In 1996, Carl Rice attended an Arizona estate sale, spotted two framed oil paintings priced at $30 each, and paid the $60 asking price without expecting anything extraordinary.
asserted
Rice → attend → anything
He liked the subject matter of one painting and the frame of the other, but assumed that paintings sold so cheaply by a professionally managed estate could not be original works by a major artist.
uncertain
paintings → like → artist
That assumption proved spectacularly wrong.
asserted
assumption → prove → ?
The paintings were later authenticated as works by Martin Johnson Heade, a celebrated 19th century American painter, and sold at Christie’s for a combined $1.072 million.
asserted
paintings → authenticate → million
The story did not end with the auction.
asserted
story → end → auction
Martha Nelson’s estate, whose personal representatives had organised the sale, later sued Rice and his wife Anne in an effort to undo the transaction.
asserted
representatives → organise → transaction
The estate argued that both sides had made a mutual mistake about the paintings’ value and that enforcing the sale would be unconscionable.
asserted
enforcing → argue → sale
But the Arizona Court of Appeals disagreed, affirming the lower court’s decision and leaving the Rices with the proceeds.
asserted
Court → disagree → proceeds
The case remains a striking example of how estate sales can hide extraordinary value, and of how the law treats a bargain made in good faith.
asserted
law → remain → faith
A $60 purchase at an estate sale
According to Justia U.S. Law, After Martha Nelson died in February 1996, her estate’s personal representatives, Kenneth Newman and Edward Franz, hired Judith McKenzie-Larson to appraise the personal property before an estate sale.
uncertain
representatives → accord → sale
McKenzie-Larson told them that she did not appraise fine art and that they would need another appraiser if any fine art were found.
asserted
art → tell → appraiser
She did not report finding any, and relying on her appraisal, the representatives priced and sold the estate’s belongings.
asserted
representatives → report → belongings
Carl Rice responded to a newspaper advertisement and attended the public sale.
asserted
Rice → respond → sale
He paid the estate’s asking price of $60 for two oil paintings.
asserted
He → pay → paintings
Although he had bought and sold some art before, he was not a trained or sophisticated collector.
asserted
he → buy → art
Court records note that he had never made more than $55 on a single piece and had previously purchased works that turned out to be frauds, forgeries, or pieces by lesser known artists.
asserted
that → note → artists
Rice later said he assumed the paintings were not originals because of the low price and because the estate appeared to be professionally managed.
asserted
estate → say → price
Still, something about them caught his attention.
asserted
something → catch → attention
He was drawn to the subject of one painting and the frame of the other, and after bringing them home he compared the signatures with examples in a book of artists’ signatures.
asserted
he → draw → signatures
The signatures appeared similar to that of Martin Johnson Heade.
asserted
signatures → appear → Heade
The discovery that changed everything
Following their usual practice, the Rices sent photographs of the paintings to Christie’s in New York to see whether they might be Heade’s work.
uncertain
they → change → York
Christie’s authenticated both paintings, Magnolia Blossoms on Blue Velvet and Cherokee Roses, as genuine works by Heade.
asserted
Christie → authenticate → Heade
The auction house then offered to sell them on consignment.
asserted
house → offer → consignment
Christie’s later sold the paintings at auction for $1,072,000.
asserted
Christie → sell → 1,072,000
After deducting the buyer’s premium and commission, the Rices received $911,780.
asserted
Rices → deduct → 911,780
They paid $337,000 in income taxes on the profit in 1997, bought a home, created a family trust, and used part of the money for living expenses.
asserted
They → pay → expenses
What had begun as an ordinary $60 estate sale purchase had become a life changing windfall, as per Justia U.S. Law.
asserted
begun → begin → Law
Magnolia Blossoms on Blue Velvet is an oil on canvas measuring 15 by 24 inches and signed “M.J. Heade” in the lower right.
asserted
Blossoms → measure → right
Christie’s records trace its ownership through the Sleeth family of Belleville, New Jersey and Tucson, Arizona, before it passed by bequest to Robert G. Nelson and then to Martha Campbell Nelson, whose estate sold it.
asserted
estate → trace → it
The auction house describes it as one of Heade’s extraordinary floral still lifes, painted around 1890 after the artist moved to St. Augustine, Florida.
asserted
artist → describe → Augustine
The estate went to court
Representative image
asserted
estate → go → image
The estate’s representatives learned of the sale in February 1997.
asserted
representatives → learn → February
They first sued McKenzie-Larson, believing she was responsible for the loss, but settled that case after discovering she had no assets with which to pay damages.
asserted
she → sue → damages
In late January 1998, the estate sued the Rices, seeking to rescind or reform the sale on the grounds of mutual mistake and unconscionability.
asserted
estate → sue → mistake
The estate argued that neither party knew the transaction involved fine art.
asserted
transaction → argue → art
It claimed both sides believed they were dealing with relatively valueless wall decorations rather than valuable paintings.
asserted
they → claim → paintings
The Rices responded that the estate bore the risk of any mistake, that the doctrine of laches prevented reformation of the contract, and that unconscionability was not a proper basis for rescinding the sale.
asserted
unconscionability → respond → sale
The trial court found that although both parties had been mistaken about the paintings’ value, the estate bore the risk of that mistake.
asserted
estate → find → mistake
It also found that the contract was not unconscionable because the parties had not negotiated the price.
asserted
parties → find → price
The estate had set the price, and Rice had simply paid it.
asserted
Rice → set → it
…and 18 more, not listed.
The Aporia
