change anything because there isn’t any consequence for Andy [Yen].”
asserted
this → believe → Andy
The employee added they “would have preferred real accountability from the leadership team.”
asserted
they → add → team
They said they felt not much could have happened due to Yen having the majority of Proton’s shares.
uncertain
Yen → say → shares
Another employee said, after Proton canceled the re-interviews, “They said in the next breath they want to continue pushing AI and that the things that were to be measured in the re-interviews would become a component of the performance reviews.”
asserted
that → say → reviews
“They have said clearly the direction had not changed.
asserted
direction → say → ?
As a Proton user that doesn’t reassure me,” the employee said.
asserted
employee → reassure → me
“As an employee, the re-interviews weren’t cancelled until this became public despite concerns raised by many of us.
asserted
this → cancel → us
I think it goes beyond communication issues and growing pains.”
asserted
it → think → issues
“Right now, everything seems consistent with it being damage control,” they said.
asserted
they → seem → ?
Another employee said they were “mostly happy with how this was addressed including by Andy [Yen].”
asserted
this → say → Yen
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
