Backlash over John Healey's Budget intensified yesterday following claims he was facing an £11billion 'black hole' in his defence spending plans.
uncertain
he → intensify → plans
The Chancellor vowed to spend 3 per cent of GDP on defence by 2030 – when ministers fear Russia could attack Europe – and to hit a Nato target of 3.5 per cent by 2035.
uncertain
Russia → vow → 2035
But the former defence secretary refused to say how he would fulfil either promise until next year, fuelling accusations he was stalling for time and had no concrete plan.
asserted
he → refuse → plan
The head of the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said Labour would need to find £11billion extra to hit the 2030 goal, while the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) said the 2035 ambition would cost £35billion.
asserted
ambition → say → 35billion
'On defence, John Healey confirmed 2030 as a target date to get spending to 3 per cent of GDP, but I'm still no wiser as to how he plans to get there, let alone to 3.5 per cent by 2035,' said Helen Miller, the IFS's director.
asserted
Miller → confirm → 2035
The Government is currently spending around 2.6 per cent of GDP on defence and had previously committed to spending 2.7 per cent by 2030 before Mr Healey announced his uplift on Wednesday.
asserted
Healey → spend → Wednesday
Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer, John Healey, holds up the traditional red ministerial box outside No 11 Downing Street before departing to the House of Commons to deliver the first budget under Prime Minister Andy Burnham's government on October 28
Pictured:
asserted
Chancellor → hold → October
Royal Marine Commandos line up to storm a compound during a live exercise demonstration at Bovington Camp in Dorset
asserted
Commandos → line → Dorset
But in a further blow, Ms Miller said she was unsure about Labour's commitment to finding the spending increases.
asserted
she → say → increases
'I'm also sceptical because I didn't hear John Healey starting the kind of pitch-rolling that you would expect if he intended to deliver these spending plans.
asserted
he → hear → plans
And I'm sceptical because history advises scepticism,' she added.
asserted
she → advise → scepticism
'When Chancellors pencil in tight spending plans in the future, they tend not to deliver.
asserted
they → pencil → future
Mr Healey was unrepentant over his maiden Budget, spending much of yesterday morning furiously defending it.
asserted
Healey → spend → it
'I make absolutely no apologies.
asserted
I → make → apologies
If we can take some steps that might help around the margins, we will do that,' Mr Healey told the BBC.
uncertain
Healey → take → BBC
But in an extraordinary broadside, Admiral Lord West, a Labour peer, accused the Chancellor of 'betraying' the Armed Forces by stalling on his spending plans.
asserted
West → accuse → plans
'He has kicked this into the long grass and has let us down on defence,' the retired Royal Navy boss told the Daily Mail.
asserted
boss → kick → Mail
'Healey stabbed Sir Keir Starmer in the back and got a nice job [as Chancellor] and now he is quite happy not to push defence … it's outrageous.
asserted
it → stab → defence
His intervention came just days after Wes Streeting, the Defence Secretary, warned the nation had 1,000 days to prepare for war.
asserted
nation → come → war
Mr Healey dramatically quit as defence secretary in June after Sir Keir tried to force him into accepting less cash for the military.
asserted
Keir → quit → military
In a blistering resignation letter, he accused the former prime minister of being 'unable' to stump up the money needed.
asserted
he → accuse → money
He also suggested spending 3 per cent on defence was a 'must' and that failing to do so put the country at risk.
uncertain
failing → suggest → risk
But James Cartlidge, the shadow defence secretary, criticised the Chancellor, telling the Daily Mail: 'In the Budget he completely failed to deliver on his own red line – leaving himself a massive black hole in defence spending … this will surely be another broken promise from Labour at a time when the threats are only growing.'
asserted
threats → criticise → time
An IFS official warned punishing cuts would need to be made by the Government to achieve the Chancellor's spending ambition.
asserted
cuts → warn → ambition
'The pain is going to come from somewhere – £11billion is a massive amount to make up,' they said.
asserted
they → go → ?
Ms Miller added she was 'grumpy' over Mr Healey's plan to raid capital reserves to fund the £4.7billion hole in the Defence Investment Plan (DIP), left over by Starmer's government.
asserted
she → add → government
'Much of it came from further cuts to the capital budgets of other government departments...
asserted
Much → come → departments
This is categorically not what the reserves are for,' she said.
asserted
she → say → what
The Daily Mail is campaigning for significantly increased spending on our Armed Forces.
asserted
Mail → campaign → Forces
During a debate on the Budget yesterday, Tory shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith accused Mr Healey of 'ducking' a decision on military spending which he said would make the country 'less secure'.
asserted
country → accuse → spending
'Britain is walking along a fiscal cliff edge, and the Government has decided this is the moment to close their eyes,' Mr Griffith told MPs.
asserted
Griffith → walk → MPs
Humiliation for Healey: Chancellor is forced into screeching U-turn just hours after promising to cut welfare bill before next election
-
asserted
Chancellor → force → election
READ MORE: Landlords warn Budget tax rise will force them to raise rents
-
asserted
rise → read → rents
Budget watchdog's worst case scenario for oil 'has already been reached'
asserted
scenario → reach → oil
The Aporia
